milblog1archives.jpg
PDA
Shop
Contact
YouTube Videos
To Mudville
Join MilBlogs
Someone You Should Know
MilBlogs


milblogsa1.jpg
Prev | List | Random | Next
Join
Powered by RingSurf!

Authors



























Ground Support

SoA_proudsupporter.gif

soldiersangels.jpg

AnySoldierLogo.jpg

topmain.jpg

books_for_soldiers.gif

foundation_heroesfund02.jpg

fallen pats.jpg

fisherhouse.jpg

hopevil.jpg

opac.jpg

Adopt a platoon.jpg

Homes for our troops.jpg

WWproject.jpg

heromiles200.jpg

operation morale.jpg

cbrdg.jpg

op-give.jpg

mamo.jpg

Sponsors

Archives
February 2012

S
M
T
W
T
F
S
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29

Monthly Archives []


Feed me:

Sponsors

MilBlogs Feeds

Add to Google Reader or Homepage
Add to Technorati Favorites
Technorati Profile
Subscribe in NewsGator Online Subscribe in Bloglines Add to Plusmo

xml.gif rdf.png atom feed.jpg

Mrsg- Greyhawk's Profile
Mrsg- Greyhawk's Facebook profile
Create Your Badge
Roll Call

6a00d83487393d53ef010536e865fe970c.jpg

The Fine Print

The Milblogs site has multiple authors. Unless otherwise credited, the opinions expressed are those of the specific author, and not the official position of any other contributor or any organization to which they belong, to include the United States Department of Defense or any of it's subordinate components.

Comments and e-mails are welcome, but all such communication is to be assumed to be 1) the original work of any who initiate said communication and 2) in the public domain, with free use granted for publication in electronic or written form. If you do NOT wish to have your message posted, write "CONFIDENTIAL" in the subject line of your email.

Original content copyright © 2006 by the respective authors. Fair, not-for-profit use of said material by others is encouraged, as long as acknowledgement and credit is given, to include the url of the original source post. Other arrangements can be made as needed.

Site contact: greyhawk at mudvillegazette dot com

« December 8, 2006 | Main | December 10, 2006 »

December 9, 2006

Re: Everything

[Greyhawk]

It's a quote ripped from out of its context. The General was referring to what has happened in the past - he says we could not have done more militarily than what we have done. He did not at all mean that we have nothing left to do, or that we can't do anything else, and certainly not that it's time to throw in the towel. He was speaking in the past tense.

The full quote is in the "continue reading" section, the full briefing text is here. The last line of the question he was responding to is this: "What missteps did we make in the last year?" And the short (but not hacked to the point of meaningless) version of his answer is "I happen to believe that we have done everything militarily we possibly can. We're working to strengthen the Iraqi military. The Iraqi army gets better every day. But I really believe the key to this conflict is to understand that it's going to take more than military action to solve the problems that face Iraq and to pull people together."

I'm not sure what's earth shattering about that. If anyone's ever been arguing that the US military by itself can fix every problem anywhere they are blithering idiots. In fact, I'm not sure what's headline worthy about that - unless you change what he meant to something entirely different.

Of course the media is going to frame that as a statement that the military can do no more than it has - which is far from the truth, and far from what the General said. But virtually any quote you see from a member of the US armed forces in the press will be completely butchered. For some reason, that butchering will invariably make it appear the individual quoted is defeated and surrendering. When reading or watching news you must bear in mind that the vast majority of members of the media are not on our side in this current war.

For the record, here's the next question:

Q And, sir, you don't think it's -- it's not too late for that? You think there's still an opportunity to turn things around?

GEN. CHIARELLI: I definitely think there's an opportunity to turn things around. There's no doubt in my mind there is.



Posted at 2259Z

everything militarily that we possibly can?

[CDR Salamander]

I am trying to process this quote from LTG Chiarelli. I need help.

"I happen to believe that we have done everything militarily that we possibly can,"
Our "full measure?" Out of Schlitz? Winchester? Culmination?

I have looked all over the place for better context. It has to be out there. Isn't there a PIO out there that can "revise and extend his remarks?" Was he talking about a specific tactical aspect? Just an unfortunate choice of words, i.e. the wrong words at the right time in the wrong ears? We all have bad days. In a word: ungh.


Posted at 1902Z

Re: Ambivalence

[Chap]

Steele's point is timely; I'd point to some other essays that are also germane:

  • Orson Scott Card's discussion on why naming this thing is so hard

  • the late Jeane Kirkpatrick's 1979 essay on why we become lame at this kind of thing (pdf).

  • Posted at 0216Z

« December 8, 2006 | Main | December 10, 2006 »