test

123

More Rumsfeld in Iraq

Donald Sensing has an email from the front on Rumsfeld in Iraq. I don't think there's ever been another SecDef that meant as much to the troops as Rumsfeld, there's an unprecedented bond between the man and the troops. It stems from mutual respect, grows from the real feeling of brotherhood of war that most military members feel at this time in history, and is strengthened by the us against them mentality that the media is fueling with their war on our boss.

Nightmares and End States

Austin Bay is a Colonel in the Army Reserve and a syndicated columnist with a feature article in the current Weekly Standard. Beyond that he holds a title I look forward to claiming myself: veteran of service in Iraq.

An excerpt from his Standard story:

What are the acceptable End States in Iraq? In an essay he wrote for the Wall Street Journal in August, Iraq's interim prime minister Iyad Allawi identified three keys to success in Iraq: (1) security and the rule of law, (2) a prosperous economy, and (3) an "inclusive, collaborative" political system. To achieve it will take years of low-level warfare and continuing security assistance from the United States even after the New Iraq begins to manage its own domestic security. No administration of whatever political stripe should think otherwise.

Another acceptable End State would be what a friend called "a too strong, bulldog Iraq." Don't dismiss the notion out of hand. Here are the attributes: "New Iraq" decides to rearm for offensive capability--and the French or Russians sell it weapons. Angry at perceived Syrian, Iranian, or Saudi interference, a brave new Iraqi government turns to regional assertiveness as a way of solidifying domestic support. The United States could live with this End State, but it would seriously frustrate attempts to spur political evolution in Saudi Arabia and Iran.

A far less acceptable End State would be a "gentle" dictatorship in Iraq, an authoritarian regime that did not threaten the region but held Iraq together by force and smashed civil opposition in the name of domestic security. This would be an ideological defeat for the United States, the defeat salved if this New Iraq were an effective counterterror partner in the region. Early Coalition withdrawal, whatever the reason, would make this End State more likely.

The last acceptable End State, but one that further frustrates long-term American goals, is the oft-debated tripartite Iraq, with Kurdistan in the north, Shia-stan in the south, and Baath-istan in the Sunni Triangle and Al Anbar Province. This would be a dangerous mosaic, but for the sake of oil revenues the Baathists would have to police al Qaeda. Kurds and Shia areas would also destroy al Qaedaites.

Defeatists and cynics will argue it's too late for the United States to wage the Millennium War on ideological grounds. This ignores the fact that this war is ideological in its deepest origins.

Afghanistan is the guide. Afghanistan's October 9 presidential election was the most significant election in 2004. Obviously, it was significant for the people of Afghanistan, but it was significant too for the forgotten, trampled, robbed, and oppressed people suffering in Earth's various tyrannies--those who do long for freedom's fairer shake. The successful election was also a major step toward victory for the civilized world. This Millennium War is as much a war against fear, poverty, and anarchy as it is a war against the petty tyrants who harbor and sustain terrorists. The 8 million Afghans who voted, despite terror threats from al Qaeda and Taliban holdouts, rejected fear. The Afghan people acted, ignoring death threats made by religious fascists, the destruction wrought by 30 years of war, and the lack of "a modern transportation and communication infrastructure" (i.e., roads and telephones).

While reading it two thoughts occurred to me.

One, this may be the first post-election (and thus free of that questionable motive) item I've read approaching serious discussion of "end state" in Iraq. Of course, that ultimate "end state" is up to the people of Iraq, but certainly now that the American elections are passed and we no longer need pay lip service to talk of "exit strategy" and other code phrases for failure the debate among those whose opinions have been shown to matter would be worthwhile.

Two, actually I have seen a purportedly serious discussion of "end sate" in Iraq before, but it was from the left, before the war even started. From Alternet, under the headline "Bush Wins: The Left's Nightmare Scenario" Mark Levine, ("assistant professor in the History Department at the University of California at Irvine") writes of his thoughts on various "end states" for Iraq, and their palatability to leftist tastes:

The first is an optimistic "We Win" scenario, which would result from massive protests and diplomatic pressure forcing President Bush to postpone an invasion indefinitely. (What has yet to be addressed is what exactly we win if Hussein remains indefinitely in power and the sanctions go on killing Iraqis.) With war seemingly imminent, the movement is being forced to fall back on a second scenario, "Everyone Loses," in which the warnings of a protracted and bloody war that destabilizes the Middle East and increases terrorism bear their bitter fruit.

However unpalatable in terms of destroyed lives and infrastructure, this latter scenario would at least quash the Administration's imperial dreams and force the kind of soul searching of United States' policies that is a major goal of the movement. But this outcome is less likely than many assume, and the antiwar movement would be well advised to plan for a third scenario: "Bush Wins."

In this third scenario, the war is over quickly with relatively low U.S. casualties, some sort of mechanism for transitional rule is put in place, and President Bush and his policies gain unprecedented power and prestige. From my recent conversations with organizers and their latest pronouncements, it is clear that this possibility has yet to be addressed. Waiting much longer could spell disaster for the antiwar movement.

You see, what he's saying is, they didn't have a plan to win the peace. Those seeking insight as to why the left continues to insist that the "Everyone Loses" option described above is in fact what is happening in Iraq today should familiarize themselves with this genesis piece on that sort of thinking. The "We win" option went out early, and the peaceful and prosperous Iraq is beyond their ability to accept for the reasons the author makes clear. All of Colonel Bay's "End States" are, to one degree or another, their nightmare; Allawi's vision made reality might be more than they could bear. Every time a bomb goes off in Baghdad, every time another Iraqi election worker is murdered in the streets, the Mark Levines of America can nod thoughtfully over their copy of the NY Times or add comments at The Daily Kos. Fortunately last month American voters ensured they can do little more.

An interesting contrast between the vision of possible futures from two perspectives, a telling juxtaposition of priorities, and a fine illustration of what I meant in stating that "the debate among those whose opinions have been shown to matter would be worthwhile.

2004 (and Beyond)

Some time in January Mudville will welcome its one millionth reader. To put that number in perspective, big blogs achieve it every week. Meanwhile, a million other blogs never will. I certainly thought I never would - through the first 8 month's of Mudville's existence the daily visits were rarely more than what the hourly totals are now.

My thanks to Mudville's top referrers for '04, in alphabetical order:

The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiller
Argghhh
Blackfive
Tim Blair
Blogs for Bush
Captains Quarters
Citizen Smash
The Corner
Daily Briefing
Dean Esmay
Doc in the Box
Hugh Hewitt
Imao
Instapundit
Lileks
Little Green Footballs
Lucianne
Michelle Malkin
Power Line
Rather Biased
Scrappleface
Sgt Hook
Roger L. Simon
The Weekly Standard (Hugh again!)

Those familiar with the blogosphere will likely express no surprise. If you do see an unfamiliar name in the list above by all means click through and stay a while, these are folks with gravitas, and all are worthy of attention.

There's something worth mentioning here, however, and it speaks volumes to how the blogosphere works. Glenn Reynolds pointed it out in his review of Hugh Hewitt's new book:

He also catches on (actually, I think Hugh was one of the first to make this point, in a post on his blog) to the importance of what Chris Anderson is calling the Long Tail -- that in the aggregate, the vast hordes of small blogs with a few dozen readers are more important than the small number of big blogs with hundreds of thousands of readers. (Here's an article on that topic by Anderson, from Wired.) I think that's absolutely right, and Hugh has some interesting things to say about it. (And journalists mostly don't get this point at all -- every time I get interviewed it seems that they want firsts, mosts, and biggests, when I keep telling them that the real story of the blogosphere is the day-to-day interaction and writing of a whole lot of blogs).

"Indeed" (heh!). As supporting testimony, I'll point out that the bottom line of my referrers list compiles "all remaining" - and that total exceeds any of the above individual referrers save one. Approximately 150,000 people visited this blog last year via links from "all remaining" and of that fact I am grateful, humble, and proud. Thank you all.

As a result of this, I'm now able to cause a noticeable blip on other site meters with a simple link. I can't remember who I first heard use the term "Mudslide" for this effect, but I like it. It's especially fun to drop one on someone in that "all remaining" category, when the result looks something like what an Installanch does to me, and I hereby announce a new year's resolution to do so more often in the coming months.

A confession on this topic: back in those early days when I rarely saw 50 visits a day I was often hesitant to link to other sites, expecting the resulting lack of traffic flow to be visible evidence of my own insignificance. I now realize that nothing could be further from the truth. Such links undoubtedly brought me to the attention of more than a few good folks. And now if you'll take a quick look down my side bar you'll find a list of those who've sent traffic this way today. (See "cavalry" section.) This is where I turn to find things new and different in the blogosphere. There's no need to click the top guys for this purpose, it's the new names farther down the list I seek out, and each one I visit reminds me that the "Long Tail" is a source of brilliance, insight, and surprise beyond anything I'll find in the all too predictable mainstream media today.

I'll close this entry with a final point. I've said this before but I can't say it enough: thanks to all who place eyes on this page. You're the only reason any of this matters! Your emails and comments are appreciated, your criticisms are valued, your presence is what keeps me going here.

Here's to more in '05.

Scott Ott is not funny.

At least not this time. And you can count on one finger the number of times that's been said here.

Please go read.

Rumsfeld in Iraq

In Mosul, a Soldier asks Donald Rumsfeld "Sir, how do we win the war in the media? It seems like that is the place where we're getting beat up more than anybody else."

The NY Times covers Rumsfeld in Iraq without addressing the exchange between the SecDef and the Soldier in a story headlined US Can Beat Insurgents, Rumsfeld Tells Troops

Not to be outdone, the Washington Post ignores the exchange in their coverage headlined In Iraq, Rumsfeld Urges Persistence

No slackers on the West Coast! The LA Times ignores that part of the story in a piece titled Rumsfeld Drops In on Troops in Iraq

But the Philadelphia Inquirer tops them all with their story! Rumsfeld tells troops: More attacks likely - yeah! - that was the message!

Other than the glaring omission they are fairly balanced efforts though. Perhaps a sense of guilt on the part of reporters post-Mosul, something similar to that felt in humans?

Top Ten Blog Moments

A link in Ed Driscoll's top ten blog moments? Yea baby. Big time.

Thanks Ed.

Mosul - the shot heard 'round the World?

As the awareness of blogs continues to rise military members are increasingly taking advantage of the ease of long-distance mass communication to family and friends offered by the web-based medium. Outside of a few mainstream media dinosaurs it should surprise no one that intentionally or incidentally, unfiltered coverage of the war in Iraq is becoming readily available "back home" in near real time.

Consider this: a few short days before Christmas 2004 a suicide bomber entered the dining facility (DFAC) at an American military installation in Mosul and detonated his explosives, killing several Americans and Iraqis and wounding many more. I'll spare you my own thoughts on the event itself; several miles and a lot of concertina wire separate me from that spot on the map. And after all, why listen to me when no less than four blogs from GIs who were there (and a fifth with a letter from a GI there) are available to you now?

What follows may be a first of it's kind; a round up of observations of a specific event in an ongoing war, posted within hours of its occurrence by troops on the ground in the combat zone. Some of these have been heavily linked throughout the blogosphere, others overlooked by all. I'll excerpt from them, but these brief cuts won't do justice to the authors' efforts. Click through and read them, along with the other posts at their sites. It's literally history in the making.

A Chaplain at the scene:

The day began early as I didn't sleep very well last night. Once I was awake I decided not to just lay there and stare at the darkness so I got up, got dressed, shaved and headed into the TOC, the heart of what goes on. In the TOC (Tactical Operations Center) they monitor several different radio nets to keep abreast of what is happening in the area. It's the place to be if you want up to the minute information. When I arrived it was fairly calm. I made small talk with the guys there and sipped that first cup of morning coffee. The day was clear and there was very little going on, or so it seemed. A very short while later we received the initial reports.

He goes on to describe the events of the day, in detail, from a very close perspective.

A GI tells the tale of two Iraqi Soldiers who were in the DFAC at the time:

Both of them were blown from their seats by the blast, which they described as, "very powerful, lots of noise and heat." The two Iraqi soldiers were both dazed. One of them could only hear a loud ringing sound in his ears. The other couldn't believe his eyes: Every where he looked people were gasping for air or bleeding profusely. Before the two Iraqis lay a helpless American soldier, who staggered across the smoke-filled mess hall at first only to fall on the ground. They couldn't understand a word coming out of the American's mouth. They only saw the blood spewing from his leg.

These two men, both in their 20s, saw carnage caused by the very people they took an oath to defend Iraq against. These two men were proud Iraqis who were trained by U.S. Army Special Forces. These two men had seen enough people die at the hands of terrorists, and on December 21, 2004, they would do everything in their power to save every person they could.

Such should be noted along with every statement of the obvious: some Iraqis are against us, and they can don uniforms too. It's also worth remembering that among the first American casualties of the war in Iraq were those caused by an American soldier rolling live grenades into the tents of his fellow GI's.

The Docs at Mosul pick up where the Chaplain leaves off:

I completely lost track of time, so I am not sure when we finally got most of the return to duty patients out, but I am guessing it was around 1800. Then it was time to start taking care of the patients on the wards. More washouts, more CT's, and more chest tubes. It was not until around 2330 that we could actually sit back, catch our breath, and relax. There was not one person in our CSH that did not work their butts of today. The team work and overall job performance were second to none. As the docs sat around and tried to analyze what had just occurred we were all shocked. We could not believe what we had just been through. But even more important, we could not believe the way the CSH handled this situation which completely overwhelmed our system. By definition a mass casualty situation is when the number of patients and their injuries exceed the available resources . This was the mass casualty of all mass casualties.

The story they tell is incredible; along with the courage and fortitude of the American and Iraqi troops at the scene, the skilled medical teams and technology at their disposal saved more than a few lives this grim day.

Afterward they were interviewed by a military public affairs rep, who tried her best to get their story told:

Coincidentally, she reports that she sent this out to almost 1200 newspapers. She only heard back from a few... To me, THIS is news. Based on the overwhelming number of emails I have received, there are a lot of people out there who are interested in reading about this stuff much more often than reading about the daily reports of the numbers killed or wounded.

Ultimately a very few outlets would bother.

The aftermath of the attack, from yet another GI on the scene:

Sitting in our chow hall this morning, I couldn't help but look at it in another light. I saw the broken bottles of steak sauce mixed with puddles of blood on the floor, the food still steaming on the steam table, littered with rubble from the blast and the absolute chaos that the scene was, even when I got there after everyone had left.

One wonders where the heroes of Mosul had their Christmas dinner this year.

And how's morale in the aftermath? Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld visits the wounded; within hours a stateside blog has an email from a doctor there describing the scene as he approached the bedside of a wounded GI (hat tip Instapundit):

That is when I, without any thought, piped in with "Sir, you can talk to him, he's awake." He told the soldier, named Rob, how proud he was of his service. The soldier was in a bit of disbelief, because he couldn't see with one eye patched and the other swollen shut. He said he wanted to talk to Rumsfeld. That's when I said "He's standing right to your left, Rob, that's his voice you hear. You can talk to him." The kid was nervous at that point, but sputtered out how honored he was to talk to him. Mr. Rumsfeld replied, "No, it's an honor for me to talk to you."

Then remarkably, the young soldier, who had just lost his left hand and right eye from an explosion, came to the defense of the Secretary of Defense, stating "Mr. Rumsfeld, I want you to know, that you are doing a fantastic job. I know that you are taking a lot of heat for the problems with getting armor for vehicles. I want you to know that things are vastly improved. Our vehicles are great, and I have never searched through junk piles for scrap metal."

At this point, Rumsfeld looked choked up, and I had a lump in my throat and and watery eyes. It was moving. What makes a man who has been so close to death, and maimed for life, come to the defense of the Army's highest ranking official? Loyalty, I dare say. Did Rob think Mr. Rumsfeld was having a self-esteem problem? In his greatest hour of need, his thoughts went to the emotional needs of another. I found it quite amazing, and moving. The Secretary took out a coin and gave it to a bystander for him, as if he didn't know he could touch him. Finally, the soldier said, "Man, Donald Rumsfeld, I wish I could shake his hand."

