milblog1archives.jpg
PDA
Shop
Contact
YouTube Videos
To Mudville
Join MilBlogs
Someone You Should Know
MilBlogs


milblogsa1.jpg
Prev | List | Random | Next
Join
Powered by RingSurf!

Authors



























Ground Support

SoA_proudsupporter.gif

soldiersangels.jpg

AnySoldierLogo.jpg

topmain.jpg

books_for_soldiers.gif

foundation_heroesfund02.jpg

fallen pats.jpg

fisherhouse.jpg

hopevil.jpg

opac.jpg

Adopt a platoon.jpg

Homes for our troops.jpg

WWproject.jpg

heromiles200.jpg

operation morale.jpg

cbrdg.jpg

op-give.jpg

mamo.jpg

Sponsors

Archives
November 2008

S
M
T
W
T
F
S
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30

Monthly Archives []


Feed me:

Sponsors

Roll Call

MBC2008sidebanner1z.jpg

MilBlog Ring Members
Random 20 Blogroll
[]

Angels / Supporting
our Troops Blogroll
[]

Friends of MilBlogs
Random 20 Blogroll
[]

The Fine Print

The Milblogs site has multiple authors. Unless otherwise credited, the opinions expressed are those of the specific author, and not the official position of any other contributor or any organization to which they belong, to include the United States Department of Defense or any of its subordinate components.

Comments and e-mails are welcome, but all such communication is to be assumed to be 1) the original work of any who initiate said communication and 2) in the public domain, with free use granted for publication in electronic or written form. If you do NOT wish to have your message posted, write "CONFIDENTIAL" in the subject line of your email.

Original content copyright © 2006 - 2008 by the respective authors. Fair, not-for-profit use of said material by others is encouraged, as long as acknowledgement and credit is given, to include the url of the original source post. Other arrangements can be made as needed.

Site contact: greyhawk at mudvillegazette dot com

« August 2008 | Main | October 2008 »

September 29, 2008

Children in Battle?

[Greyhawk]

John S. D. Eisenhower: "Presidential Children Don’t Belong in Battle"

As the only living presidential son to serve in combat while his father was in office, I feel an obligation to express my concern that both of the current vice presidential candidates, Gov. Sarah Palin and Senator Joseph Biden, have sons in Army units on orders for duty in Iraq. In addition, the Republican presidential candidate, John McCain, has a son who is in the Marine Corps and subject to a second deployment to Iraq at any time.

Considering how small the force we have in Iraq is in comparison to the nation’s population, this is a startling circumstance. It is not, however, a desirable one. It reflects favorably on the patriotism of those involved, but in itself it can hardly increase the military understanding, the grasp on foreign relations or (least of all) the perspective of the parents.

My unique position in this regard was called to my attention a few days ago in a radio interview. Did I believe that the children of presidents (or vice presidents) should be assigned to combat zones? I was surprised by my own quick reaction:

“No,” I declared automatically. “They have no place there.”

Though my response was impulsive, I have, on thinking about it, concluded that it was the right one.

Was it?

Personally I think we should put an age limit on military service - say, 18 years old - to ensure that no children are ever sent to battle. As I understand the author, who spent part of his childhood as a major in the Korean war (presumably commanding younger, less experienced children), this exemption should only apply to candidates.

For those who think that's too exclusionary: I suppose I could be convinced that some children could serve in non-combat roles - say, at the Pentagon or staff positions at lower levels - if they're exceptionally bright. But I'd have to hear a strong argument supporting that position.


Posted at 1250Z | Comments (10)

Somali Pirates: The Ship Full of Tanks Is Under U.S. Navy Eyes

[Eagle1]

RORO.jpg

Maybe you've heard the story about the Ukrainian owned, Belize-flagged Roll On-Roll Off ship with 33 Russian made T-72 tanks and other weapons and ammo that a group of Somali pirates has nabbed and is holding off the coast of Somalia...

Well, the U.S. destroyer USS Howard is keeping a close eye on it.

Details here with more Navy photos.


Posted at 0020Z

September 28, 2008

Fighting Pirates Way Back When

[Eagle1]

No, not the Barbary pirates.

Malay pirate proa.jpg

Those guys on the other side of the globe.

It was perhaps the first U.S. military intervention in Asia. Andy Jackson was involved.

As explained here.


Posted at 2247Z

VA to Raise Traumatic Brain Injury Benefits

[Soldier's Mom]
VA to Raise Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) Benefits

The Dept. of Veterans Affairs announced last week changes to its schedule for rating disabilities for Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), the "signature wound" of Iraq and Afghanistan.

A VA press release noted, "Traumatic brain injuries result in immediate effects such as loss or alteration of consciousness, amnesia and sometimes neurological impairments." In some cases "prolonged or even permanent problems with a wide range of impairment in such areas as physical, mental and emotional/behavioral functioning may occur." People with TBI may experience headache, sleep difficulties, decreased memory and attention, slower thinking, irritability, and depression.