Later the secretary takes Q and A from the troops. CNN played it live on their Daybreak program, but could not have known what was coming. Much of the talk swirls around stop loss issues - often called a "back door draft" by those with little understanding of the seriousness of the military's business - when suddenly another topic arises. As you read it, bear in mind this question is asked by a soldier immediately following a horrific attack. Given the opportunity to address the SecDef, this is what was on his mind:

Timesaver

The terrorists responsible for Mosul Bombing thoughtfully describe their methods:

BAGHDAD ? A video posted by an Iraqi insurgent group yesterday purported to show last week's suicide attack at a U.S. base in Mosul, with a fireball rising from a white tent.

The group said the bomber slipped into the base through a hole in the fence during a guard change ? an operation carried out after a long period of surveillance.

The footage showed a black-garbed gunman wearing an explosives belt around his body ? apparently the suicide bomber, identified in the tape as Abu Omar al-Mosuli ? bidding farewell to his comrades. The video of the pre-suicide ritual gives no details about the bomber beyond his name.

The Ansar al-Sunnah Army earlier had said it would release a video of Tuesday's attack, which killed 22 persons, including 18 U.S. service members and civilian contractors.

The bombing ? the deadliest attack on a U.S. base in Iraq ? prompted a U.S. military investigation into how the bomber got onto the heavily guarded site and how security at bases can be improved.

Three Iraqi national guardsmen and a fourth "non-U.S. person" also were killed. The military has not said whether that fourth man was the bomber.

In the video:

"One of the lions from our martyrdom-seeking brothers will infiltrate the defenses of the enemy at the Morez base in Mosul.

"He will slip through a hole in the camp's wire, exploiting the changing of the guard. We have been observing their schedule for a long time.

"This lion will then proceed to his target, and he will take advantage of lunchtime, when the dining hall is crowded with the crusaders and their [Iraqi] allies.

"The operation will then be carried out. Let Bush, Blair and Allawi know that we are coming and that we will chase them all away, God willing," the terrorist said, referring to President Bush and Prime Ministers Tony Blair of Britain and Iyad Allawi of Iraq.

The two men then embrace the one wearing the explosives belt.

An image then shows a map of the base, as one gunman points out locations using a military knife. One location is marked "the dining hall" in Arabic.

A later outdoor video image ? shot on Tuesday, when the attack occurred ? shows a fireball rising from the distance with the accompanying sound of the explosion. A final image ? shot from a vehicle driving past the base ? shows the torn white tent that served as the base mess hall.

This should help speed up the investigation, and avoid repeats.

All Mrs G wants for Christmas...

...is a soldier coming home.

For those troops that are reading blogs to get closer to home, our thoughts and prayers are with you. We love and miss you.

Merry Christmas,
Keep Safe,
Come home soon.

ps

Greyhawk,

I've spent too much on Christmas presents this year,
I think trying to compensate for you not being here,
but out of all those gifts under the tree,
the only gift these kids want is you to come home safe and free.

XXXXOOOO

(Now this didn't start out to be a poem but after the first three lines it had to end as one. I think there's a poetic bug in the blogosphere air)

Belleau Wood

A Classic!

Belleau Wood

Oh, the snowflakes fell in silence
over Belleau Wood that night
For a Christmas truce had been declared
By both sides of the fight

As we lay there in our trenches
The silence broke in two
By a German soldier singing
A song that we all knew

Though I did not know the language
The song was "Silent Night"
Then I heard my buddy whisper,
"All is calm and all is bright"

Then the fear and doubt surrounded me
"Cause I'd die if I was wrong
But I stood up in my trench
And I began to sing along

Then across the frozen battlefield
Another's voice joined in
Until one by one each man became
A singer of the hymn

Then I thought that I was dreaming
For right there in my sight
Stood the German soldier
'Neath the falling flakes of white

And he raised his hand and smiled at me
As if he seemed to say
Here's hoping we both live
To see us find a better way

Then the devil's clock struck midnight
And the skies lit up again
And the battlefield where heaven stood
Was blown to hell again

But for just one fleeting moment
The answer seemed so clear
Heaven's not beyond the clouds
It's just beyond the fear

No, heaven's not beyond the clouds
It's for us to find it here

The Authors are : Joe Henry and Garth Brooks Copyright 1997Listen to it here

In the mail:

Dear Madam, DearSir, We wish you and your family a wonderful Christmas and all your friends. And a great Thank You to all the people who has supported us to help the wounded Soldiers and Marines in Landstuhl. We will all the wounded troops are staying for recovery over Christmas in LRMC here in Germany a still and peace loving Merry Christmas and a great and good Happy New Year and more Peace of Earth.

Merry Chrismas and Happy New Year

Wilhelmine Aufmkol, Germany
soldiersangels.com
Army Fisher Houses
________________________________________________________________

- Merry Christmas and Happy New Year from home -
to all Soldiers, Civilian and Patients in the US Hospital in Landstuhl,
the Fisher House Landstuhl and the Kleber Barracks in Kaiserslautern!

On the 15th December 2004, a wonderful winter morning with blue sky and white frosted trees, we started with 2 cars our trip to Landstuhl. It was so cold, but no rain and snow! A great day began. So let me tell you: Our day in Landstuhl was, I cannot tell you, overwhelming. It was a large moment to see, that someone is so far away from home and you can treat to him and you see that he is overjoyed and his eyes beam with joy.

This is a story you don?t believe if you have everything what you like to have to live! Rudi told me he has never seen that someone was so happy to get a shower gel! He told me, ?Tell me how anyone can be happy only over a shower gel! As I set up an open box with personal hygiene items at the entrance of the Kleber Barracks because I had something left in my car. I saw as I came back that a soldier in uniform was standing nearby the box and looking in it! ? As my husband saw him the Soldier looked at Rudi and asked him: ?Sir, can I have this shower gel, only the shower gel please?? Rudi looked so surprised and said, ?Yes sure! All the things we have with us are for the soldiers, Sir.? In this moment the Soldier, he has been arrived in Kleber today, looked perfectly happy and he said so many thanks to Rudi. So a shower gel is sometimes such more as an expensive gift what you do not need at the moment!

First I must say ?Thank you? to all the wonderful people who donated so much good things for the 60 backpacks, 25 sport backs, and all the Christmas stockings which arrived here in Germany for to hand out to wounded Soldiers and Marines in LRMC and in the Kleber Barracks.

Our new Angel Mary Ann, an American from Munich, came with us with additional 47 filled backpacks, 20 CD player and 20 special backpacks for wounded women. And so it is the Soldiers Angels hope that we can bring the wounded service members - who are far away from home and loved ones in this holiday season - holiday greetings and a little bit of comfort.

The Fisher House is ?a home away from home?

Irene and Manfred Kilp, Mary Ann and I we met us at 9:30 am in Landstuhl on gate 3. At first we had an invitation to a wonderful musical program at the Fisher House! The Officers' wifes' Club from Ramstein AB were coming to present their Christmas program. They sung Christmas songs for guests of the Fisher House.

Here we met John, a wounded Airborne Division soldier with his wife. John is an outpatient and stays with his wife for recovery in the Fisher House. We wished both a wonderful Christmas under this specific circumstance this year. For his wife we had a nice German/English cooking book and for him a backpack with a handmade blanket and a large Christmas stocking.

A great thank you to Kathy Gregory, manager from the Fisher House Landstuhl for to give us her time to go with us to the wounded soldiers. We don?t know how it could works without Kathy and the Fisher House! Read more here about the Fisher House and how you can help: http://soldiersangels.homestead.com/Fisher-House-Germany.html

from left Manfred, Willie, Rudi and Irene

At the Hospital

LRMC is about eight miles away from Ramstein and is the largest U.S. Medical Center in Europe. It operates with outpatient clinics - one of them is in Kaiserslautern ? the Kleber Kaserne. Landstuhl has a capacity of 230 beds or more if it is necessary. Here you have inpatients who can have battle injuries with gun shot wounds, burns, amputations, or other non battle injuries as heart attacks and so on. And here are outpatients, who can go by themselves and do not need to lay down in a bed for recovery.

As we went to the hospital with Kathy, the manager from Fisher House and SPC W. from the Family Assistance Center with 60 filled backpacks with handmade blankets. Our sewing circles gave their time and sew the blankets for the wounded. These blankets will bring hope to so many of our wounded heroes. The Clair E. Gale Junior High School, ID as well as, Joyce from AZ, Paul and Berta from CA, Rosi from Idaho, Sarah from FL and the students from the East Hill Christian School 1st and 4th grade Pensacola, Fl and other Angels and friends have sent us to fill in the backpacks wonderful Christmas cards. A lot of other Angels have donated T-shirts, socks, underpants, candies, items for personal hygiene, books and more goodies. And we here in Germany have filled all the backpacks and sportbags. And without the personal help from Sgt. Leecharde R. Bersamina from the 1st AD this would not be possible, too.

The 150 Christmas stockings from the Soldiers Angels were a gift bag of goodies filled with reading materials, stationary, pens, socks, and selected toiletry items such as bath gels, shampoos, lotions, razors, dental products, or more goodies.

Operation Christmas From Home

As we handed out the first Christmas stockings in the Hospital the both wounded were so surprised that someone from home was thinking on them. Both asked me at once, "Who has made the wonderful Christmas stockings?" I told them, ??two great ladies, Sarah and Becky, worked over months to make this ready for you!? A doctor who was standing beside the bed of one wounded hero told me, ??it is a great thing that so much people from home spend their time and money to bring our heroes a so great Christmas gift. They must know that they are not alone?? You can believe me the both guys had tears in their eyes!

I'd like to thank Soldiers Angels for their time and dedication to make sure all of our soldiers feel loved.

Tending Distant Fires

Far from hearth and home, watching
Cold alone but not alone
On distant shore and only wanting
Safe return and little more

What tales we'll tell
When that time comes
When tales can be told

When things grim
Seem far away
When other fires go cold

Some distant sunset, vision fading
Memories remain
And tired eyes gaze 'pon folded flags
While distant drums beat their refrain

Saluting fallen friends whose names
And youth will never fade
Here's to those on other shores,
for them live well, the price is paid

- Greyhawk,
-- Iraq, December 2004

Deployed far from home and hearth this Holiday season, awaiting a bit of cheer via comments:

1000 Words from Iraq

2Slick's Forum

Able Kane Adventures

Armor Geddon

Beef Always Wins

Blog Machine City

Dagger JAG

In Iraq for 365

Iraq Calling

Lance in Iraq

A Line in the Sand

The Mudville Gazette

Never heard of this place till now!!!

News from Baghdad

OIF

The Questing Cat

Steven Kiel

Training for Eternity

Tweak's World

Life in This Girl's Army

pure-randomness

NotQuiteDead

DogHostage

RaMrOd's Blog

67TH COMBAT SUPPORT HOSPITAL DOCS

And those who wait:

Trying to Grok

Visit here; spread Christmas cheer
and if you can, throughout the year

(missed any? Leave a comment or email greyhawk@mudvillegazette.com)

MERRY CHRISTMAS, MY FRIEND

MERRY CHRISTMAS, MY FRIEND

‘Twas the night before Christmas, he lived all alone,
In a one-bedroom house made of plaster and stone.
I had come down the chimney, with presents to give
and to see just who in this home did live.

As I looked all about, a strange sight I did see,
no tinsel, no presents, not even a tree.
No stocking by the fire, just boots filled with sand.
On the wall hung pictures of a far distant land.

With medals and badges, awards of all kind,
a sobering thought soon came to my mind.
For this house was different, unlike any I’d seen.
This was the home of a U.S. Marine.

I’d heard stories about them, I had to see more,
so I walked down the hall and pushed open the door.
And there he lay sleeping, silent, alone,
Curled up on the floor in his one-bedroom home.

He seemed so gentle, his face so serene,
Not how I pictured a U.S. Marine.
Was this the hero, of whom I’d just read?
Curled up in his poncho, a floor for his bed?

His head was clean-shaven, his weathered face tan.
I soon understood, this was more than a man.
For I realized the families that I saw that night,
owed their lives to these men, who were willing to fight.

Soon around the Nation, the children would play,
And grown-ups would celebrate on a bright Christmas day.
They all enjoyed freedom, each month and all year,
because of Marines like this one lying here.

I couldn’t help wonder how many lay alone,
on a cold Christmas Eve, in a land far from home.
Just the very thought brought a tear to my eye.
I dropped to my knees and I started to cry.

He must have awoken, for I heard a rough voice,
“Santa, don’t cry, this life is my choice
I fight for freedom, I don’t ask for more.
My life is my God, my country, my Corps.”

With that he rolled over, drifted off into sleep,
I couldn’t control it, I continued to weep.

I watched him for hours, so silent and still.
I noticed he shivered from the cold night’s chill.
So I took off my jacket, the one made of red,
and covered this Marine from his toes to his head.
Then I put on his T-shirt of scarlet and gold,
with an eagle, globe and anchor emblazoned so bold.
And although it barely fit me, I began to swell with pride,
and for one shining moment, I was Marine Corps deep inside.

I didn’t want to leave him so quiet in the night,
this guardian of honor so willing to fight.
But half asleep he rolled over, and in a voice clean and pure,
said “Carry on, Santa, it’s Christmas Day, all secure.”
One look at my watch and I knew he was right,
Merry Christmas my friend, Semper Fi and goodnight.

It's courtesy of WLIT's Melissa Forman (thanks to Sara B. for the link). Below is the credit from WLIT:

Written by former Marine Corporal James M. Schmidt, in 1987 when stationed in Washington D.C., it was pounded out on a typewriter while awaiting the commading officer's Christmas holiday decoration inspection. It was originally title "Merry Christmas, My Friend", and was an instant success that reportedly brought tears to the eyes of the barrracks Commander who ordered it distributed to everyone he knew. It appeared in the barracks publication Pass in Review in December 1987 and Leatherneck Magazine in December 1991.
The poem was recorded as a tribute by Father Ted Berndt, a former Marine and Purple Heart recipient during World War II, currently residing in Dousman, Wisconsin for his daughter Ellen Stout, a Clear Channel radio personality.

My version seems a little different than the Audio. The original poem is here

Hat tip to BlackFive for audio

Remember the Grinch

Does it seem to you that there's lots of bad news lately?

It seems that way to me every year...

A Soldier's Christmas

This is my favorite

A Soldier's Christmas

The embers glowed softly, and in their dim light,
I gazed 'round the room and I cherished the sight;
My wife was asleep, her head on my chest,
My daughter beside me, angelic in rest.

Outside the snow fell....a blanket of white,
Transforming the yard to a winter delight;
The sparkling lights on the tree, I believe,
Completed the magic that was Christmas Eve.

My eyelids were heavy, my breathing was deep,
Secure and surrounded by love I would sleep;
In perfect contentment, or so it would seem.
So I slumbered in peace, then I started to dream.

The sound wasn't loud, and it wasn't too near,
But I opened my eyes when it came to my ear;
Perhaps just a cough, I didn't quite know,
Then the sure sound of footsteps outside in the snow.

My soul gave a tremble. I struggled to hear,
And I crept to the door just to see who was near;
Standing out there alone in the cold of the night,
A lone figure stood, his face weary and tight.

A soldier, I reckoned, some eighteen years old,
Perhaps a Marine, huddled there in the cold;
Alone in the dark, he looked up and smiled,
Standing watch over me, my wife, and my child.

"What are you doing?" I asked without fear,
"Come in this moment! It's freezing out here;
Put down your pack, brush the snow from your sleeve,
You should be at home on this cold Christmas Eve!"

For barely a moment, I saw his eyes shift,
Away from the cold, and the snow in a drift;
To the windows that danced with a warm fire's light,
Then he sighed, and he said, "It's really all right."

"I'm out here by choice. I'm here all the time,
It's my duty to stand at the front of the line;
No one has to ask me, or beg, or implore,
I'm proud to stand here like my father before."

"My grandpa at Pearl, on a day in December,
Is a memory my grandma will always remember;
My dad stood his watch in the jungles of 'Nam,
And now it's my turn, and so, here I am.

I've not seen my family in more than a while,
But my parents send pictures. They're great for a smile."
Then he bent down and carefully pulled from his bag,
The Red, White, and Blue. An American flag.

"I can live through the cold, and this being alone,
Away from my family, my house, and my home;
I can stand at my post through the rain and the sleet,
I can sleep in a foxhole, with little to eat.

I can carry the weight of killing another,
Or lay down my life for my buddy.....my brother;
Who stand here with me against any and all,
To insure for all time that this flag does not fall.

So go back inside," he said, "harbor no fright,
Your family is waiting and I'll be all right."
"But isn't there something I can do, at the least,
Give you some money? Prepare you a feast?

It seems all too little for all that you do,
Being away from your home and your family too."
Then his eyes welled a tear that held no regret,
"Just tell us you love us, and never forget;

To fight for our rights back at home while we're gone;
To stand your own watch, no matter how long.
For when we come home, wither standing or dead,
To know you remember we fought and we bled,
Is payment enough, and with that we will trust,
That we mattered to you, as you mattered to us."

By Michael Marks? 2000

Global
SpecOps

Soldier On

In the aftermath of the bombing in Mosul, life goes on:

Sitting in our chow hall this morning, I couldn?t help but look at it in another light. I saw the broken bottles of steak sauce mixed with puddles of blood on the floor, the food still steaming on the steam table, littered with rubble from the blast and the absolute chaos that the scene was, even when I got there after everyone had left.

There is no other option.

Where are you having Christmas dinner this year?

Rumsfeld

The last straw. Fire this man, Mr Rove, fire him now!

Christmas Eve Question

Christmas Eve Question

"Mommy, who brings Santa presents?"
(it was his hundredth question of the day)
His little face gazed up solemnly;
She was at a loss for words to say.

She hugged him tight and smoothed his blanket
and thought of Santa and all that flying
?round a world caught up in tragedy,
a world at risk ? so many dying.

Yet this unselfish five year old
with Christmas starlight in his eyes
had to think and wonder who
would give Santa his own surprise.

Then carefully she chose her words
so he would understand
how the scope of Santa?s trip
?cross each and every land.

"Your Daddy and men like him, son,
give Santa gifts this night
each time he leaves the North Pole,
they help him plan his flight."

"They tell him when it?s safe to fly
so he?ll come to no harm
from our Okinawan high rise
to the smallest German farm.?

?In camouflage they guard him
from every dune to each oasis ?
in deserts torn apart by war,
bringing gifts to hiding places.?

?Helicopters are his mountain escort,
protecting him at such a price!
So Afghani boys and girls like you
Will have candy, toys and even rice.?

?When he flies over seas and oceans
ships and carriers light his way
while submarines listen in on sonar ?
none will let him go astray.?

?Men like Daddy guard the White House too,
as they watch our flag fly free,
then map out a route past the ?No Fly Zone?
towards Grandma?s in Albany.?

?He whispers his thanks to those standing guard
in Arlington, this dark lonely eve;
bows his head in respect for those who have died,
asking comfort for those who grieve.?

?He?ll stop off quick at Quantico,
and Parris Island too,
they?ll refill his pack with toys there,
for kids not as lucky as you.?

At Camp Pendleton he?ll land the sleigh ?
For the reindeer need to rest
And even Santa needs to eat and drink
(they?ve left cookies and milk in the mess.)?

?So you see sweetheart, he does get gifts
all through our Christmas Eve night.
He?s safe, he?s guided, protected and loved
Throughout his worldwide flight.?

?Men like Daddy give him the same gifts
they bestow on the world each day.
All gifts can?t be wrapped up in ribbons and bows,
can you see what I?m trying to say??

and we can stay calm and serene.
He belongs to the world, but especially us ?
You see, Santa was once a Marine.?

by: Paula

TO YOU AT CHRISTMAS

To those that are grieving our lost soldiers.

If I could do whatever I want to do
To make complete your gladsome Christmas-Day,
I would not bring a single thing to you,
But I would come and take some things away.

I'd take away all trouble from your heart,
Each pain and sorrow I would have relieved;
And every word that caused a single smart,
And every hour through which you sadly grieved.

I'd have them all begone - forever gone
Forgotten like the things that cannot be
And then each hour would be a joyful one
For only good things would be left, you see

Now that is what I'd really like to do,
If I could do the things I wish for you.

-Author Unknown

Mosul

More

Rocket

Bingo

Tony Blair and Iyad Allawi, in Iraq yesterday:

Question:

Prime Minister, can you just give us a sense of your feelings today. You flew here in secrecy, under armed protection, into what is still a safe zone, more than a year and a half after Saddam fell. Can you honestly say to yourself, this is what I meant to bring about when I said that we will ...?

Prime Minister:

That is a good question. I will tell you exactly what I felt coming in. Security is really heavy, you can feel the sense of danger that people live in here, but what I felt more than anything else was this, the danger that people feel here is coming from terrorists and insurgents who are trying to destroy the possibility of this country becoming a democracy. Now where do we stand in that fight? We stand on the side of the democrats, against the terrorists. And so when people say to me well look at the difficulties, look at the challenges, I say well what is the source of that challenge? The source of that challenge is a wicked destructive attempt to stop this man, this lady, all these people from Iraq who want to decide their own future in a democratic way, having that opportunity. And where should the rest of the world stand, to say well that is your problem, go and look after it, or you were better off with Saddam running the country, as if the only choice they should have in the world is a choice between a brutal dictator killing hundreds of thousands of people, or terrorists and insurgents. There is another choice for Iraq, the choice is democracy, the choice is freedom, and our job is to help them get there because that is what they want. And you know sometimes when I see some of the reporting of what is happening in Iraq in the rest of the world, I just feel that people should understand how precious what is being created here is. And those people from that Electoral Commission that I have described as the heroes of the new Iraq, every day, a lot of them aren't living in the green zone, they have got to travel in from outside, they do not know at any point in time whether they are going to be subject to brutality or intimidation, even death, and yet they carry on doing it. Now what a magnificent example of the human spirit, and that is the side we should be on.

Dr Allawi:

I may add a few points to what Prime Minister Blair has said. Iraqis do not see what happened as invasion, as I clearly said that we deeply appreciate the commitment of the international community to have helped the Iraqi people to rid Iraq of ... and to stand with us in fighting terrorism. Frankly what you see now, the security, is a manifestation of a war that is being waged against us by evil forces. We have to stand firm, we have to stand tall, we have to defeat the insurgents, we have to defeat the evil forces, we have to defeat terror, and this is really to protect the whole world and the generations to come. We are adamant that we are going to proceed with the democracy, with the freedom, with the rule of law, with respect of human rights, these are the important values that have been brought into Iraq, and for the first time the Iraqis feel the sense of liberty, it is a dream which is becoming true. We don't expect forces ... against us just to stand idle, to see this huge construction going ahead in a peaceful way. This what you see now, inshallah will disappear in the very near future.

Words not intended to address yesterday's events, but remarkably apropos.

All We Want for Christmas...

This is beautifully written, and thought it would be befitting to all those lost.

Twas the night before Christmas, the house seemed so sad, Early this year, this family lost ?Dad.? He?d been a soldier, in Afghanistan serving, To help people live free, now thankful, deserving.

His wife and the kids have cried a river of tears,
They had known this could happen, through all of the years.
It?s a dangerous business, no place for wimps.
Some don?t come home, some others with limps.

As I slipped down the chimney, I really did dread?
That I?d fall straight apart in this house with war dead.
I crept from the hearth, wondering what would I see,
What my eyes would behold, in this land of the free.

The home was decorated, with the tree and some lights
The milk, plate of cookies, and some other tasty bites.
Next to this was a note, from the boys up in bed,
I picked the page up and here?s what it said.

Please go read the full version written by MajorDad

THE HOLIDAYS

The holidays

Well the holidays are here.
Everyone is filled with christmas cheer,
But the life of a soldier is so alone,
As he leaves his wife and kids at home.

He's serving his country in some foreign land,
He longs just to hold his daughter's hand.
From the smiles on her pretty face,
To her little dresses, made with lace.

He wishes and dreams of being home on
Christmas day. To sit and watch her see
If things went her way.

I hope you get everything that you wanted,
And then some too.
I promise you sweetie,
Daddy will be home soon.

Merry christmas
I love you,
Daddy

By Keith Goins

How Will the Media Spin This One?

The Washington Times provides background on 'Chemical Ali', expected to be the first member of Saddam's regime to stand trial:

On March 16, 1988, 5,000 residents of Halabja, a Kurdish city in eastern Iraq, were killed and 10,000 injured when Saddam Hussein's army attacked with chemical weapons ? perhaps the largest-scale use of such weapons against a civilian population in modern times. That morning, Iraqi Air Force planes bombed the city with a lethal chemical cocktail of mustard gas and sarin, tabun and VX nerve agents. Two days ago, the man accused of overseeing the attack, Gen. Ali Hasan al-Majid, also known as Chemical Ali, appeared before a judicial tribunal in Baghdad. He is likely to go on trial next year for war crimes, genocide and crimes against humanity in connection with Halabja and a series of other atrocities allegedly carried out by forces under his command.

In Halabja on that terrible day, families hiding in their basements (the safest place to be when Iraqi troops launched conventional artillery attacks) began vomiting and died of suffocation as a result of the chemical weapons attack. As the gas spread, birds began dropping out of trees, cows collapsed and women and children attempting to flee the city went blind. As children fell, their panic-stricken parents abandoned them by the side of the roads leading out of town. Dr. Christine Gosden, a professor of medical genetics at the University of Liverpool in Great Britain, who has visited Halabja to study the effects of chemical weapons, reported that long-term effects of their use include eye and respiratory problems, severe skin problems, mental difficulties, miscarriages and infant deaths.

<...>

Later, addressing members of the Iraqi Ba'ath Party, al-Majid spoke about the Kurds on a tape obtained by Human Rights Watch: "I will kill them all with chemical weapons...Who is going to say anything? The international community? F?- them!"

How will the media spin it? Here are some early indicators:

The London Telegraph: Trial of Chemical Ali can't end the suffering of his victims

The Seattle Times: Iraqis criticized for secret hearings

Dallas Mornng News: Hearings for Hussein regime blasted

The Washington Post: Can this man get a fair trial?

The trial is at least a month away.

Free Time

The headline over this story reads "Brash Guardsman Isn't Sorry":

The National Guardsman who put Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld on the spot about having to scavenge metal to boost the armor on military vehicles says he has no regrets.

In speaking out for the first time, Thomas Wilson declared: "If this is my 15 minutes of fame, I hope it saves a life."

"Why do we soldiers have to dig through local landfills?" he asked Rumsfeld in a Q&A nearly two weeks ago. The secretary's response, that "You go to war with the Army you have," spawned a storm of criticism.

"Personally, I didn't like that answer," Wilson told Time magazine, though he was quick to add he meant no disrespect and that he is a big supporter of President Bush. But Wilson brushed off reports that he was coached by a reporter to quiz Rumsfeld.

The reporter "suggested a less brash way of asking the question," he added. But "I told him no, that I wanted to make my point very clear," Wilson said.

That, of course, is the Reader's Digest Condensed version of the give-and-take between the two. But hey, why let facts interfere with the story?

Sorry or not, however, now that the claim that Spc Wilson's unit was traveling into Iraq with unarmored Humvees has been declared false he may soon be a sorry son of a bitch.

Meanwhile, Spc Keith Lucas actually is in Iraq, and spending a lot of his time clearing roadside bombs. He does have off-duty time though:

Spc. Keith Lucas, a Missouri National Guardsman on duty clearing bombs from roads in Iraq, participated Saturday in the commencement ceremony at the University of Missouri-St. Louis with the help of a satellite hookup. ?Hopefully, we'll get back real soon,? Lucas told fellow graduates watching him live on a giant screen. The 26-year-old mass communications major was given a minute-long ovation. Lucas' family accepted the diploma on his behalf. ?It shouldn't be just for him ? it's for all those guys over there,? said his father, Larry. Keith Lucas is due back in the states in February.

Not sure if Spc Wilson will have that much free time on his deployment... (que the NCOs...)

Tanks!

Hugh Hewitt, on Time magazine noting a "blog of the year":

This recognition is greatly deserved but also a little ironic --as if, in 1940, the radio networks got together to award a "television reporter of the year" award.

Geeesh, some people just can't show simple gratitude.

The fact that it's been a year since my response to Time's cover story reminds me that after another year with an increasing number of front-line blogs, emails home, and other real-time communication from GIs here we've seen little change from some sources in tone of coverage on the supposed "GI view" of the war. The fact that the media storyline hasn't changed is not surprising, the fact that so many are willing to believe it is unfortunate.

The fact that blogs have come a long way in that same 12 months shows that increasing numbers of people are not so inclined, and I remain hopeful for the year ahead.

So continue to put words in our mouths at your own risk, you priests of a crumbling temple. We've our own platform now, and we'll call you down from that lofty tower...

Here's OIF vet Jason Van Steenwyk responding to the Christian Science Monitor via letter.

Here's Michael at A Day in Iraq recounting stories of his previous assignment in Iraq and his ongoing preparations to return here. A quote: "I can't think of anywhere else I would rather spend over a year of my life."

Now I could name a couple, (but here's to better years!) but I recognize his sincerity, and I know exactly what he means. Others in DCUs do too.
How would a cynical mainstream media respond to such?

Cori Dauber notes another case of the "demoralized military a la Vietnam" theme in the press.

Rick Atkinson, author of the subject piece, wrote the book "In the Company of Soldiers", one of least informative accounts I've ever read from an embed on the invasion of Iraq. Atkinson recounts a large share of the negative reporting throughout the actual march on Baghdad; we trained for the wrong foe, sand and dust will stop us, Baghdad will be a nightmare of door-to-door combat, etc. etc. Even after the fact in the book he couldn't really bring himself to rise above his pre-war conclusions that 1) the war was unjustified and all about oil and 2) the war was a series of U.S. failures culminating in the capture of Baghdad but so what?

Atkinson from Soldiers:

On Forward Area Refueling Points (FARPs):

With stupefying obtuseness, the military had named the FARPs for oil companies, despite Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld's insistence that the invasion of a country with 112 billion barrels of confirmed reserves had "nothing to do with oil, literally nothing to do with oil".

On the motivation of U.S. Soldiers:

But most soldiers evinced a cool detachment toward their potential Iraqi adversaries. Certainly no hate lodged in their bones. Many had an inchoate conviction that this deployment was somehow linked to the terror attacks of September 11, 2001, a delusion encouraged by the nation's political leadership. Long before 9/11, however, the Army had become an expeditionary force that careered among global hot spots. If they were modern legionnaires, these soldiers nevertheless thought of themselves as defenders of a secular faith embracing sundry liberties and entitlements, including many that were noble, and others - such as the daily consumption of more than 25 percent of the world's oil supply by only 5 percent of the world's population - that were less so.

On finding a warehouse complex full of boxes labeled 'Oil-for-Food':

As we poked about, I catalogued the emporium. Warehouse No. 4: fifty-kilo sacks of sugar from France and twenty thousand bags of black tea from India. Warehouse No. 10: cooking oil from Malaysia. Warehouse No. 19: detergent powder - the place smelled like a lemon grove - from Algeria and Syria. Warehouse No. 5 was my favorite: bed sheets, Phillips flat-screen televisions, men's underwear, throw rugs, light bulbs, candles, compressors, pencils, erasers, light switches, trash bags, and, not least, a carton of box cutters. Perhaps, I thought, we had found the elusive link to Al-Qaeda.

That final comment being particular ironic in light of the growing Oil for Food scandal.

His otherwise straightforward account is marred by political injections into what is actually a 90 percent non-political look at an army at war. But in the end - perhaps in fear of being labeled a "Bushie" - he can't resist spilling his personal views out onto the page. His opinions on the war are anything but inchoate; his attacks are like little IEDs shoehorned in at various spots throughout his prose, catching you when you're off guard.

Atkinson's previous effort, "An Army at Dawn", was a Pulitzer Prize-winning account of WWII battles in North Africa, a campaign marked by initial failures that nonetheless set the foundation for eventual victory. In "Soldiers" he actually recounts learning he'd been honored with the Pulitzer while in Iraq during the war. I haven't read that one, but I'd expect his problem is presenting real-time data vs. history, the latter being somewhat more malleable in the hands of someone unconcerned with accuracy, or a response from those who were there. Perhaps he expects that years from now his work on Iraq will be the definitive shaper of thoughts on this age?

Here's a quote from his latest article:

But as this war grinds on, as these dead stack up, soldiers and their families are faced with the appalling suspicion that their troops are risking their lives in a cause that is uncertain at best and illegitimate at worst.

The son of an Army officer, Atkinson is ever careful to wrap his nay saying in a thin armor of feeble praise for those in uniform. But guys like Michael or Red Six or 2Slick keep showing up on the horizon, and certain 'embeds' would do well to take note.

Even tanks get destroyed some times, don't you know.