Posted at 2242Z

FY09 Defense Authorization Act

[Soldier's Mom]

Among other things, the FY09 Defense Authorization Act Authorizes military/vets not in uniform to salute flag during national anthem.

A summary (courtesy of MOAA) of some of the other provisions of FY09DAA over at Some Soldier's Mom


Posted at 2116Z

Bracelets

[Greyhawk]

Presidential politics is trivial compared to losing a child - no matter how old that child may be. I hope this doesn't turn ugly for a military family.


Posted at 2026Z

September 27, 2008

Re: Stars and Stripes

[John Noonan]

At least the Army is drafting guidelines. The Air Force's approach is to simply ban blogs all together.

Leadership!

My old 'Rat' roommate from VMI is a staff writer for the Air Force Times. He said -and I'm paraphrasing a bit here- that Air Force public affair types are the most frustrating people in the world to deal with. Simple clarification questions have to be shot up to the civilian head of each department/unit, and they are horribly inept at dealing with any media rep in general.

His example was the Air Force's recent loss of the Joint Cargo Aircraft. Pointing out that the Air Force had a legitimate need to equip a couple of guard units with the new airframe, my buddy said that their complete inability to 'get their story out' resulted in Congress funding the plane for the Army only. Now there's a bunch of pissed of Guardsman who were told that they'd have a flying mission, but now have no planes.

Where's that picture again Greyhawk???


Posted at 2131Z

Re: Stars and Stripes

[Greyhawk]

I don't remember seeing a flag there.


Posted at 2115Z

Was the Stars & Stripes at the MilBlog Conference?

[Mrs Greyhawk]

Army drafting new blogging guidelines

The Army is working on a set of guidelines for soldiers’ conduct in online forums such as blogs and message boards, but it might be a while before the message reaches the troops.

The guidelines — a compilation of the scattered rules and regulations governing online activity by soldiers — will be included in a rewrite of Army public affairs regulations to be published in the next six months to two years, Department of the Army public affairs specialist Lindy Kyzer said in an e-mail. Soldiers will be told about the guidelines during pre-deployment public affairs training, she said.

But that doesn’t mean soldiers can blog with impunity until the new guidelines are published.

Operational security rules, which prohibit the publication by soldiers of classified or sensitive information, and the Uniform Code of Military Justice, already limit what soldiers can do online, Kyzer said.

"What the new public affairs guidance … will provide is further clarification of what is acceptable in online postings or digital communication," she said.

The new guidelines do not cancel existing regulations but instead supplement them, she said.


Posted at 2107Z

Re: USAF Baby

[John Noonan]

Ditto ditto ditt-effin'-o. I figured that we were done with this asinine uniform bingo when Schwartz took over. Shows what I know.

But -- in fairness-- the obsessive fetish with legacy-by-uniform-changes seems to have been put on hold, for now.

It could just be that the Air Force is entering an era that, in part, will be defined by what will not be a hot-button issue: uniforms.

"First things first," Air Force Chief of Staff Gen. Norton Schwartz responded Sept. 17 when asked by Military.com whether uniforms -- new ones or modifications to current dress -- will be relegated to the back burner during his tenure.



Posted at 2103Z

In Memory of...

[Mrs Greyhawk]

Screen legend Paul Newman loses his battle with cancer. He was a class act, I was a big fan, and he will be missed.

Mr. Newman was political but he was not a hack, he put his money where his mouth was.

“This is not about celebrity, this is a political issue,” he said about giving through Newman’s Own. “The concept that a person who has a lot holds his hand out to someone who has less is still a human trait.
<...>
Newman has given money to various children’s charities and health centres, to a group that helps the homeless become self-reliant, to refugee groups, to humane societies and animal hospitals and to all manner of educational outlets. He co-sponsors the PEN/Newman’s Own First Amendment Award, a $25,000 reward designed to recognize those who protect the U,S. First Amendment as it applies to the written word.

What you may not know about Paul Newman. He was decorated with the American Area Campaign Medal, the Good Conduct Medal, and the World War II Victory Medal:

Paul Leonard Newman enlisted in the U.S. Navy on 22 January 1943, after his graduation from Shaker Heights High School in Cleveland, Ohio. The second son of a thriving sporting-goods storekeeper (Arthur, his brother, eventually became a film production manager), Paul (born 1925) had acted in a few school productions but had never considered making a profession of show business. He attended Ohio University in Athens while he waited to hear from the Navy, and during his months there he had time to perform in another school production, The Milky Way, in which he played a boxer.

Newman was sent to the Navy V-12 program at Yale, with hopes of being accepted for pilot training. But this plan was foiled when a flight physical revealed him to be color-blind. So he was sent instead to boot camp and then on to further training as a radioman and gunner.

Qualifying as a rear-seat radioman and gunner in torpedo bombers, in 1944 Aviation Radioman Third Class Newman was sent to Barber's Point, Hawaii, and subsequently assigned to Pacific-based replacement torpedo squadrons (VT-98, VT-99, and VT-100). These torpedo squadrons were responsible primarily for training replacement pilots and combat aircrewmen, placing particular importance on carrier landings.