Last edition of "Good news from Iraq" for 2004

Dear Mr & Mrs Greyhawk

Wishing you a relaxing and happy Christmas and an exciting - and safe - 2005; and thanking you for your support throughout this year.

This is the last edition of "Good news from Iraq" for 2004 - as always, there's plenty of news under-reported by the mainstream media - and as Iraq is moving closer to the election, the segment will definitely be coming back in 2005:

Chrenkoff

Opinion Journal

Winds of Change

Best regards

Arthur

The Medic?s Christmas Poem

Let's not forget the ones that do their best to patch our boys up before they send them home:

"'Twas the night before Christmas as I flew o'er the Army Post,
when I spied a young man who seemed out of place.
His eyes showed compassion, his hair a bit short,
but his head was held high and his body was strong.

His air was confident, his uniform smart,
but what impressed me most was the size of his heart.
For he embodied honor, one of this country's best,
and the words U.S. Army showed large on his chest.

As I stood there in wonder and gazed into his eyes,
the words that he spoke took me quite by surprise.
"What's wrong Santa, haven't you ever seen a Medic before?"
I sensed something special and longed to know more.

"To be honest, this field thing wasn't part of my plan,
but the Army didn't give me a hospital or garrison."
The words he spoke next surprised me all the more,
"But I'm as proud of my Unit as I am of the Army!"

"Don't worry Santa, that I'm a Medic you see,
for when a Soldier goes down they will still call on me.
They'll forget I'm a Soldier, they'll call in my stock.
At the top of their lungs they'll yell ,"Medic!"

"And I'll answer that call, anytime, anywhere.
Though I know I'm a target I really don't care.
I'll face incoming fire as I race cross the land,
and use my very own body to shield a downed man."

"Working long hours and into the night,
my unit's battle is over, but I'm just starting to fight.
For the life of every Soldier is sacred to me.
I refuse to surrender them to death, and in that I'll find victory."

"And yet I'll take the time to comfort a dying man,
to sit down by his side, to reach out and hold his hand.
For it takes as much courage to care as to fight.
For just as the poem says, many don't "go gently into that night."

"Santa, it's not any one uniform that makes you a man,
but rather it's those ideals for which you choose to stand.
I draw my line here, it's long and it's plain.
For pain, hurt and suffering are the things I disdain."

I know very well that I may lose my life,
So that a Soldier may see an unmet child and young wife.
So Santa, it really doesn't matter if they don't like my hair.
I'm a Army Medic, their Doc, and I'll always be there."

"I follow the brave docs who have come long before,
from North Africa, Korea, and Vietnam?s shore.
As history proudly shows, they all gave their best,
and for those who have died, surely they're blessed."

"At Inchon, the gulf and times during Tet,
our brothers have fallen, but we carry on yet.
For we carry their honor and legacy still."
As I held back my tears it took all of my will.

I had to leave him there for I had other plans,
but I knew in my heart that the Army is in good hands.
As I flew away I heard his laughter, it rang so loud and clear.
"Hey Santa, how 'bout a nice pair of boots for the 26 miler next year?"

An enigmatic farewell?

From Ali

Blog Power

I, a GI in Iraq, found this through Power Line.

By the way, if you?re interested in what combat troops have to say about the armor issue, read this.

And in the amazing coincidence department, that story also involves Sgt Lizzie

Hat tip for those last two to Sarah.

USO

Friday night, my kids and I went to see the visiting USO show that just came from Iraq and Afaganistan. Greyhawk was kind enough to work the shift so that his boys could see the show, so he missed the USO's visit to Iraq. Here's my report Greyhawk.

The Tops and Blue entertained us while we waited for the show to begin and they were some very talented singers.

The show started with the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Richard Myers.

Robin William, John Elway, Blake Clark and a pin up model, Leann Tweeden were here and performed a great show. These guys have been very busy. The day before this, John Elway, Robin Williams, Leeann Tweeden and Blake Clark listen to remarks by General Richard B. Myers at the ground breaking ceremony for the Pat Tillman USO center at Bargram AB, Afghanistan.

Now at our show Leann talked about her dad being in Vietnam and what USO ment to him and how these help make it happen.

Then John Elway came out a threw a few autograghed footballs.
My 5'1 and three quarter" frame had no chance at catching one of these.

Blake Clark, who was an infantry platoon leader in Vietnam, was hiliarious.
His impression of Steve Irwin the crocidile hunter catching Al qaeda was great.

Then for the grand finally, Robin Williams who was in top form making everyone laugh till they cried.
May he live to be a 100, like the legendary BoB Hope.

Now the real stars of the evening were these folks.

The wounded soldiers from Landstuhl medical center that were well enough to come out in the cold to see the show. (The ones in desert camo. Sorry for the bad pic, couldn't get close enough for a good shot.)

All in all it was a great show and although I would have liked for it to have been a little longer, those wounded soldiers that couldn't come out, were not going to be left out. Robin and the rest of the USO group paid a vist to the wounded a Landstuhl Regional Medical Center after the show.

The USO’s commitment to be America’s link with her men and women in uniform has and will always provide a "touch of home" for as long as we have those in service to our country and for that I thank them.

A Christmas Bow for My Soldier

A Christmas Bow for My Soldier

Our yellow ribbon has faded, so we tied a new one tight
A bold symbol to represent your spirit glowing with Christmas light,
It's color reminds us of all you are going through
And your heart of love that beats for what is true.

More than ever at Christmas, we do want you...to come home to stay,
But as God has another plan, we'll try hard to be brave on this special day.
Oh how so dearly we wish..you were with us here,
Home in our hearts, forever near.

How much we want to hold you...close and never let you go,
To keep you from harm, no more suffering to know.
We are praying angel comfort for you in all your pain,
So you will feel the peace of Christmas instead of chilling rain.

For, you have such courage..brave loyalty in your heart,
A call to be a blessing where you are, that keeps us apart.
So, while we'll miss you so..our hearts also beat with pride,
As we celebrate yuletide this year, without you by our side.

But, in spirit you are here..just as if you never went away,
For the Christmas love we share, means you will be with us on our day.
Close forever, never to part..held together for the same arms,
Up-hold us, as the ones that keep your soul from harm.

Each day we wake and pray God your heart to keep,
And may you dream many sweet memories as you sleep,
While you lay beneath the shining stars above,
Surrounded by eternal love.

God brought you into His world so long ago,
For you to set others free from the tyrrany of the foe,
You go forth every day, with your life to give.
That precious little ones may come to know truth and be free to live,.

We send you our blessing, we send you our Christmas love
If somehow our wishes can bring you light from above,
To surround your heart with that first Christmas joy and peace,
So that litttle boy delight will never cease.

The color of your life will never fade, your rich beauty is tied in place
and your light will glow forever...for in our heart, we see your face.

Soft Whispers from
Derry's Heart Poems© 2003

Oh Well, Maybe Next Year

Surely this is the big story in your local daily:

NEW YORK Once again, newspaper reporters score poorly in the annual Gallup Poll, released today, on ?honesty and ethical standards? in various professions, as judged by the American public. They rank even lower than bankers, auto mechanics, elected officials, and nursing-home operators.

To put this in perspective: Newspaper reporters are even less respected than their TV counterparts.

Somehow, however, they top lawyers, car salesmen, and ad directors. And they also edge business executives and congressmen

The list:

At the top, 79% gave nurses high or very high marks. Other categories, in order: grade school teachers, pharmacists, military officers, doctors, police officers, clergy, judges, day-care providers, bankers, auto mechanics, local officeholders, nursing home operators, state officeholders, TV reporters, and then newspaper reporters.

A lot of fine reporters in the world should be outraged at their fellows who bring them low. Of course, this story says nothing about who's who and why the results are as they are.

By the way, you nurses, teachers, and pharmacists better watch you backs...

Salute

Denzel Washington is a stand up guy:

Washington had offered to help present Purple Heart medals Friday to Spinks and two other soldiers wounded in Iraq.

Hospital officials said the idea of a San Antonio visit was first suggested to him by an unidentified veteran known as "Ranger Jones," who met the actor during the 1988 filming of "Glory."

Washington told about 300 patients, soldiers and hospital staff members at the medal ceremony that he felt honored to recognize "such brave men and women." Besides pinning medals on the three soldiers, he also visited about 20 other patients Friday.

"As is often the case, when you think you're coming to give something, you end up receiving so much more," he said.

With his wife and four of his children nearby, he drew a roar of applause when he pledged support of America's military.

"I guess you read a lot about quote-unquote 'celebrities' being anti-war, and anti-this, or whatever they anti-," he said. "But you know this particular celebrity supports you 100 percent."

Also in attendance were two Medal of Honor recipients from the Vietnam War, retired Col. Robert W. Howard and Maj. Alfred Rascon. Both got standing ovations.

Voices of Iraq

Jeff Jacoby reviews the film Voices of Iraq, which we introduced here.

Elsewhere here's one former Saddam loyalist looking to start a singing career.

Harrison Ford will star in an upcoming movie about Fallujah.

Tim Blair reminds us of a recent Ford quote on Iraq.

From The Jag

Eric at Dagger Jag has been working issues with the Iraqi elections. In one of his posts on that topic he also introduces something you likely haven't heard of:

Today we conducted another detainee release mission. I've wrote about one way back during the summer but things have changed a bit since then. We still conduct the release missions every week or two. The detainees come up from Abu Ghraib on busses or trucks and we meet them in Tikrit and escort the busses to a smaller village outside of Tikrit. There, they are released at a "halfway house" of sorts.

The Iraqis running this program wanted to establish a way to reintegrate the detainees into Iraqi society and try to educate them and encourage them to help work for the future of Iraq. The detainees receive new clothes and are checked out by an Iraqi doctor. Then they are fed and picked up by their host families. A number of local families in the town have agreed to house the released detainees and help them reintegrate into Iraqi society. The town has been very peaceful throughout the whole time we've been here and, because of that, they have reaped a lot of benefits. Some of that might be a quid pro quo but I much of it is because contractors can work safely there and we are willing to help them with their needs. The families show the former detainees what can happen to an area that is peaceful.

For three days the released detainees attend classes at the "halfway house." They receive classes on how to use a computer and the internet (something that might or might not be useful to them) but most of the classes are on Iraqi history, religion, and politics. The goal is to motivate these men to take charge and work for the good of THEIR country. It really is an amazing program and, by all accounts, successful as well. Many of the detainees go back to their homes afterwards and keep in touch with the director. Some have even come back and helped out with later classes. It has been the most encouraging thing for me especially since all of this was done without our prompting or funding. The director is a remarkable man who developed the program and is paying for it with his own funds and with donations from other Iraqis. He has told me, and I agree, that the program is much more successful because they are not associated with the US military. They are Iraqis taking care of other Iraqis.

Read it all.

He's got more on the halfway house here.

Excerpt:

The director shared another anecdote with me about a released detainee who explained to the group how before he was detained, he thought all Americans were like Saddam Hussein's goons; cruel monsters who used their power to do whatever they wanted and killed anyone who got in the way. He said that when he was detained he was treated well and actually made friends with some of the prison guards. He said he had completely changed his mind about the Americans and wanted to tell everyone he used to hang out with not to attack the Americans anymore. Now I don't know how much of this is true but it does sound like the program is doing some good.

And more on the upcoming elections here.

A Military Christmas

Any one in the military can relate to this one:

A Military Christmas

Dad was in the Navy, during Christmas we were seldom back home.
We spent our holidays in different states, sometimes rather alone.
We spent Christmas over seas in a number of foreign lands.
Christmas was never conducted according to a civilian plan.

No going over to Grandma's house, to eat a Christmas meal.
In 20 years we got there twice, that was a major deal.
We would drive a thousand miles, to be there Christmas Eve.
Days later it was time to go, dad was out of military leave.

We would drive all night to get back, to the Naval base.
This ended yet another, cross-country Christmas race.
Finish our favorite holiday food, crackers with cheese dip,
Dad would drive out to the pier, to sign back-in to the ship.

We all loved going onboard ship for a holiday meal.
My sisters ate all the shrimp that they could peel.
I would talk to the mess-cooks standing in the chow line.
Dependent meals on shipboard were always a magical time.

During my Air Force career I got home for Christmas only a time or two,
But my Air Force spouse made a holiday of white, not of Elvis blue.
Christmas dinner was with our GI friends, who could not get "home,"
Sometimes over twenty, no one was left alone.

G.I. s and sailors are your family when stationed far from home.
In my day no e-mail and in most cases you couldn't even phone.
Christmas cards went early, because of the long homeward flight.
Anyone's holiday mail was a G.I. shared delight.

Cards, pictures and cookies enjoyed with a Marine cohort.
Moments later defending the line; Christmas can be rather short.
War doesn't stop for the troops because of a national holiday.
Even on the 25th someone is earning their combat pay.

I am an old retiree sitting back in my rocking chair.
But my wife is still active duty performing the mission out there.
We are always on the move, from air base to air base,
In my old age, this military stuff, keeps picking up the pace.

We're at a comfortable "state-side" base this winter holiday.
Somewhere a troop is earning, Christmas hazardous-duty pay.
Please take care of "your" sailor, marine or G.I. this holiday season.
To appreciate your troops never needs a reason.

We are at an Air Force base, out west this Christmas year.
No grandparents, no siblings, not even my in-laws are here.
It's another military holiday and we are far from "home."
But I have my wife, my daughter and the dogs--we are not alone.

We choose to be in a military, that on holidays takes us far and wide.
But we serve our nation, maybe even with a little selfish pride.
We are doing something right for this wonderful homeland.
She is a military woman and I am a military man.

Enjoy this holiday season, remember who keeps you safe at home.
Think of the Sailor, Marine or G.I. out there feeling quite alone.
They choose to be there, even on Christmas night.
Support your troops, what they do for this country, is indeed right.

Thanks to veterans who have done military Christmas in the past.
The new troops continue the tradition, to make our freedom last.
Sleep well this Christmas Eve, at home in your warm bed.
To our military, defending the nation, full speed ahead.

Major Van Harl USAF Ret.
20 December 2003

Global
SpecOps

Christian Science?

A reader writes:

Dear Greyhawk,

As a loyal reader, may I submit a special request? I'd be interested to know your thoughts (as someone "on the ground") about this article in the Christian Science Monitor. I have to admit, it has me a little worried.

Stop worrying.

So, The Christian Science Monitor has departed from its usual mission of monitoring Christian Scientists to present us with a front page piece on the shambles that is the American Military today. Since it's a recitation of so many of the themes popular with the anti-military crowd in the media these days it's worth the effort to address them all in one place. Having read that story I do have a few minor issues with it.

Issue 1 - It's a page 1 story. Actually that's only a problem if it's an opinion vice news piece. Is it? That's to be determined.

Issue 2 - the author, Brad Knickerbocker. We'll not refute any of Brad's claims based on who he is, nor will we question his objectivity, but the reader deserves to know his background before making any judgments, don't you think?

Brad has covered the war extensively for Christian Science Monitor. Here, for example is a recent piece attempting to calculate the possible number of civilian casualties in Iraq. The link is actually to a reprint of the work found at CounterCurrents.org, a site with sections on Iraq, Palestine, climate change, globalisation, US imperialism, etc., etc., etc. Along with Knickerbocker reprints they also feature Fidel Castro diatribes for your enlightenment.

In fact, reprints of Brad's stories are a favorite at "anti-war" sites; here's a list of those you can find via the Why War? web site, which prominently features this (non-Knickerbocker) quote on their front page:

Al-Qa’ida is neither irrational nor unable to intelligently articulate their objectives. The American government is able to disseminate propaganda globally while suppressing al-Qa’ida’s response. Thus, the English speaking world is forced to trust the analysis of al-Qa’ida provided by those who have shown themselves willing to lie in their pursuit of an unjust war. If the American public had been able to read al-Qa'ida documents they would have known that al-Qa’ida was explicit about their joy in America’s overthrow of Saddam Husayn.

They also offer a line of anti-war bumperstickers that would look perfect on any color Toyota Prius.

Certainly the fact that he's a favorite author of these sorts doesn't imply that he endorses their opinions; the inverse, however, is apparently true.

He's not just an anti-war guy though, he also did a few scare pieces. Here's a round-up his articles on the imminent chemical, biological and nuclear threat faced by the US in 2002. (Those halcyon days when 'anti-war' didn't "sell") As with the other sites we'll assume Brad has no idea his work is reproduced there - but we'll all certainly appreciate that as a result of the courageous reporting of the Brad Knockerbockers of America the threat has yet to materialize.

Enough of the past! Brad's latest piece breaks new ground, combining his "anti-war" attitude with his "scare" tactic to create a powerful hole. The first couple of paragraphs are not an issue (in fact, since I'm wearing combat boots and can't count beyond ten, I'll dispense with numbering the issues), they are just an introduction, establishing his command of the topic and presenting unsupported claims we assume the remainder of the story is designed to prove.

Without further ado, here's Brad:

Griping among the troops is as old as armed conflict, illustrated most memorably by cartoonist Bill Mauldin's "Willie and Joe" characters during World War II. But something more than that is happening now in Iraq with what appears to be growing resistance from the troops.

Evidence includes numbers of deserters (reportedly in the thousands), resignations of reserve officers, lawsuits by those whose duty period has been involuntarily extended, and a refusal to go on dangerous missions without proper equipment. There's also been a willingness at grunt level to publicly challenge the Pentagon - as Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld found out recently in a trip to the war zone, where he got an earful about unarmored humvees.

For the record, I'm not personally aware of any war-related desertions. (I do know of a couple - Jeremy Hinzman and Pablo Paredes - due to the extensive press coverage they've received, and I'm sure there are others.) My personal experience is limited though, I'm only personally involved with just under a thousand GI's. Hmmm... I guess my experience does exceed that of Brad Knickerbocker, but that says nothing as to his right to offer his opinion. Let's move on.

While some don't see much defiance - and, in fact, have been surprised by the depth of solidarity - others see an unusual amount of tension surfacing for an all-volunteer military force.

"Some" and "others" - irrefutable, ironclad! In an effort to render my personal bias transparent, I admit freely I'm amongst "some", though I don't deny the existence of "others". I've seen this phenomenon with my own eyes - some soldiers enjoy food in the DFAC, others prefer MRE's. Likewise, while some people trust reporters, others do not. I'll spare you the endless litany of constructions regarding "some and others". Some of you will appreciate that, others will not. It would be nice if journalists were trained at schools that discouraged use of such statements, as everyone will agree.

Enough of that. If you're like me, the burning question you're asking right now is "What is driving the resistance?"

"What is driving the resistance is the same thing that drove it during Vietnam - a lack of trust in the civilian leadership and a sense that the uniformed leaders are not standing up for the forces," says retired Army Col. Dan Smith, a military analyst with the Friends Committee on National Legislation in Washington. Colonel Smith doesn't expect the kind of "fragging" incidents that occurred in Vietnam where soldiers attacked their own officers. "This force is too professional," he says. "But the lack of trust and the inequity of the tours will very likely be reflected in the numbers of Guard and reservists who vote no-confidence with their feet."

Were I the suspicious sort, I'd highlight that Vietnam quote above. James Taranto isn't suspicious either, he identifies Brad as a "Vietnam nostalgist". That sounds right to me.

I am suspicious when I see organizations named and not explained. Just what is "The Friends Committee on National Legislation"? We'll assume that Brad answered that question but the explanation was edited out for space in the final edition.

I have no problem with space. "The Friends Committee on National Legislation" a Quaker group - which is fine by me - the Quakers are a religious group dedicated to peace and justice for all mankind and they were anti-war when anti-war wasn't cool (1862, for instance). Dan Smith is listed on their site as a Senior Fellow, Military and Peaceful Prevention Policy.

Their cause is indeed noble, but failing to mention the agenda of the quoted expert would cause some to question the agenda of the author and publishers of the story. I wouldn't, of course, since this is a page one article it's obviously not an opinion piece.

But defining the speaker doesn't address the claims - but as those claims are as yet unsupported we can't refute them. "Soldiers are discontented" you say. I reply "No" - and there you have it.

But here comes the support:

That's the Spirit!

From the Orlando Sentinal, a story headlined American Spirit Takes Root In Iraq:

'Tis the season, and Americans deserve some holiday cheer. Herewith some of the good things happening in Iraq, beginning with Omar and Mohammed.

Regular travelers of the blogosphere, that rare and wonderful new universe where bloggers post news, commentary and other ruminations on the Web, may be familiar with the names Omar and Mohammed.

They, too, are bloggers. In Iraq with brother Ali, they created a blog called Iraq The Model, through which they've kept the blogosphere abreast of events from their native, on-the-ground perspective.

Last week, Omar, 24, and Mohammed, 35, both dentists, came to the United States to meet their American blogging counterparts and to shake hands with someone they hold in high esteem -- President George W. Bush. They wanted to thank him.

The two Iraqi brothers, who are Sunni, came to the United States under the sponsorship of Spirit of America, a nonprofit organization founded by technology entrepreneur Jim Hake that helps Americans serving abroad improve the lives of others.

A great article, and appearing in several sources, including the Chicago Tribune, where the headline has been altered to read "Freedom's spirit takes root in Iraq".

We'll assume they think that means the same thing.

Meanwhile, Jim Hake emails:

BLOGGER CHALLENGE

Our Blogger Challenge ended at midnight on Wednesday. Nearly 200 bloggers joined the effort and, as I type, raised $90,247. Incredible!!! There was a great flurry of activity in the final hours and, in amazing come-from-behind effort, Iraq the Model, jumped into the lead. Iraq the Model has raised $17,140 . The leading team is the Northern Alliance of Blogs. The Alliance has raised $12,135. Thanks to the bloggers we now have more than 11,000 contributors. A 10% increase in 2 weeks.

We are still accepting checks and will have a final total and rankings next week. Thank you to all the bloggers that participated. It is an enormous contribution. Woooohoooooo!! We even had two foreign teams (that I know of) - from Canada and Spain. Please click here to see all the bloggers that joined the effort and thank them, too:

PRESIDENT BUSH

Last Thursday, I met with President Bush for 1/2 hour in the Oval Office along with SoA's Kerry Dupont, Omar and Mohammed from Iraq the Model and Friends of Democracy. The meeting came as a surprise. We received a call in our taxi while we were headed back to our hotel asking if we could be at the White House in 25 minutes. I'm told those close to the President thought it would be good for him to hear from "ordinary" Iraqis and to hear about Spirit of America. Paul Wolfowitz, Deputy Secy of Defense, and a staff member from the National Security Council were also there.

I found the President to be focused, interested, intelligent and committed. He also has a good sense of humor, which he employed liberally. Let me assure you, Spirit is not, and never will be, a political or policy organization. We view the work we are doing as something that people of every political persuasion should support. We're not going to blow it by playing politics. Nonetheless, we have one President. He is the Commander in Chief of the servicemen and women we are helping in Iraq and Afghanistan. We should want his support and now I'm glad we now have it.

The first part of the meeting focused on Omar and Mohammed's views of Iraq. Then we talked about Spirit of America. After hearing about what we are doing, the President turned to Omar and Mohammed and said, "You see gentlemen, that is the beauty of America. I never met this man before but he's out there helping to win this war on terror just as much as 'Wolfie' here." I would have expected President Bush to have kind words for what we are doing. I wasn't sure if he would see the strategic importance of what we are doing but I'm very happy he does. He went on to talk about the importance of private-sector, grass roots activities - people helping people, saying "that's what I believe in." Of course, that's what Spirit of America is about.

For you dog lovers, as we left, we met Barney - the President's dog - and learned that Barney is getting a sister named Beasley.

GENERAL TOMMY FRANKS

Unlike the serendipitous meeting with Pres. Bush, the meeting with Tommy Franks had been in the works for a while. I'm happy to say that he also understands the value of what we're doing. This is best relayed by paraphrasing what he said. Gen Franks makes an important distinction between terrorists and terrorism. He said the military can deal with terrorists pretty well with a 9mm bullet. But terrorism was a whole different, more complex thing. He said he thought that Spirit of America and the America people had a better opportunity to deal with/reduce/defeat (I forget the exact word) terrorism than the U.S. Government bureaucracy. Of course, the commitment of the U.S. Government is essential. His point, I believe, was to highlight the importance of the American people and the particular approach of Spirit of America.

I hope General Franks will be able to be involved in some of our activities moving forward. Either way, we have a great new friend.

Here in Mudville it was Mrs G who led the charge, and though we joined rather late in the effort I'm amazed and grateful to the readers who contributed. Thanks to you all! If you requested pogs and Dinar, they'll get to you. The Mrs has her work cut out for her, and holiday mail being what it is (from around the world, no less), your patience is appreciated.

Hero

Your must read for today

On a Cold Snowy Night

On a cold snowy night back in 86
I saw a young man standing by some bricks

I watched out my window as the snow drifted down
I could see his breath in this cold little town

He was walking back and forth with his gun by one arm
at first I was nervous but he meant me no harm

He stood there and stood there freezing I know
just standing a pacing there in the snow

Then out of nowhere a tear fell from my eye
just knowing he would protect me even if he had to die

I gathered my self up and went to my Dad
it was 2 in the morning but he was not mad

I went to the Kitchen and made some warm tea
walked down the cold stairs "to you, from me"

He put out his hand and put it on my head
then he whispered to me "all is safe, go on to bed"

with a lump in my throat a tear in my eye
I went back upstairs but did not cry

I went back to the window and took a peek out
he looked up and saw me his smile came out

He stood at attention saluted me, he did
I saluted him back and let out a grin

By Adam J
Adam says: (I was 11 years old and My Father was stationed in Germany that was right after we Bombed Libya.)

Rough men

Hawk,

It was my reading of that quote at your site so many times that inspired me to write something about it. It is a wonderful bit of wisdom, and combined with this quote of Haile Selassie's, is a rather effective way of making critics of the war ponder their position, if but for a moment, until their fuzzy logic takes hold again.

"Throughout history, it has been the inaction of those who could have acted; the indifference of those who should have known better; the silence of the voice of justice when it mattered most; that has made it possible for evil to triumph."

Charles at Global Spec Ops brought this bit of wisdom to my attention.

"Good people sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf."

George Orwell (with a nod to the Mudville Gazette)

Rough men

There's a character trait that's decided by fate
Comes (sadly) to many, far too faint, far too late.
They won't face the aggressor, stand up to his ire
They have not the will to fight his fire with fire.
So they bend over backwards to see all sides as fair,
Till they're faced with dragon breath fire in their hair.
Like our brethren in France, who'd know better than we,
Yet seem never to learn, seem doomed never to see.

Yes, it seems there are some who're determined by fate,
To possess not the courage to step up to the plate,
Who shrink from all threat because nothing's worth war.
But how can they know lest they've been there before?
Thank God some have courage, the will, yes, the grace,
To stand for the shirkers, stand strong in their place.
Thank God we have stalwarts who'll stand for us all,
Who will rise to the challenge at their nation's call.

The faint-hearted, who fear, whose reaction is flight,
Have no comprehension of those who will fight.
To hide their own trepidation they attempt to demean
The rough men, who defend them, as barbaric, obscene.
Yet these rough men stand ready, hard weapons to hand,
To put placaters behind them, draw a line in the sand,
To preserve for the peaceniks what they won't defend,
So their own unearned freedom won't perish, won't end.

To appeasers, rough men are coarse government tools.
To rough men, appeasers are dumb delusional fools.

Russ Vaughn
2d Bn, 327th Parachute Infantry Regiment
101st Airborne Division
Vietnam 65-66

Thank You Russ

Russ Vaughn is the Poet Laureate of The American Thinker

UPDATE: It seems there is a debate on where this quote originated. Now by all means, I'm no scholar but I can google and this is my conclusion.

It may be a merger of the statment made in Orwell's essay on Rudyard Kipling (1942) ["He (Kipling) sees clearly that men can only be highly civilized while other men, inevitably less civilized, are there to guard and feed them."] and the definition of a pacifist from Orwell's "Notes on Nationalism" (1945) [PACIFIST: Those who 'abjure' violence can only do so because others are committing violence on their behalf.]

Now who do we attribute this quote to? I say both. No one knows who created the exact quote that Greyhawk uses. Neither Orwell or Kipling said those exact words in any of their writings and we may never know who did, so let's close the matter with what we do know. These two were brilliant men and the quote was obviously derived from these writings.

And to the commenter who says on his site, Still, (mostly) warmongerers have been repeating this made-up phrase without question for a long time, and now with the "Good" attached - which in my opinion significantly alters the meaning of the quote which implies that the "good people" consent. Plenty of good people do not consent to most war.

To this I say yes, you right, "Good" shouldn't be added because bad people also sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf. And the word "Good" added doesn't show consent by good people, it's just an undeniable fact, and for your information all quotes are made up, that's how they come into existance. Now "Shoo Fly don't bother me". -Thomas Brigham Bishop (sang by Kitty Wells)

PS:
maybe Greyhawk should add this quote to his header:

"Take my word for it, the silliest woman can manage a clever man; but it needs a very clever woman to manage a fool. - Rudyard Kipling"

Silly me
-- Mrs Greyhawk

Greyhawk says:

By the way that's why I never attributed the quote - its source is unknown. A lot of people credit me with it now, but that was never my intention. (Well, I did add the bit about the reader forgiving rough language or behavior.)

Voice of the People

ALJazeera says thousands of Iraqi's will be disenfranchised in the upcoming elections. Who are these thousands they champion?

Tens, and may be hundreds of thousands, of Iraqi voters will most likely be unable to cast their ballots in the general elections slated for January 30, 2005, either for being homeless or detained by the U.S.-led forces.

Over 300.000 Iraqis, mostly Sunnis, have been forced to leave their homes in Fallujah, west of Baghdad, due to the continuous shelling that climaxed in a blistering air and ground sweep by US and Iraqi forces in November.

Are we to assume that they would have been voting without that blistering sweep? That the 'insurgents' would have participated in the democratic process?

Speaking of insurgents...

There are also tens of thousands of detainees, majority of which are also Sunnis, who are not subject to the Independent Election Commission in Iraq (IECI).

What a shame it would be if their voices weren't heard, their opinions unknown.

It is good to hear a new voice raised championing democracy though - we'll certainly look forward to Al Jazeera's reports on the upcoming Saudi elections too, with a special focus on women's suffrage issues there.

This Christmas is Different

Christmas before Sept. 11th vs. Christmas after Sept. 11th

This Christmas is different

Last Christmas we were thinking about all the things we didn't have.
This Christmas we are thinking about all the things we do have.

Last Christmas we were placing wreaths on the doors of our homes.
This Christmas we are placing wreaths on the graves of our heros.

Last Christmas we were letting our sons play with toy guns.
This Christmas we are teaching them that guns are not toys.

Last Christmas we were counting our money.
This Christmas we are counting our blessings.

Last Christmas we were lighting candles to decorate.
This Christmas we are lighting candles to commemorate.

Last Christmas we paid lip service to the real meaning of the holidays.
This Christmas we are paying homage to it.

Last Christmas we were digging deep into our bank accounts to find money to fly home for the holidays.
This Christmas we are digging deep into our souls to find the courage to do so.

Last Christmas we were trying not to let annoying relatives get the best of us.
This Christmas we are trying to give the best of ourselves to them.

Last Christmas we thought it was enough to celebrate the holidays.
This Christmas we know we must also find ways to consecrate them.

Last Christmas we thought a man who could rush down a football field was a hero.
This Christmas we know a man who rushes into a burning building is the real one.

Last Christmas we were thinking about the madness of the holidays.
This Christmas we are thinking about the meaning of them.

Last Christmas we were getting on one another's nerves.
This Christmas we are getting on our knees.

Last Christmas we were giving thanks for gifts from stores.
This Christmas we are giving thanks for gifts from GOD.

Last Christmas we were wondering how to give our children all the things that money can buy.
This Christmas we are wondering how to give them all the things money can't... like peace and security.

Last Christmas we were thinking about all the pressure we were under at the office.
This Christmas we are thinking about all the people who no longer have an office.

Last Christmas we were singing carols.
This Christmas we are singing anthems.

Last Christmas we were thinking how good it would feel to be affluent.
This Christmas we are thinking how good it feels to be alive.

Last Christmas we thought angels were in heaven.
This Christmas we know they are right here on earth.

Last Christmas we were contemplating all the changes we wanted to make in the new year.
This Christmas we are contemplating all the changes we will have to make in this new reality.

Last Christmas we believed in the power of the pocketbook.
This Christmas we believe in the power of prayer.

Last Christmas we were sharing/spreading/listening to gossip.
This Christmas we are sharing/spreading/listening to the Gospel.