During his two years in the Pacific the Newman luck held, especially on one occasion when his pilot fell ill and their aircraft was grounded. The rest of the squadron was transferred to an aircraft carrier operating off the coast of Japan, where a kamikaze hit the carrier, inflicting heavy casualties on the men and aircraft of Newman's squadron.

While he was with VT-99, training personnel in TBM-1Cs, TBM-3s, and TBF-1cs, the squadron moved to Eniwetok, then to Guam, and in January 1945 on to Saipan. This remained its base of operations until its decommissioning nine months later. A VT-99 contingent including Newman was aboard the aircraft carrier Hollandia (CVE-97), which was operating about five hundred miles off Japan when the Enola Gay dropped its atomic bomb on Hiroshima.

newman_paula.bmp

Finally, Paul Newman served with Carrier Aircraft Service Unit 7, one of many shore-based carrier air-group support units. CASUs operated the facilities, serviced and rearmed, made repairs, and handled routine upkeep and administrative duties. Newman's CASU was based in Seattle, conveniently located for his discharge at Bremerton, Washington State, on 21 January 1946. He was decorated with the American Area Campaign Medal, the Good Conduct Medal, and the World War II Victory Medal.

Kinda of funny how this part of his career isn't mention in the media.

He was also a supporter of our Military.

OI-Paul-Newman-award_big.jpg



Posted at 1956Z | Comments (1)

September 26, 2008

Re: USAF Baby

[Greyhawk]

Won't I ever get tired of it?

mike02.jpg

Nope, don't think so...

Air Force Chief of Staff Gen. Norton Schwartz is requiring most airmen to wear their blue uniforms every Monday beginning Sept. 8, according to a Sept. 4 memo he sent to all service members.
<...>
The current practice of airmen wearing ABUs and BDUs almost all the time originated under Gen. John Jumper, the chief of staff at the time of the 2001 terrorist attacks. Then, in summer 2003, Jumper directed that airmen begin to return to blues as the uniform of the day. But Gen. T. Michael Moseley reversed that decision when he became chief of staff in late 2005, arguing that the nation was still at war and that airmen should dress like it.

He said at the time that his decision was closely related to his effort to instill a “war-fighting ethos” in Air Force culture, one of his main priorities as chief.

The nation is at war, the Air Force is at the Mall, shopping for spiffy new uniforms.


Posted at 2249Z | Comments (3)

RE: White Flag

[Greyhawk]

In short: "Senator Obama, withdraw your troop withdrawal".

Interesting - coming on the day of the foreign policy/national security debate.

Not to be a complete wet blanket, but lest anyone get their hopes up I would note that the simple presence of a large number of US forces on the ground doesn't automatically promote political reconciliation or facilitate a functioning government without some willing cooperation (or "buy-in") by key players. Basically, the local elected officials have to want to make progress before progress can be made. Case in point: the United States. I'm not sure the US Government can reach Iraq-level results this weekend, but I am certain beyond any doubt there is no military solution to the problem.


Posted at 2239Z

Air Force Baby

[Mrs Greyhawk]

LUV IT!


Posted at 1907Z | Comments (1)

Gold Star Mother's Day, 28 Sep 08

[Soldier's Mom]
THE WHITE HOUSE

Gold Star Mother's Day, 2008

by the President of the United States of America, A Proclamation

Throughout our history, the men and women of the Armed Forces have put our Nation's security before their own, doing their duty in the face of grave danger.

On Gold Star Mother's Day, we pay solemn tribute to the mothers of the patriots lost serving this great Nation.

Gold Star Mothers inspire our Nation with their deep devotion to family and country. These extraordinary women serve their communities, dedicate their time to helping members of our Armed Forces and veterans, and bring comfort and hope to families whose loved ones laid down their lives in the defense of our liberty. Nothing can compensate for their sacrifice and loss, yet Gold Star Mothers demonstrate tremendous courage and resolve while working to preserve the memory and legacy of all our fallen heroes.


Posted at 1744Z

Washington Post waves white flag

[CDR Salamander]

Asks Sen. Obama (D-IL) to do the same.

Democrat Barack Obama continues to argue that only the systematic withdrawal of U.S. combat units will force Iraqi leaders to compromise. Yet the empirical evidence of the past year suggests the opposite: that only the greater security produced and guaranteed by American troops allows a political environment in which legislative deals and free elections are feasible.
I'll would accept their surrender to the pro-victory team; but I would rather they give it to Gen. Petraeus or Gen. Mattis.

Senator; over to you.


Posted at 1636Z

Why US Soldiers Should Be Sent to Gulags

[LT Nixon]

There's a very detailed and very creepy description of how returning veterans should be rounded up into gulags to be "re-educated" in the comments section of an AZ Central article on the Natl Guard. The super-secret and anonymous "Code Monkey" sent me the details. People often talk about the poor treatment of Vietnam vets being a big myth...good thing the internet is around today to document all the nonsense out there today.