Last Christmas we were complaining about how much of our earnings went to taxes.
This Christmas we comprehend that freedom isn't free.

Last Christmas we valued things that were costly.
This Christmas we value things that are holy.

Last Christmas the people we idolized wore sports uniforms.
This Christmas the people we idolize wear police, firefighter and military uniforms.

Last Christmas peace on earth was something we prayed for on Sunday morning.
This Christmas it's something we pray for every day.

Circling

Austin Bay has been here, done that, as we say in the business.

But to this I say maybe...

Draw another circle around Jan. 30. That's Iraq's first election day. Underline the two weeks prior to Jan. 30. That will be a savage fortnight in which terror campaigns and political campaigns collide. Democratic candidates will be assassinated and polling stations will be blown to bits, as Saddamite and Al Qaeda reactionaries -- the Middle East's ancien regime of tyrant and terrorist -- attempt to force an oppressed people to submit one more time to the yoke of fear.

...maybe not.

Something will certainly go boom, of that I'm sure. Stay tuned.

That's not the key point of his piece, by the way. Go read, you'll see. It will be the only storyline elsewhere, of that I also have no doubt.

SOA

I'm moving this post up for those that may have missed it.

Have you donated to the SoA Blogger challenge? Here's the sort of things you're helping to make happen.

Iraq the Model bloggers Omar and Mohamed are touring America along with SoA founder Jim Hake (MilBlogger Grim got a coveted invite to one event!) demonstrating the new Arabic language blogging tool called Viral Freedom:

Every blog developed using the Arabic blogging tool will include space that is under the control of organizations that we work with, such as Friends of Democracy. This space or “real estate” will be a portion of the blog header (top of the page) and the left column. The organizations will use the space to promote groups, individuals and news that, in the big picture, advance freedom, democracy and peace in the region. Thus, everyone that creates a blog will be promoting moderate and progressive information and viewpoints in the Arab world. Friends of Democracy will use the space to publicize pro-democracy groups, election information and related news. The blogs created under Friends of Democracy will be ambassadors of democracy in the Arab world.

Friends of Democracy
The first group of blogs will be under Friends of Democracy. It will focus on Iraq but anyone, and any group, anywhere that wants to be a “friend of democracy” will be able to create and maintain a Friends of Democracy blog in Arabic at no cost. Friends of Democracy will establish and enforce policies regarding blog use and blog content.

Beyond Iraq
If enough funds are raised, we will seek other moderate organizations to oversee blogs in other Arab countries such as Saudi Arabia and Syria. We will also fund the development of the blogging tool in Farsi so it may be used in Iran and in Kurdish.

Contributions through Mudville thus far are enough to fund hosting of 50 blogs 100 Blogs(!!!) for one year in this effort (Note: contributions are to SoA to use as they see fit - will go where the need is greatest.)
"Viral Freedom" makes Mrs. G's choice of link banner quite appropriate, don't you think?

Witness the growing influence of blogs; Omar and Mohamed have already met the President of the United States - and soon they'll be hosted by none other than Roger L Simon! (The reader can insert their own witticism here.)

In honor of the whole series of events, I've decided to up the ante: all who donate 20 dollars or more via Mudville (click banner above) will receive not just pogs but 10,000 (Saddam era) Iraqi Dinar. See additional details here. (And yes, those who've already asked shall receive this too. Act now - offer good only while supplies last.)

SGT Hook Out?

It is a sad day to hear that Sgt Hook will be hanging up his boots and retiring from Blogging. Although he will sorely be missed, Greyhawk and I understand completely, Hooks position on this.
Farewell sir, but please keep in touch via e-mail.

Peace out!

Greyhawk says:

Awwwww crap!

(Hey, I warned you about that rough language.)

The Sands of Christmas

I'll be posting various Military Christmas poems found on the internet during the next couple weeks.
here's one to start.

The Sands of Christmas

I had no Christmas spirit when I breathed a weary sigh,
and looked across the table where the bills were piled too high.
The laundry wasn’t finished and the car I had to fix,
My stocks were down another point, the Dolphins lost by six.

And so with only minutes till my son got home from school
I gave up on the drudgery and grabbed a wooden stool.
The burdens that I carried were about all I could take,
and so I flipped the TV on to catch a little break.

I came upon a desert scene in shades of tan and rust,
No snowflakes hung upon the wind, just clouds of swirling dust.
And where the reindeer should have stood before a laden sleigh,
eight hummers ran a column right behind an M1A.

A group of boys walked past the tank, not one was past his teens,
Their eyes were hard as polished flint, their faces drawn and lean.
They walked the street in armor with their rifles shouldered tight,
their dearest wish for Christmas, just to have a silent night.

Other soldiers gathered, hunkered down against the wind,
To share a scrap of mail and dreams of going home again.
There wasn’t much at all to put their lonely hearts at ease,
They had no Christmas turkey, just a pack of MREs.

They didn't have a garland or a stocking I could see,
They didn't need an ornament-- they lacked a Christmas Tree.
They didn’t have a present even though it was tradition,
the only boxes I could see were labled "ammunition".

I felt a little tug and found my son now by my side,
He asked me what it was I feared, and why it was I cried.
I swept him up into my arms and held him oh so near
and kissed him on the forehead as I whispered in his ear.

There’s nothing wrong my little son, for safe we sleep tonight,
our heroes stand on foreign land to give us all the right,
to worry on the things in life that mean nothing at all,
instead of wondering if we will be the next to fall.

He looked at me as children do and said its always right,
to thank the ones who help us and perhaps that we should write.
And so we pushed aside the bills and sat to draft a note,
to thank the many far from home, and this is what we wrote,

God bless you all and keep you safe, and speed your way back home.
Remember that we love you so, and that you’re not alone.
The gift you give you share with all, a present every day,
You give the gift of liberty and that we can’t repay.

by Michael Marks
© December 2003

Global
SpecOps

Seems Bill thinks like me and has same poem also.

It's starting to look like Christmas

Sometimes it's Personal

Sometimes I get the feeling some folks forget that the military blogger isn't just spouting their opinion from mom's basement. Here's a must read from Smash. Just go.

Welcome to the World Tonight

Omar, in Iraq the Model:

Arthur Chrenkoff has another round up of good news from Afghanistan. I can't stop feeling amazed whenever I see the enormous effort Arthur puts in his blog trying to show some of the untold news about Iraq and Afghanistan, and I keep wondering, "On who's payroll is he?! Poor "anti-war" bloggers, who toil just for the sake of truth living only on wine and french bread.

First: appreciate the subtlety of Omar's wry humor, that's satire worthy of Swift from a man from a culture most likely far from yours for whom English is a second language. Your reading of such a thing from such a source would have been impossible a few short months ago when neither the technology nor the freedom were available to him.

Then ponder this: An American GI in Iraq just linked to and commented about an Iraqi citizen, who was linking and commenting on a post from an ex-pat from Poland now living in Australia and providing information to the world on the situation in Afghanistan.

What does it all mean? That's entirely up to you.

Dismiss such things as trivial if you wish, but most who read these words likely already understand the enormous potential of blogs. Others see all this as evil, but then many of our ancient ancestors were likely anti-fire. More recently there were those who opposed Gutenberg's light in the darkness.

Here, let me fuel the fire, for clearly the this day the Knights Templar ride:

Agents Blackfive and Grim report from the East Coast (Harvard and DC, respectively).

And for the latest from our agents in California, here's Roger and Chap.

For good measure, here's international-man-of-mystery Wretchard.

Extreme heat? No - just a nice warm glow.

Exactly

Everything you need to know about the situation here in Iraq today, in thirty words or less.

Or more.

Also pictures.

Who doesn't love pictures?

Update: Click on Dec 14 on calendar in upper left at link

Divine Justice

?would be served if this man died of starvation

Other methods would be also be okay with me though.

And for a trip down memory lane, Mudville, this time last year. This blog was the first to post the news.

Time flies whether you're having fun or not.

You Won't Hear This One In The Congressional Debates

Sarah with a letter from a GI on the Armor issue - he makes another point we're all well aware of, but that I haven't heard used in this discussion yet. (And you'll probably not hear it anywhere else. There's only a few with the 'license' to say it.)

Rebel Rouser has some interesting pics of the HMMWVs being used in Iraq, along with the latest and greatest.

True Grit

Zev Chafets in the NY Daily News says Thomas Wilson, the Soldier who asked the armor question of Secretary Rumsfeld, should get a Silver Star. His 'heroics' aren't quite to that level, but the statement reminds me of this old joke:

The Chiefs of Staff are bragging about the relative courage of the members of their respective services. To settle the ensuing argument, they make a bet on who commands the bravest troops. One by one they call low ranking GI's into their meeting.

First in is a Marine. "Grenade!" shouts the Commandant of the Marine Corps. "Hooah" shouts the Marine, and he grabs the dummy 'live' grenade from the floor and hurls it out the window. "Gentlemen," says the Commandant, "that man has courage - as do all my Marines!"

A Soldier folows. "Grenade!" Shouts the Army General, and in the blink of an eye the Soldier throws himself on the fake weapon. "Gents, I think you'll agree that American Soldiers epitomize bravery!" States the Army Chief, with pride.

A Sailor enters. "Grenade!" The Admiral shouts, but before he finishes the first syllable the Sailor has fled back out the door, and the remaining Chiefs laugh out loud.

The Chief of Staff Air Force nervously calls his man in.

"Airman, fall on that Grenade!" he shouts, determined not to experience the humiliation of his Navy partner.

"Kiss my ass, General!" The Airman replies.

Stunned silence fills the room, until the Air Force General says: "Well I think that settles it boys - this man has balls!"

Setting an Example?

Ouch! - In more ways than one.

When Marine Lance Cpl. David Battle learned he'd either have to sacrifice his ring finger or the wedding band he wore, he told doctors at a field hospital in Iraq to cut off the finger.

The 19-year-old former high school football star suffered a mangled left hand and serious wounds to his legs in a Nov. 13 fire fight in Fallujah. Battle, who is recovering at his parents' home in this desert city 80 miles northeast of Los Angeles, came under attack as he and fellow Marines entered a building. Eleven other Marines were wounded.

Doctors were preparing to cut off Battle's ring to save as much of his finger as they could.

"But that would mean destroying my wedding ring," he said. "My wife is the strongest woman I know. She's basically running two people's lives since I've been gone. I don't think I could ever repay her or show her how grateful ... how much I love my wife, my soul mate."

With his approval, doctors severed his finger, but somehow in the chaos that followed, they lost his ring.

Although Battle was disappointed, his wife, Devon, said she was honored.

"I can't believe he did that," she said. "At first I was mad when he told me, but then I realized how lucky I am to have him in my life."

The couple, who met in the eighth grade, were married in June, just two weeks before Battle left for Iraq. He hopes to eventually return to the Marines, and to replace his wedding ring, but that will have to wait until he recovers.

In the meanwhile, Battle's high school has planned a banquet in his honor next week.

"We need to make more David Battles," said Daniel Pierce, the school's assistant head coach. "He is one amazing guy."

Arthur's Latest

Dear Mr & Mrs Greyhawk

From the other theater of operations...

It's early days yet, but Afghanistan looks like a success story of President Bush's foreign policy - not surprisingly then, the media has "moved on" to other quagmires and disaster areas. Afghanistan's just not all that important anymore.

Let all of us in the West, leading safe and comfortable lives which allow us to take so much for granted, don't disparage the little things that are today taking place on the other side of the world; a song that can now be sung, a girl who can go to school, a joke that can be told, a country road being built - or indeed a rose smelled again. These things may not sound like much to us, but for the people of Afghanistan they are all small steps leading them towards a better life and a normal future.

The latest round-up of positive developments from Afghanistan is available on:

Chrenkoff

Opinion Journal

Winds of Change

Thanks for your help in spreading the good news.

Best regards

Arthur

Stranger than Fiction

Here's an idea for a hybrid science fiction/techno-thriller story I'm working on. I think it'll be a hit, see if you agree:

Part 1:
A city becomes a haven for hostile alien forces who look like real people; they delight in capturing humans, torturing and killing them to keep the rest of the population under control. Though the majority of citizens want to be left alone they don't have the power to expel the invaders, and many join the enemy out of fear or desire for what little power they can gain. The situation worsens, and threatens the fragile peace and stability of an entire region. As global political strategies swirl in the background, the majority of peaceful citizens flee in advance of military forces coming to end the reign of terror, violently. In the background many argue for 'peaceful solutions' and 'reaching out' to the aliens, with whom we have much 'common ground', while others label these people as traitors to humanity, or question whether they are human at all. Still, the battle is inevitable, short lived, and devastating. The aliens are crushed by high-tech weaponry they couldn't begin to comprehend, and a plan is prepared for rebuilding the city and returning the people to their homes.

Part 2:
But how to ensure the same situation doesn't happen again? Here's where more tech/scifi elements come in. Alien identification systems are developed, though some declare them ineffective and unreliable. Checkpoints are set up around the city, and no one gets in without getting ID cards, requiring being photographed, fingerprinted and having their iris scans taken. All this info is to be kept in a central database. Elements of 'rights to privacy" and "big brother" plotlines will thicken the plot. How much freedom can we sacrifice to preserve our freedom? will be an underlying theme. All characters involved will twist reality to suit their personal agendas, and simple human errors will become global issues as warring factions fight to gain the upper hand in the situation.

The people will of course experience a range of emotions on returning to their devastated city. Many will be outraged, others will look forward to a future free from fear; their ultimate response to the situation will depend on the success of the complex rebuilding and compensation plan. This plan must be enacted swiftly, and here the element of conflict and suspense builds rapidly. Forces within the city and in the wider world beyond have multiple reasons for sabotaging the entire effort. Vast numbers of people worldwide will become unwitting pawns for various factions. Meanwhile, surviving aliens will regroup elsewhere...

The story will be told from the point-of-view of numerous characters on all sides of the issue; citizens, soldiers, surviving aliens, and family members of each along with the stories of the various geo-political leaders and factions that have their own motives for their actions. This will be a "can't miss thriller", a "page turner", perhaps even a "blockbuster" novel. I'm not sure of the ending yet, but I know that if the plan of the "good guys" can be shown to be a miserable failure actually driven by corrupt influences at the top, and that the "monsters" were actually "no different then us" (or better even, as we "degenerate" as a result of our misguided actions) I'll have a real New York Times bestseller on my hands.

Oh wait, that's not fiction, that's Fallujah today.

Never mind.

Up Your Armor III

Joe Galloway (of "We Were Soldiers" fame) gives a great overview of the realities behind the recurring "armor shortage" story. Galloway (disclaimer: we've never met) is a reporter whose views I disagree with frequently and respect tremendously, but his report on the background reinforces several of the concepts introduced here and here last week. Excerpts follow, but as always, read the whole thing.

...the guerrilla war quickly escalated. U.S. forces in Iraq quickly discovered that the humvee - a light transport vehicle designed more than 15 years ago to replace the old World War II jeep - worked better than anything else they had on hand in terms of maneuverability and durability.

Unfortunately, it had zero protection built into it for the soldiers riding in it. The requests for humvees built with armor at the factory, and for add-on armor kits, grew from a few for Special Operations forces at the end of summer 2003 to 400 in November 2003 and more in months following. The total request, scheduled to be met in March, is for about 22,000 armored humvees.

Retired Col. Gary Motsek, a senior civilian official for the Army Materiel Command, said that given early shortages of a critical high-tensile steel and continuing shortages of bulletproof glass for windshields and door windows, it's little short of a miracle that the escalating demand has been met within about a year.

"The frustration I have is people asking: 'Why wasn't this on the shelf?' This involves a change of tactics, a change of the fight," Motsek said. "When the mission changed and the war changed, the armoring of the humvee became priority number one."

Motsek said that the design for an armor add-on kit was sketched out over a weekend, and the metal was cut and attached to a humvee within 10 days. That humvee was tested immediately for protection not only against small-arms fire but also heavier weapons. It took only four months from the first request in August 2003 to the beginning of production of the armor kits - a process, Motsek contended, that normally takes years.

A year ago, the steel needed for the armor kits wasn't manufactured anywhere in the United States, and the output of the single plant making bulletproof glass was 15 windshields a month.

Today there are several American sources for the special steel, and the plant making ballistic glass has ramped up production to 500 windshields a month. It will be joined in February by a second plant also capable of making 500 windshields a month.