C.H.U.D. Busters


Posted at 0644Z | Comments (1)

Exonerated Marine vs Ex Marine

[Greyhawk]
One of the Marines cleared in the killings of Iraqi civilians in the town of Haditha plans to sue his congressman today for statements he says defamed him and other members of his squad.

Former Marine Lance Cpl. Justin Sharratt, 24, of Canonsburg, will file a civil lawsuit against U.S. Rep. John P. Murtha, D-Johnstown, who was widely quoted two years ago saying that eight Marines carried out a cold-blooded killing of 24 civilians in the Iraqi town on Nov. 19, 2005.

Charges were later dropped against all but one of the Marines, with a military prosecutor calling allegations against Mr. Sharratt "incredible."

More here, including a review (based on Bing West's and Bob Woodward's newly published accounts) of Murtha '06, some classic video, and a look at his opponent ("A man who is himself a decorated Iraq war veteran. A man who was in the Pentagon on September 11, 2001. A man who has spent nearly 3 decades serving his country in uniform. Lt. Col. William Russell (USAR ret.)") this November.


Posted at 0119Z

asiadomainnameregistrar scam

[Greyhawk]

Via email:


Posted at 0104Z | Comments (1)

September 24, 2008

There be pirates

[Eagle1]

Pirate news good: Navy oiler shoots at some.

Pirate news bad: The Danes let some go.

Shoot straight, me lads, shoot straight.

800px-USNS_John_Lenthall_T-AO-189.jpg


Posted at 1930Z

2008 Milblogs Conference Pics: Around the Room

[Greyhawk]
more1.jpg

more2.jpg

Posted at 1431Z | Comments (2)

2008 Milblogs Conference Pics: THE NEW CADRE OF WAR REPORTERS

[Greyhawk]
anewcadre2.jpg

Panel: Christian Lowe (DefenseTech), Toby Nunn (Toby Nunn's Briefing Room), Troy Steward (Bouhammer), J.P. Borda (Milblogging.com)

Moderator: J. R. Michael (Mudville Gazette/MilBlogs)



Posted at 1400Z

2008 Milblogs Conference Pics: LIVE DOD BLOGGERS ROUNDTABLE

[Greyhawk]
dod roundtable.jpg

Hosted by: Jack Holt, Office of the Secretary of Defense

Moderators: Ward Carroll (Military.com) and John Donovan (Castle ARGGHHH!)

Appearances (Via Phone) by:

Geren.jpgbergner.jpg

The hon. Pete Geren, Secretary of the U.S. Army and Major General Kevin Bergner, Chief of Public Affairs, U.S. Army


Posted at 1318Z

2008 Milblogs Conference Pics: Are MilBlogs Still Relevant?

[Greyhawk]

Yes, is my answer.

are mb still relevant 7.jpg

Panel: Matt Burden (Blackfive), Phil Carter (Intel Dump), J. R. Michael (Mudville Gazette/MilBlogs), C. J. Grisham (A Soldier's Perspective)

Moderator: Ward Carrol (Military.com)


Posted at 1101Z

Behind the Scenes: A Kawasaki Moment

[Andi]

I think some behind-the-scenes footage at the next conference would be very entertaining. Last year, some really funny things happened (I'll try to get to those some day). This year had its share of funny, too.

Just before the first panel began, some of you may have noticed a visitor walk in and quietly take a seat in the front row on the far side of the room. I saw him and didn't recognize him, but someone else did. This person came over to me and, in a very excited, animated manner, said....


Posted at 0146Z | Comments (1)

September 23, 2008

Want more Party Pictures?

[Greyhawk]

No - not the Republican or Democrat Parties - real party pictures...

mbc20087.jpg

Just look down there...


Posted at 2319Z | Comments (2)

Don't Be Skeered

[Greyhawk]
mbc20084.jpg

Posted at 2228Z

A Cheesy Photo from Vegas

[Greyhawk]

Some might claim to have the cheesiest photo from Vegas - but I actually do. It's below the fold.


Posted at 2213Z | Comments (3)

A Damming Photo from Vegas

[Greyhawk]

Many might claim to have the most damming photo from Vegas - but only I really do. It's below the fold.


Posted at 2007Z | Comments (2)

Re: Lt Gen Caldwell

[Greyhawk]

Even though he was addressing the MilBlogs Conference specifically I think there are implications there that should be noted throughout the new media landscape. Lt Gen Caldwell is positioned to lead the military "charge" to embrace new media - far beyond just milbloggers. If this sort of thinking catches on, the opportunities/access for bloggers will continue to grow in the DoD.

And Lt Gen Caldwell isn't a guy just showing up for the game - his new media "strategy" has been evolving for quite some time, and in many ways is similar to his predecessor at CAC/Ft Leavenworth (then-Lt Gen Petraeus) reworking of larger strategy (or strategic thinking) for counter-insurgency operations.

And like that effort, this one would have been useful a few years earlier, too. But again I see parallels - Roggio's early embeds with Marines in Anbar being an example of the same sort of isolated early success in IO that Col McMaster's Tal Afar campaign or Col MacFarland's embrace of the Awakening movement was in COIN.