The Armor Holdings plant that turns out new humvees with full armor protection has, in that same year, boosted production from 50 a month to 450 a month. Army Materiel Command officials said there were discussions about Armor Holdings' offer Thursday to increase production of the armored humvee from 450 to 550 per month. They expressed surprise that such an increase might be possible.

The "we can increase production" quote has been parroted repeatedly in the mainstream media with little background or additional information provided. It's good to see someone willing to put a more complete story out for the tax-paying public; it's no surprise that Galloway is the man that did so.

Global Voices Online

BlackFive has been rubbing elbow With a lot of influential bloggers, at Harvard.
Go read his adventure here and here

man, spend a few months in Iraq and you miss out on everything!

Weblog Awards

The results are in, and the best blog in the world is...

...still whoever you think it is, silly. So thanks to Kevin for putting up with the headaches and hosting a great party (for that's what it really was you know) and thanks to all who helped Mudville finish a respectable second (in a statstical 3-way tie with the most excellent Assymetrical Information and Allah in a category loaded with heavyweights and many of my favorite blogs) and congrats to Ace, who's in a class by himself!

Full results are here.

Big Time

MilBlogger (Intel Dump) Phil Carter on the armor issue (and transformation in light of the the evolution in threat faced by the military) - in the New York Times:

Many are taking the exchange, along with alarming new statistics on military preparedness from the House Armed Services Committee, as proof that the Bush administration has failed to give soldiers in Iraq the equipment they need to face combat. Actually, the problem runs much deeper than the current administration: it stems from the Pentagon's uneven effort over the last decade to turn a cold-war military into a force able to meet today's challenges.

<...>

Simply put, there are no more front lines. In slow recognition, the Army purchased light armored vehicles in the late 1990's for its military police to conduct peacekeeping, and more recently spent billions of dollars to outfit several brigades with Stryker medium-weight armored vehicles, which are impervious to most small arms and rocket-propelled grenades and can be deployed anywhere in the world by airplane.

But the fact that there is no longer a front line also means there aren't any more "rear" areas where support units can operate safely. Support units must now be prepared to face the same enemy as the infantry, but are having to do so in trucks with canvas doors and fiberglass hoods because Pentagon procurement planners never expected they'd have to fight. Remember that Pfc. Jessica Lynch, the Iraq invasion's most celebrated prisoner of war, was a supply clerk with a maintenance company.

Well done, Phil! (Oh wait - it's Phillip now! ;) - Hey don't forget all us "little guys"!)

Quotes of the Week

The Mudville Gazette proudly spotlights our quotes of the week. Are they poor choices of words or accidental statments of truth? Did they say what they mean or mean what they say? Let's go through the looking glass, and you can be the judge:

When Army Sergeant Dennis Edwards spoke at Dennis-Yarmouth Regional High School in Massachusetts, students and teachers "...listened in rapt silence as he told chilling tales of battlefield horror in Iraq and criticized President Bush's motives for going to war". The centerpiece of his presentation was his description of how "...he and two other soldiers shot and killed a 10-year-old boy in Iraq who pretended to be wounded and suddenly fired an AK-47 rifle. The boy was found to have explosives attached to his body, Edwards told the stunned audience."

One minor problem: he made the whole thing up. Brian MacQuarrie's Boston Globe story relates the reaction to the news from the students and faculty at the school, and gives us quote number one:

"His confession has also saddened Dennis-Yarmouth teachers and students, who said they felt honored and captivated by his appearance."

Yes, how sad that there wasn't really a dead little 10-year-old boy. No word whether "grief counselors" were available to help them "move on".

Speaking of gullibility and a willingness to believe anything about those wacky Arabs, Tyler Golson relates his experience teaching English in Damascus, specifically his shock at learning his students weren't Hamas or International Answer members when they revealed to him their support for George Bush. Tyler responds, and provides quote two:

"But doesn't he scare you?" I asked finally, unable to contain my personal feelings and throwing the lesson plan out the window. "Because of Bush's ideas many people in my country think that all of you are terrorists."

Way to build the bridge, buddy. (Hat tip here and here.)

Quote three is an overlooked comment in the notorious email exposed by the Drudge Report. Edward Lee Pitts, the reporter who planted the question about armored Humvees, explains his motivation:

I have been trying to get this story out for weeks- as soon as I foud (sic) out I would be on an unarmored truck - and my paper published two stories on it. But it felt good to hand it off to the national press.

Fortunately it has also been handed off to the blogs.

From Afghanistan

Stephen F. Hayes writes from Afghanistan in the weekly Standard, describing the managed chaos surrounding the inauguration of Hamid Karzai as first elected president of that nation, then relates a portion of the inaugural address

All of this activity came to a halt when Karzai, dressed in his flowing green silk coat and black lambskin hat, approached the microphone. He thanked Vice President Cheney for making the trip from Washington and then turned his attention to the American people:

Whatever we have achieved in Afghanistan--the peace, the election, the reconstruction, the life that the Afghans are living today in peace, the children going to school, the businesses, the fact that Afghanistan is again a respected member of the international community--is from the help that the United States of America gave us. Without that help Afghanistan would be in the hands of terrorists--destroyed, poverty-stricken, and without its children going to school or getting an education. We are very, very grateful, to put it in the simple words that we know, to the people of the United States of America for bringing us this day.

Sadly, most Americans never heard these words. Gratitude, it seems, is not terribly newsworthy. Neither is democracy. The Washington Post played Karzai's inauguration on page A-13, a placement that suggested it was relatively less important than Eliot Spitzer's decision to run for governor of New York or the decision of the U.S. government to import flu vaccine from Germany.

In this season away from friends and family in a land not quite as far along that rough road to freedom, those of us in Iraq can take heart from these words too - though it's indeed a shame I hadn't heard or read them before Hayes' report either.

And all the more a shame, given that many of America's finest gave their all for this moment and those yet to come. Those with any sense of recent history whatsoever will recall that from the start the Afghan operation was declared a "quagmire" and "another Vietnam" by many in the American media, who cited history, terrain, and American weakness as likely causes for failure. Still, within three years of commencing this bold adventure we've replaced a 'government' that thought nothing of destroying the World Trade Center, 2000-year-old statues of Buddha, and countless human lives with a leadership that promises hope in the face of hopelessness, and an ability to look towards tomorrow without despair.

By the way, here in Iraq there's much left to do and little time to do it between now and election day, and those so inclined are encouraged to offer prayers for the Coalition troops, their families back home, and the people of Iraq today. With Christmas coming and ugly work at hand you can be assured the quagmire crowd will have plenty to discuss in the days to come.

Breaking News!

The latest news video from Iraq. Reporter interviews insurgents, in color, in your living room. Shocking, must watch.

Last Day!-2004 Weblog Awards

We're not just in the Military Blog category! There are MilBloggers hidden throughout the 2004 Weblog Awards. And here is where you'll find them:

EagleSpeak in the 6750+ category.

Geek Empire and Chapomatic in the 3500 - 5000 category.

The Common Virtue in the 1000-1750 category (Man down! Get there, stat!)

Brain Fertilizer and Froggy in the 500-1000 category.

Serenity's Journal and Ipse Dixit in the 100-250 category.
And...

The Mudville Gazette and The Evangelical Outpost in the
Top 100 category.

This is the last day to place your vote, so what are you waiting for? Get over there!

Recovery

This is big news, isn't it? Surely it's the story everyone's talking about in the States?

FALLUJAH, Iraq - U.S. Marines have almost completely cleared this former insurgent stronghold of insurgents and weapons, setting the stage for the return of the civilian population before next month's elections, a senior commander said yesterday.

Lt. Gen. John Sattler, who commands the 1st Marine Expeditionary Force, said that 97% of Fallujah's more than 20,000 buildings "have been swept for the third and hopefully, final time."

"We've removed all the ordnance, it's free of any insurgents and any improvised explosive devices or booby traps that might have been left behind," Sattler said.

U.S. and Iraqi forces in November recaptured this city 40 miles west of Baghdad from the hands of guerrillas who had used it as a base to launch attacks across Iraq.

Sattler cited the Iraqi commander of Fallujah, Lt. Gen. Abdul Khadar, as saying he would like to start bringing some of the 250,000 displaced people back by Dec. 24. By then, measures will be in place to guard against insurgents slipping back into the city, Sattler said.

Also yesterday, Iraq's mainstream Shiite groups announced a diverse list of 228 candidates for the Jan. 30 elections, a victory for Shiite leaders who wanted to present a powerful, united front as they seek a leading role in post-Saddam Iraq after years on the sidelines.

Iraq's leading Shiite cleric, Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, gave his blessing to the list. The 228 candidates include independent Sunni Muslims, a Shiite Kurdish group, and members of the Yazidi minority religious sect and a Turkomen movement, among others. Also among them are members of the Iraqi National Congress, including former exile and one-time Pentagon favorite Ahmed Chalabi.

I mean, it's what a lot of Marines and Soldiers gave their lives for after all, so I'm sure it's the lead story everywhere.

Semi Government

Our friend Bill at Small Town Veteran has been corresponding with an Iraqi, and sharing opinions of an editorial.

Iraqi Editorial ?Semi government?

By: Muhammed Abdul Jabbar

?Help team or foreign help team has deviated from consensus of Islamic teams in terms of the importance of Imams or government. It said that the society has no need for a government. Of course, this idea is not encouraged by large numbers of scholars and it was kept in religious community books....

<...>

I have seen many similar editorials in other Iraqi newspapers. This is a sentiment shared by many writers. Iraq has a united people of different races: Arab, Kurd, Turkman etc. and of different faiths: Muslim, Christian, Jew and of different factions: Sunni, Shiite, Kaldian, Ashurian, Catholic, Ashkenazi & Sephardi etc... But above all they are Iraqi and most want to stay that way. This feeling of Iraqi unity is becoming stronger as Iraqi elections near. Being able to cast their vote, and voice their opinions unites Iraqis. This newfound freedom is a great bond and common denominator of Iraqis. Iraqis feel valued, responsible for their country, responsible for their future, responsible for other Iraqis and lately, responsible for minorities? rights. While Iraqi politicians squabble for voter favoritism, voters are getting more sophisticated with their search of information and demands for better security, infrastructure etc. It is awe-inspiring to watch the development of freedom and democracy in Iraq. It is shocking however to see the very high price paid. This I am sure reminds us how precious our own democracy is and gives us a higher appreciation of the hard work and sacrifices our founders endured.

Regards
Haider Ajina

It really is an interesting read, something you won't find in the MSM.

Heh!

An unexpected honor; an annual award from Rightwingsparkle:

"Blog Most Likely to make me cry: Mudville!"

Ignoring for now how that might compare to the honor she bestowed on 2Slick (who, by the way is pudgy, balding, and thinks his gold tooth looks hot) I realize that though I'm pleased to be named "best" anything, I don't want people staying away from here for fear of crying. (Especially my fellow MilBloggers like 2Slick, who tends to cry loudly with little provocation - think Bambi's mother).

And every time I put up a funny post, I always get comments regarding how surprised somone is that they found something funny here! The time has come to put that misconception down for good. Commencing immediately below this line, a series of posts cut from previous entries in the Mudville Gazette, the funniest MilBlog in the History of the World!

I'll leave it to the reader to figure out the "current events" upon which most of these items were based.

Without further ado:

_______________________________________

How Johnny got his Hat (I)

The fog was thick as pea soup as we made our way across the border, but it muffled the sounds of the boat as we entered Cambodia. That was good, because our business there was anything but good.
"I wish you'd take that damn blindfold off." I whispered to the skipper.

"I learned to sail this way, hombre." He replied. His parrot sat silently on his shoulder. The bird spoke three languages but was not using any of them now.

"That bird makes me nervous" told him "if he spouts off in any of those three languages I'll..."

"Four languages." He said, still wearing the blindfold, piloting the river on pure instinct, nerves of steel. "English, French, Italian, and 'bird' - you probably forgot bird." He cut the engine, pulled the mask off. "He's disciplined. He wont squawk. And this is as far as we go. I'm not risking my crew. Or my bird"

"Fair enough, far enough." I said, slipping over the side. Kurtz didn't know it but his time was running short.

"Hey..." the skip whispered as I came up for air, "you forgot your hat."

"Keep it." I said, and pushed for shore.

_______________________________________

Ooglay Hussein's diary, 21 March, 2003:

Ahh my "ally" Frenchman, here I Ooglay am drinking now heavily for reasons of my own and will soon be finished for tonight. But my educating is needed for those of American schoolings. Listen here is the reason why Georgebush is the world joke butt okay?

I am inventing good jokes all the time in the palace and so I went to tell my glorious father for whom i will gladly make of myself a baricade before your paper tanks a new joking i had thought. I saw his office door being not shut allways so that means i can enter? right? so i approached the prescence of he for whom the sun provides warmth and he was on the phone at his desk but i stood proudly before him and he is talking to chiraq and this is always making him angry and he is saying when jacques will your foul foreign legion arrive? Don't jerk me Jacques! And okay i think he needs a laugh.

"Glorious Father for whom i would gladly ride a MOAB from the plane to the ground,here is a riddle for your laughing!!"

And he looked at me with those kill-you-slowly eyes he used on dans rather but doesn't say a word and I say "then how many georges bush does it take to screw in a lightbulb?" and he looks now like he looks at the meat grinder people and I say "Oh no please don't say there's more then one!!! Get it?"

And so that is when he struk me very forcefully between my eyes with the phone.

And I am now falling backwards and if not for the will of Allah that our friend Hans Blix was there to catch me I would inded have fallen into the drums of ricin that were nearly filling that half of the room.

So now is why george bush is worlds joke, okay, because a bit later as i come to my senses my glorious father for whom I would run naked with only my sword into your onrushing marines is telling this same joke of mine to Chiraq!!

And that is how it came to be, that the world jokes about bush, i swear on my mothers purity!

But Frenchmen, where is my foriegn legion frenchmen?

_______________________________________

The year: 2009

Location: A major Hollywood Studio soundstage.

Scene: A movie being filmed.

Woman (sobbing): What do you mean? What are you saying? Why did you lie to me?

Man (approaching her, arms extended): Now sugerbuns, don't get all...

Woman (sobs turning to anger): ?I can hardly breathe, (gulps for air) and you have the nerve to...

Man: Honey, now come on, you know your the only one I love!

(Man reaches woman, she smacks him)

Woman: (Sobbing but angry) Don't you honey me, you...

Hillary: Cut!!

Mike M: Hey, I'm the director! I'm supposed to say that!

Hillary: Shut up, you disgusting fatzoid shlob, or you'll wish you had free health care. I thought we agreed that my character would not display violent tendencies?

Is Nothing Sacred?

Nudity in blogs: Can't something be done?

(Welcome back Chris Muir!)

Update: No perma-links available, click Dec 11 on calendar in upper left at Chris? site.

Teach Your Children

Meet Sgt Dennis Edwards:

When Army Sergeant Dennis Edwards spoke at Dennis-Yarmouth Regional High School last month, 100 students listened in rapt silence as he told chilling tales of battlefield horror in Iraq and criticized President Bush's motives for going to war.

Edwards, 23, a Barnstable High School graduate, said he and two other soldiers shot and killed a 10-year-old boy in Iraq who pretended to be wounded and suddenly fired an AK-47 rifle. The boy was found to have explosives attached to his body, Edwards told the stunned audience.

Now, Edwards has admitted to his superiors in the elite 82d Airborne Division that the story about the shooting was a lie, Army officials yesterday. As a result, the veteran of operations in Iraq and Afghanistan could be charged with making false statements, face a court-martial, and be stripped of his rank.

His confession has also saddened Dennis-Yarmouth teachers and students, who said they felt honored and captivated by his appearance.

''We need to use this as a teachable moment," Superintendent Tony Pierantozzi said yesterday. ''We need to make sure our students . . . clearly understand that sometimes individuals might elaborate stories or examples for their own benefit."

And that sometimes some grownups believe everything they hear that supports other wrong ideas they have. Teachers, reporters...

Why would they want to believe?

Edwards was on leave visiting family when he appeared Nov. 23 in the school cafeteria at a teacher's invitation. The Cape Cod Times reported that Edwards criticized Bush's invasion of Iraq as a ''personal vendetta" to complete President George H.W. Bush's unfinished work against Saddam Hussein. ''The first Bush couldn't get it done, so it's time for the next Bush to do it," the Times quoted Edwards as saying in the talk.