Less dramatic? Indeed. Less important? Time will tell.


Posted at 1453Z

LTG Caldwell on MilBlogging

[Andi]

Below is LTG William Caldwell's address to the 2008 MilBlog Conference:


Posted at 1147Z

September 22, 2008

Credit Where Credit is Due

[Andi]

A conference doesn't just happen. It requires an army of volunteers. A few people deserve some special thanks for lending a hand. First of all, both Greyhawks and Some Soldiers' Mom (and hubby) volunteered their time to help stuff the attendee gift bags, and they were life savers. Mrs. G also designed the graphics for our conference, as she has every year. Homefront Six and AF Sister manned the registration desk. Some Soldiers' Mom was the go-to gal for the Bozik baby shower and David Marron worked our charity piece. Fuzzy and other angels were on hand to man the Military.com booth, which featured Soldiers' Angels. Oh, and most importantly (heh), Boston Maggie graciously ran downstairs to Starbucks to fetch some green tea when I thought I was going to drop dead from green tea withdrawal.....

Thanks to everyone for your help.


Posted at 2325Z

They're out there---listening!

[Eagle1]

They come from the sky!

After almost 70 years they're still out there listening ... and might have been involved with Roswell.

Plan9SaucerShadow.jpg


As set out here.


Posted at 0444Z

How to Make A Blackfive Sandwich

[Greyhawk]
Posted at 0121Z | Comments (5)

September 18, 2008

How do I explain it with a straight face?

[CDR Salamander]

We all know that selection boards are a zero-sum-game. Only so many slots are available to so many people. For one to advance, another must be left behind.

We emphasize and try our best to create a meritocracy where if you work hard, perform best, and excel better than your peers you will be rewarded, recognized, and promoted for it. It is a trust, knowing that all human institutions are imperfect, that your Chain of Command will do their best to be as fair as possible. You, by your performance and career decisions, more or less can drive your success.

There are a few other things that we have as fundamentals. One of which is we will not tolerate individual or institutional racism. Another is a culture of fairness.

What do you do when you reach the point that a Junior Officer puts a couple of emails and messages in front of you and asks, "Sir, could you explain this to me? " "Where will my performance overcome the circumstance of my birth? Can it?" "Where is the meritocracy you talked about why you came here?" "Where is the fairness in this?"

"How is this not racist?"

Date: Monday, September 15, 2008, 6:14 PM
Subject: General Tasker: Coordination Office: Hot List: Cxxx Nxx
CNIC DIVERSITY ACCOUNTABILITY BRIEF

Captains,

Sorry for the late turnaround on this from me to you. Cxxx sent us this hot tasker this morning with a COB Monday (Washington DC) deadline. They are asking for "a list of your Early Promote and Must Promote in Pay Grades 05 and 06." We must assume they want the names.
...
One piece which is clearly part of the original tasker from VADM Harvey (attached) but which is not mentioned at all in the Cxxx tasker is "diversity;" however, as it appears to be the entire point of the data call, please annotate which of your O5/O6 EP/MP officers (from last cycle) are diverse.

The source message still, seven months later, leaves me without and answer to the JO.
- CNO wants to see the enterprise demographic data that has been part of the previous reviews and will also want to review both percentages and raw numbers within each category.

- CNO will focus on middle career management -- who are the diverse hot runners in an enterprise (you should know them by name) and what is the plan for their career progression. In particular, be able to answer the following:
(1) Who are the minority O-5/O-6s in your community?
(2) What are YOU doing to ensure these men and women are being properly developed to attain the highest levels of leadership?
(3) What is being done within your Enterprise / Community to ensure that these men and women are assigned to the key billets that lead to promotion?

- You will need to know what your enterprise's benchmark for success is in regard to middle career management and the timeframe in which success will be achieved.

- A three year plan addressing your key issues that includes a measurable way ahead must, rpt MUST, be briefed.

- The CNO approved benchmark for officer success is a 2037 Flag Pool that is 10% AA / 13% API / 13% Hispanic. This goal is what you should measure your officer corps against.

Here is the comparative ENS accessions who will make up the 2037 flag pool:
77% White
8% African American
6% Hispanic
9% Asian/Pacific islander or Native American
You do the math on what needs to be done to meet that quota ... errr ... goal.

What do I tell the Ensign from rural Louisiana with the French sounding name with brown hair and brown eyes to explain why, if he is lucky enough to be considered for Flag, that the blond hair blue eyed Doctor's son from Florida with the last name Gonzalez will not receive special consideration because he has "Hispanic" ticked off on his record?

Help me out, because I have no idea.


Posted at 1928Z | Comments (4)

September 15, 2008

GEN Petreaus Farewell Letter

[Greyhawk]
When I took command of Multi-National Force-Iraq in February 2007, I noted that the situation in Iraq was hard but not hopeless. You have proven that assessment to be correct. Indeed, your great work, sacrifice, courage, and skill have helped to reverse a downward spiral toward civil war and to wrest the initiative from the enemies of the new Iraq.
"Hard is not Hopeless" - words to live by.
Posted at 1402Z

I'll have the soup with knife, please

[Greyhawk]

John Nagl, in the WaPo:

BAGHDAD When I retired from the Army in June, my comrades in arms laughed at my summer vacation plans: another August in Iraq.

But I had unfinished business here. When my unit left Iraq in September 2004, one of my battle captains presented us with coffee mugs to celebrate our return home. The sardonic inscription: "Operation Iraqi Freedom 2003-2004: We were winning when I left."

Hmmm... we were winning when I left, too. Here's what Nagl thinks now.


Posted at 1345Z | Comments (3)

John McCain: "We have succeeded in Iraq"

[Greyhawk]

Details here.


Posted at 0953Z

September 14, 2008

Before the Big Winds

[Eagle1]

battle-of-galveston.jpg

The largest city in Texas was blockaded, attacked, recaptured.

Before it was the site of the largest weather-related loss of life in U.S. history.

As set out here


Posted at 2109Z

September 13, 2008

A Prayer For Track and Beau

[Greyhawk]

Beau Biden: spoke at the Democratic National Convention (but downplayed his upcoming deployment to Iraq).

Track Palin: "campaign prop".

It's certainly no secret that both these men are going to Iraq. But apparently some things are more secret than others.

Army position:

Citing security restrictions, the Army will not say where in Iraq Palin's or Biden's units are being sent. Both units are scheduled to be in Iraq for 12 months.
I respect that, as I respect and admire both men for what they are doing. They are doing their part. In my mind additional details aren't needed.

I wish others agreed.


Posted at 1927Z | Comments (2)

September 11, 2008

Joe Cook

[Greyhawk]

Many of you have probably already seen this video (3,404,685 views as of this posting) and know the "surprise" ending. If you haven't seen it, take a look before clicking read more - there are spoilers therein.

I put this here not as an endorsement of the content, but because I checked the back story and I think reporting that is worthwhile - one thing we've learned in these parts is not to trust everyone who says they're an Iraq veteran.


Posted at 1039Z | Comments (8)

September 10, 2008

Re: The war for the war

[Greyhawk]

I like the caveat you put up front at your place. As I read the Woodward WaPo stories I thought "Damn good story - I wonder how much of it is true?" I suspect the answer is somewhere between 90-100 percent. Trouble is in many cases I can't tell you which part is or isn't.

I'll still probably get the book. Many people will. I wish Bing West's Strongest Tribe would sell as well - but I only saw one of those titles when I stopped at the local Kroger for milk on my way home today.

Here's a long story from the New Yorker on the "surge development" topic, too. It's a Petraeus profile, but it offers a LOT of background on the surge, with emphasis on the lower-than-Joint-Chiefs guys who made The Plan.

Note this quote from the New Yorker:

Bush told his National Security Council staff, as one of them recalled it, that he feared that if the U.S. did not change its strategy the war would be lost. On another occasion, according to this former official, Bush declared that there were few things he cared about more than the health of the United States military, but losing in Iraq was one of them.
...and this one from Woodward:
Mullen told Keane he had become acutely aware of the strains on the Army and the Marine Corps. Military families were shouldering the strain, and the military was losing quality officers.

"Mike, all of that's true," Keane said. "But this is true every time we fight a war of any consequence." Wars break armies, and they have to be put back together, he said. That's the price of war. But the price was worth it. "You've not talked one time about winning here, Mike. Not one time have you mentioned 'I want to win in Iraq.' I mean, do you?"

I think a probable truth can be inferred from that, and it is ugly but necessary. Keane was exactly right: wars break armies. That should be part of the decision process for the leaders of a nation preparring for war. Once that decision - that great and terrible decision to go to war - is made, it is (if not inevitable) an entirely predictable consequence of that decision. To argue that we must stop at some later point because "the army" is breaking is absurd and disingenuous - it's a pre-war consideration mis-applied to a post-war world. For politicians to claim otherwise is an insult to the intelligence of all concerned.

The truth we can infer from the above passages is that Bush understood that.

By the way, as the media narrative shifts to credit the guys who made the plan while the phrases "President Bush's surge" and "listen to the Generals" vanish into yesterday's news, you'll have another signal that we won.


Posted at 0145Z

September 09, 2008

The war for the war

[CDR Salamander]

I am a skeptic about all things Woodward, but in the WaPo and WSJ there are two good reads about his new book that outline the battle for the surge and the personalities involved. This, I thought, is/was very telling about the battle inside the Army of Northern Virginia and the Potomac Flotilla.

Mullen, formerly chief of naval operations, had not favored the surge; Keane had, publicly and vocally. Mullen told Keane he had become acutely aware of the strains on the Army and the Marine Corps. Military families were shouldering the strain, and the military was losing quality officers.

"Mike, all of that's true," Keane said. "But this is true every time we fight a war of any consequence." Wars break armies, and they have to be put back together, he said. That's the price of war. But the price was worth it. "You've not talked one time about winning here, Mike. Not one time have you mentioned 'I want to win in Iraq.' I mean, do you?"

It was an insulting question to put to a fellow military man.

"Of course I want to win," Mullen said.

"I assume you do," Keane replied, "but to the degree that you're putting pressure on Petraeus to reduce forces, you're taking far too much risk, and that risk is in losing and not winning."

"Well," Mullen said, "we're just going to disagree."

"You really don't want me to help Petraeus?" Keane asked. "Dave Petraeus, no matter who he wants to talk to over there, no matter what size he is, shape he is, what his views are, given Petraeus's responsibility -- he's got the toughest job anybody in uniform has -- why wouldn't you let him have that?"


Posted at 1932Z

MilBloggie Nominations Begin

[Mrs Greyhawk]

On September 19, 2008, the 3rd Annual Milblogging Conference will be held in Las Vegas, during the conference MilBlogging.com will be the awarding the 3rd Annual Milbloggie Awards, which recognizes MilBloggers for their contribution to the milblogging world over the past year.

All nominations must be submitted online through Milblogging.com by 11:59 pm EST on Wednesday, September 10th, 2008

Some readers may remember from past blog competition that Greyhawk does not want to be nominated in any weblog awards where he's competing with other active duty milblogs.

Although this is in reference to a different award, his reasoning can be found here:

When I first saw the awards I was glad to see there was no military blog category. I know this was done with the best intentions but I can't support this sort of competition between actual military - there's a beauty 'pageant/popularity/high school prom queen element to this that utterly trivializes the fact of what we're doing.

There are a handful of actual blogs run by active duty military people on or the near the front lines I cycle through them every day. Every day I'm glad to find the authors have not gone the way of Bob Zangas, who quit blogging forever in the Spring when he and his Iraqi interpreter were gunned down near Hillah by insurgents wearing police uniforms. (Updated w/ milbloggers lost - Army Spc. Francisco G. Martinez, Lt. Thomas M. Martin, Sgt Eddie Jeffers, and Maj. Andrew Olmsted)

On the other hand I note a significant number of blogs about military done by veterans and non-military folks. I can't speak for others here on the front line but I think the category would best be filled by those sorts.

Again, I know the category was added with the best of intentions and am honored to be mentioned, but I respectfully decline to participate.

and more here

...some will note I requested not to be included in the Military Blogs category, in fact I swapped a couple of polite emails to that effect with Kevin Aylward, who understood my position in the matter completely.

The top five nominees in each branch category will be announced on Thursday, September 11th, 2008 and those nominees will move into the Voting Phase beginning September 11th, 2008. Details here


Posted at 0157Z

RE: Misguided Youth

[Greyhawk]

Jeebus, will it ever stop?

There is a whole lot of rumor out there, but I have heard this one at a few places, just google Palin and Jail.

Rumor is he cut the brake line on a school bus and took the army to avoid jail time.

Sounds crazy, but seeing what has panned out as true so far was crazy before it was confirmed.

Because, yeah, as Governor you could keep a thing like that secret.

IF YOU KILLED EVERYONE INVOLVED.

(But that's the only reason these red neck rubes join these days, isn't it? Sounds plausible to some, I suppose.)

Good lord, if everything they claimed was true about this family was actually true they'd be the worst family in the history of the universe. But these people BELIEVE this Shite. I guess that's what "BELIEVE" means on all those Obama posters. It's an effing ORDER.

Scary. Just scary.


Posted at 0037Z | Comments (4)

September 08, 2008

The Audacity of Hype

[Mrs Greyhawk]

Apparently General Patraeus' "Surge Strategy", had nothing to do with the success in Iraq, it's because of Biden

Iraq is getting better because they are doing exactly what he recommended.

HT: Jawa


Posted at 1559Z | Comments (1)

Just Noticed the "P"

[Greyhawk]

...in a commenter's name here. (As in "Maj (P) John".)

But maybe I'm the last to know.


Posted at 1246Z | Comments (2)

September 07, 2008

On the Bubble

[Eagle1]

Mustin Sled w bomber.jpg

When Navy Captain Mustin wasn't fooling around with catapults, he was playing with "sleds."

As explained here.


Posted at 2233Z

Ships on anti-pirate patrol in the Gulf of Aden might see a new pirate trick

[Eagle1]

aden gulf.jpg

CTF 150 out in the Gulf of Aden might want be aware that the Somalia pirates may have a new trick up their sleeves, as set out here.

Sort of a reverse Q-ship...


Posted at 0140Z

September 05, 2008

Six degrees of Sarah Palin

[Buck Sargent]

The world just keeps getting smaller and smaller.

But I suppose it's more like two degrees, actually. I've learned that GOP hopeful Sarah Palin just so happens to be the friend of a friend.

Great personal insight on the VP candidate, and doesn't even have to resort to busybody gossip mongering. (So you know he doesn't write for US Weekly!)

*Update: My wife, who frequently acted in campaign and industrial commercial spots for Dave in Alaska, recently recalled accompanying him to the picturesque Palin home on the lake in Wasilla back in 2002. Wifey reports that then-Mayor Palin was "extremely gracious and seemed genuinely interested in the particulars of my life." After which the Mayor returned to fishing out back with her kids.

Incidentally, Dave gave me a copy of his book just before I deployed, and it is an excellent read.


Posted at 0216Z | Comments (2)

Death Tolls

[Greyhawk]

Headline:

Nearly 125 Shot Dead In Chicago Over Summer
Total Is About Double The Death Toll In Iraq
Story:CHICAGO (CBS) ― An estimated 123 people were shot and killed over the summer. That's nearly double the number of soldiers killed in Iraq over the same time period.

In May, cbs2chicago.com began tracking city shootings and posting them on Google maps. Information compiled from our reporters, wire service reports and the Chicago Police Major Incidents log indicated that 123 people were shot and killed throughout the city between the start of Memorial Day weekend on May 26, and the end of Labor Day on Sept. 1.

But almost exactly the same as the number killed in Afghanistan over the same period.

(Via Insta.)


Posted at 0110Z | Comments (2)

September 04, 2008

Ahhh... Opportunity to Save a Misguided Youth??

[Soldier's Mom]

Read this

CROSSVILLE, Tenn. — A California teen was arrested and charged with criminal impersonation in eastern Tennessee for allegedly fooling businesses into thinking he was a soldier to get discounts and other perks.

The Cumberland County Sheriff's Department arrested 19-year-old Damian Paul Castillo of Anderson, Calif., last week on 25 counts of fraudulent use of a credit card, six counts of violation of the bad check law and one count of criminal impersonation.

Sheriff's Investigator Ben Waller says Castillo is accused of passing himself off as a member of the U.S. Air Force by wearing a military uniform. He's also accused of bilking nine businesses out of more than $14,102. Investigators say the Air Force confirmed he had never enlisted.

Some of the alleged scams included getting plane tickets upgraded, shopping tax-free or getting a military discount. Investigators say he's also accused of using a credit card that was not valid and writing bad checks from another fraudulent account.

Wonder if he had a fake I.D.? So, is this one of those opportunities for the Court to say, "Marine Corps or Juvie Hall? You choose." Of course, the Corps might have no use for him... but I'm thinking (if he meets the other requirements), he could be straightened out... quick. If he declines to join the brothers he seems to so "admire", I say "Throw the book at him!" But that's a mom thing...



Posted at 1738Z | Comments (1)

The UK's treatment of Troops is Unbelievable

[Mrs Greyhawk]

Wounded soldier forced to sleep in car after hotel refuses him a room

A wounded soldier home from Afghanistan on sick leave was forced to spend the night in his car after a hotel refused him a room.

Corporal Tomos Stringer was told by staff at Metro Hotel, in Woking, that it was company policy not to accept members of the armed forces as guests. The 24-year-old had travelled to the Surrey town to help with funeral preparations for a friend killed in action.

It was so late that Cpl Stringer, who had broken his wrist jumping off an Army truck as it was attacked, had no choice but to bed down in his tiny, two-door car, arm covered in plaster.

Cpl Stringer, of 13 Air Assault Support Regiment, The Royal Logistic Corps, has now returned to Afghanistan, but his mother, Gaynor Stringer, from Criccieth, north Wales, told The Times that she is still furious about the incident.

<...>

A wounded soldier home from Afghanistan on sick leave was forced to spend the night in his car after a hotel refused him a room.

Corporal Tomos Stringer was told by staff at Metro Hotel, in Woking, that it was company policy not to accept members of the armed forces as guests. The 24-year-old had travelled to the Surrey town to help with funeral preparations for a friend killed in action.

It was so late that Cpl Stringer, who had broken his wrist jumping off an Army truck as it was attacked, had no choice but to bed down in his tiny, two-door car, arm covered in plaster.

Cpl Stringer, of 13 Air Assault Support Regiment, The Royal Logistic Corps, has now returned to Afghanistan, but his mother, Gaynor Stringer, from Criccieth, north Wales, told The Times that she is still furious about the incident.



Posted at 1547Z | Comments (2)

WTF? Is this campaign strategy?

[Mrs Greyhawk]

Obama might pursue criminal charges against Bush· Biden says criminal violations will be pursued

· Democrats have issued subpoenas to Bush aides
· 3 staffers have been held in contempt of Congress

Democratic vice-presidential nominee Joe Biden said yesterday that he and running mate Barack Obama could pursue criminal charges against the Bush administration if they are elected in November.

Biden's comments, first reported by ABC news, attracted little notice on a day dominated by the drama surrounding his Republican counterpart, Alaska governor Sarah Palin.

But his statements represent the Democrats' strongest vow so far this year to investigate alleged misdeeds committed during the Bush years.

"If there has been a basis upon which you can pursue someone for a criminal violation, they will be pursued," Biden said during a campaign event in Deerfield Beach, Florida, according to ABC.

"[N]ot out of vengeance, not out of retribution," he added, "out of the need to preserve the notion that no one, no attorney general, no president -- no one is abo