In an interview later, the Times reported, Edwards said that ''we went over there for one reason, and because that fell through we're stuck over there for another reason." Edwards, who served in Iraq from August 2003 to March of this year, said US officials had not planned well for the mission.

They'll probably still cling to that part though.

UPDATE: How did I miss this the first time?: "His confession has also saddened Dennis-Yarmouth teachers and students, who said they felt honored and captivated by his appearance."

The admission that no ten-year-old boy was killed has saddened them?

Want to do something nice for a GI in Iraq today?

Go vote for him in the Weblog awards. (And thanks to all of you who already have.)

Note: Seems Kevin has gotten a little saavy and has put in a spam blocker.

Political Blogs 101

New to the Blogosphere? I can't imagine a better way to learn about it than from Omar at Iraq the Model who explains the whole right/left political division of blogs, and how it relates it to Iraq.

It was really confusing to me in the beginning that liberals would not support the change in Iraq (remember we were isolated so we didn't know much about that) even though they were against Bush, as it's over now and any humanist should (in my mind) support democracy and peace in Iraq. Besides, I've always considered myself a liberal! On the other side, I had a bad impression that many of the people on the right were fanatics and racist! How much did we learn in this year!

See you later. I mean, new to blogs or not you know you're going to go read it all, right?

By the way, I, a GI in Iraq, voted for Iraq the Model in the contest he references. Ponder that one.

Oh, and us MilBloggers don't get much attention from those lefty bloggers either.

Update: Right Wing News has some insight into the American left thinking on Iraq. These examples might be extreme, but I suspect not rare. That's a shame.

Up Your Armor II

Greetings from Iraq! First off to the millions of you who are concerned, rest assured, as I write this, my personal armor is within arm's reach.

Yesterday we noted this general truism:

"The U.S. military has always been perfectly trained and equipped to win the last war".

And the specific Murphy's law that shows why it doesn't matter anyway:

"No plan survives first contact with the enemy."

And the relationship of these to the "armor" issue, through this third fact that overwhelms them both:

"So for now, at least, enough of a shred of American "can-do" attitude and perseverance survives to ensure that the truism stated above remains only a minor inconvenience."

Today I find Steve Hayward illustrating the concept in The Corner:

The news yesterday of soldiers challenging Rumsfeld about the lack of armor, spare parts, etc, brought back to mind many of my father's WWII stories, where, as a long-range reconnaisance and sub-hunting Navy pilot in the South Pacific starting in 1942, spare parts were in such short supply that he routinely looked for downed planes they could scrounge spare parts from, sometimes even behind enemy lines in New Ginuea. Nobody complained about it; they just got by. Actually, he got a commendation for ingenuity; maybe these folks in Kuwait should get a similar commendation.

Also, because his squadron had to fly missions of up to 30 hours, flying from northern Australia as far as the Chinese coast to track Japanese fleet movements, they often removed much of the heavy armor on the belly of their planes to extend their fuel range, with the obvious trade off of higher risk. Oh, his entire sqaudron also got their tours extended more than once.

But of course that's different, somehow...

Then here's another comment from the same Tennessee Guard unit as the young Specialist who quizzed the Secretary of Defense, as quoted by the very reporter who fed him that question:

"They (insurgents) are trying to attack weak convoys, not strong convoys," said Staff Sgt. Brian Culberson, 28, of Cleveland, Tenn.

He said soldiers scrounging for extra armor are not unique to this war. He recently saw a magazine article about units in Vietnam scavenging steel for their vehicles.

"They had the same problem with convoys getting hit with guerrilla warfare," Sgt. Culberson said. "The odds of us getting hit are pretty slim, but it is still an odd."

Scrounging is a time honored military tradition. You're not handed everything you need, and certainly nowhere near everything you want. (And with time comes additional needs - see Murphy's law). Overcoming shortages can be characterized as ingenuity on the part of the individual or failure on the part of the government. Sound familiar? Certainly the military doesn't have propriety of the concept.

There is an element of the victimization in the current lefty portrayal of this issue. People shouldn't have to do what the government should do for them! Small wonder that entitlement is the page they've chosen from their rather limited playbook on this one.

Having noted all that, I say without hesitation or qualification that yes, the government should do everything possible to assure as much protective gear gets to those of us in harm's way as is possible. Along with lethal offensive gear that tends to reduce threat too. Oh, and food, clothing, fuel, spare parts, communications systems, mail...

But I digress. Let's stick with armor for a moment. It's one of the issues that has seen phenomenal improvement over the past couple of years. Anyone recall seeing pictures of troops in body armor prior to OIF? Not likely - it wasn't in widespread use.

Likewise a second "defensive" area of rapid progress has been medical care. Combat units include "combat lifesavers", all troops get training in "self aid and buddy care", fully trained medics are near by and near-state-of-the-art facilities are found increasingly closer to the battlefields. Larger facilities are available in theater, airlift is readily available, and a system exists to get those who need it to Landstuhl Medical Center in Germany or stateside hospitals in rapid time - sometimes measured in hours rather than days.

Good old American ingenuity in action! And what has this "can-do attitude and American Know how" brought us, on the battlefield and in the media? The combination of improved personal armor and medical care has resulted in a greater percentage of survivors of wounds, as the Washington Post notes in a story headlined U.S. Combat Fatality Rate Lowest Ever:

Technology and Surgical Care at the Front Lines Is Credited With Saving Lives

Ten percent of soldiers injured in Iraq have died from their war wounds, the lowest casualty fatality rate ever, thanks in large part to technological advances and the deployment of surgical SWAT teams at the front lines, an analysis to be published today has found.

There's an unfortunate tradeoff, however:

But the remarkable lifesaving rate has come at the enormous cost of creating a generation of severely wounded young veterans and a severe shortage of military surgeons, wrote Atul Gawande, a surgeon at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston.

But witness the "no win" situation that the some in the press engineer, as evidenced in the Boston Globe's treatment of the same story:

Amputation Rate For US Troops Twice That Of Past Wars

Doctors cite need for prosthetics as more lives saved

US troops injured in Iraq have required limb amputations at twice the rate of past wars, and as many as 20 percent have suffered head and neck injuries that may require a lifetime of care, according to new data giving the clearest picture yet of the severity of battlefield wounds.

The data are the grisly flip side of improvements in battlefield medicine that have saved many combatants who would have died in the past: Only 1 in 10 US troops injured in Iraq has died, the lowest rate of any war in US history.

But those who survive have much more grievous wounds. Bulletproof Kevlar vests protect soldiers' bodies but not their limbs, as insurgent snipers and makeshift bombs tear off arms and legs and rip into faces and necks. More than half of those injured sustain wounds so serious they cannot return to duty, according to Pentagon statistics.

Bottom line: for some the only thing worse than troops in danger for lack of armor is troops who survived because of armor.

Guess we'll just have to pack up and go home.

Up Your Armor I

Members of the Tennessee Guard, on their pending travel to Baghdad

While some 278th soldiers were pleased about the prospect of a plane ride into Iraq, others said they didn't want to miss the ground convoy's adrenaline rush.

"That would be like going to Disney World and not riding the roller coaster," said Capt. Chris Brock, 43, human resources officer for Support Squadron.

Seems like the heirs of Davey Crockett aren't lacking courage, or a sense of history:

Soldiers are traveling into an Iraq where insurgents attack with homemade bombs placed along the roads.

"They (insurgents) are trying to attack weak convoys, not strong convoys," said Staff Sgt. Brian Culberson, 28, of Cleveland, Tenn.

He said soldiers scrounging for extra armor are not unique to this war. He recently saw a magazine article about units in Vietnam scavenging steel for their vehicles.

"They had the same problem with convoys getting hit with guerrilla warfare," Sgt. Culberson said. "The odds of us getting hit are pretty slim, but it is still an odd."

The reporter who covered the unit, and wrote the above story, is Edward Lee Pitts. According to Drudge, Pitts, who writes for the Greeneville (Tn.) Sun also planted the notorious "dumpster diving" question for Secretary Rumsfeld.

I just had one of my best days as a journalist today. As luck would have it, our journey North was delayed just long enough see I could attend a visit today here by Defense Secretary Rumsfeld. I was told yesterday that only soldiers could ask questions so I brought two of them along with me as my escorts. Before hand we worked on questions to ask Rumsfeld about the appalling lack of armor their vehicles going into combat have. While waiting for the VIP, I went and found the Sgt. in charge of the microphone for the question and answer session and made sure he knew to get my guys out of the crowd.

So during the Q&A session, one of my guys was the second person called on. When he asked Rumsfeld why after two years here soldiers are still having to dig through trash bins to find rusted scrap metal and cracked ballistic windows for their Humvees, the place erupted in cheers so loud that Rumsfeld had to ask the guy to repeat his question. Then Rumsfeld answered something about it being "not a lack of desire or money but a logistics/physics problem." He said he recently saw about 8 of the special up-armored Humvees guarding Washington, DC, and he promised that they would no longer be used for that and that he would send them over here. Then he asked a three star general standing behind him, the commander of all ground forces here, to also answer the question. The general said it was a problem he is working on.

Pitts goes on to detail at length the attention shown by national media to "his troops". His worship and awe of the heroism of the national reporters is obvious from his email in the Drudge link - clearly this man knows his heroes when he sees them - though he's not afraid to draw lines in the sand. (Emphasis added below.)

The NY Times reporter asked me to email him the stories I had already done on it, but I said he could search for them himself on the Internet and he better not steal any of my lines. I have been trying to get this story out for weeks- as soon as I foud (sic) out I would be on an unarmored truck - and my paper published two stories on it. But it felt good to hand it off to the national press.

Too bad those "national press" guys didn't have time or space to publish the whole story of the exchange between the SecDef and Spc. Thomas Wilson:

Q: Yes, Mr. Secretary. My question is more logistical. We?ve had troops in Iraq for coming up on three years and we?ve always staged here out of Kuwait. Now why do we soldiers have to dig through local landfills for pieces of scrap metal and compromise ballistic glass to up-armor our vehicles and why don?t we have those resources readily available to us? [Applause]

Actually it's coming up on two years, but who's counting? It's been such a roller coaster ride it seems like three years. Anyhow, here's the Secretary's reply in full:

SEC. RUMSFELD: I talked to the General coming out here about the pace at which the vehicles are being armored. They have been brought from all over the world, wherever they?re not needed, to a place here where they are needed. I?m told that they are being ? the Army is ? I think it?s something like 400 a month are being done. And it?s essentially a matter of physics. It isn?t a matter of money. It isn?t a matter on the part of the Army of desire. It?s a matter of production and capability of doing it.

As you know, you go to war with the Army you have. They?re not the Army you might want or wish to have at a later time. Since the Iraq conflict began, the Army has been pressing ahead to produce the armor necessary at a rate that they believe ? it?s a greatly expanded rate from what existed previously, but a rate that they believe is the rate that is all that can be accomplished at this moment.

I can assure you that General Schoomaker and the leadership in the Army and certainly General Whitcomb are sensitive to the fact that not every vehicle has the degree of armor that would be desirable for it to have, but that they?re working at it at a good clip. It?s interesting, I?ve talked a great deal about this with a team of people who?ve been working on it hard at the Pentagon. And if you think about it, you can have all the armor in the world on a tank and a tank can be blown up. And you can have an up-armored humvee and it can be blown up. And you can go down and, the vehicle, the goal we have is to have as many of those vehicles as is humanly possible with the appropriate level of armor available for the troops. And that is what the Army has been working on.

And General Whitcomb, is there anything you?d want to add to that?

GEN. WHITCOMB: Nothing. [Laughter] Mr. Secretary, I?d be happy to. That is a focus on what we do here in Kuwait and what is done up in the theater, both in Iraq and also in Afghanistan. As the secretary has said, it?s not a matter of money or desire; it is a matter of the logistics of being able to produce it. The 699th, the team that we?ve got here in Kuwait has done [Cheers] a tremendous effort to take that steel that they have and cut it, prefab it and put it on vehicles. But there is nobody from the president on down that is not aware that this is a challenge for us and this is a desire for us to accomplish.

?It's all about duty, and he felt compelled to be over there,? she said. She said both she and her ex-husband voted for Bush in November and support him ?100%.?

But both she and Spc. Wilson's current girlfriend agree that Rumsfeld seemed "caught off guard" by the question. It's not known whether they've seen or read his actual response, or if they're victims of coverage like that produced in the NY Times:

Spc. Thomas Wilson had asked Rumsfeld, ``Why do we soldiers have to dig through local landfills for pieces of scrap metal and compromised ballistic glass to up-armor our vehicles?'' Shouts of approval and applause arose from other soldiers who had assembled in an aircraft hangar to see Rumsfeld.

Rumsfeld hesitated and asked Wilson to repeat his question.

``We do not have proper armored vehicles to carry with us north,'' Wilson, 31, of Nashville, Tenn., concluded after asking again.

``You go to war with the Army you have,'' Rumsfeld replied, ``not the Army you might want or wish to have.''

A Dying Warriors Last Request

via Blackfive

Hi All-

Please help with this easy request. Feel free to copy and paste
instead of link.
Specialist David Mahlenbrock was killed by an IED on December 3rd in
Kirkuk, Iraq.

I received this email. It's from David's Squad in Bravo,
65th Engineers in Iraq and they are forwarding a request from David.
It appears that David had a special letter sent to his squad in the
event of his death. He wanted Toby Keith's "American Soldier" played
at his funeral:

------------------------------

Dear 1st Squad,

If you're reading this, then I've died for our country. I just
hope it wasn't for nothing.

After the IED went off yesterday, I wanted to write this in case
something happens to me. There are a few more letters that I'd like
you to give my wife and family.

I'd like to have a military funeral, but, if you can work please
make sure that Toby Keith's "American Soldier" is played at the
ceremony in addition to the bagpipes. If they won't let it happen,
that's ok, thanks for trying?...

I know that all the belongings I have here will go to Melissa,
but there are a few more things I'd like for you guys to make sure she
gets. I have a dog tag w/ our picture on it along w/ some pictures
and an American flag in my left breast pocket. There is also a can
that says "Son" on it that Melissa's parents gave me that I'd like for
them to have, and that angel stone should go to her grandma and
grandpa Snow.

Now if I died w/ blue eyes (one blew that way and one blew the
other way) and there's nothing really left of me, that's ok, I know
you meant well.

Alright, enough with the dead guy's last request, there's a lot
of thank you's I wanna say to you fellas??

-------------------------------------
David will be laid to rest in Arlington on Wednesday, December 15th at 10AM EST.

David's family and friends are trying to get help mobilizing radio
stations to play the song "American Soldier", dedicated to David, on
Wednesday December 15th at 1PM EST.

I would appreciate it if you could encourage your readers to call and
email radio stations to play Toby Keith's "American Soldier" -
dedicated to Specialist David Mahlenbrock - at 1PM EST on Wednesday
December 15th.

Thanks!

Blackfive

Sweet Warrior

Lance Corporal Kyle Renehan, the brother of Spencer Renehan (SadLonelyGeek) passed this morning of complications from his wounds. We pray for his family. *****************************************

Sweet Warrior

Come to me, sweet warrior.
Take me by the hand.
Follow me to quiet places
in a quiet land.
Sleep in fields of emerald
beside the quiet sea.
Feel the sun upon your face
and stay awhile with me.

I followed you to battle, son,
and helped to calm your fears,
and laughed with you in happy times
and brushed away your tears.
I shielded you with tender wings
when you were very small,
staying close across the miles
after duty's call.

Come to me, sweet warrior.
Take me by the hand.
Follow me to quiet places
in a quiet land.
Walk with those who came before
beside the quiet sea.
Feel the mists upon your face
and stay awhile with me.

Gone's the time of duty now,
your battle has been won,
and brothers wait to welcome you
beneath a rising sun.
Take my hand, we'll go to them
it's where you need to be,
a land of gentle warriors
each one, USMC.

Come to me, sweet warrior.
Take me by the hand.
Follow me to quiet places
in a quiet land.
Walk amongst your brothers here
beside the quiet sea.
Feel the warmth of heaven's grace
and stay awhile with me.

-Lila Meyer, Dec 9, 2004

For background information please see Beth’s post here or Bill Faith's here and work back.

Regards to Murphy

Glenn says (or links or quotes) everything I would have on the "Dumpster Diver" story.

No wait, here's more! The desired image the reporters on this issue want to evoke in your mind is one of American troops at the mercy of terrorists, going into a hail of bullets and rockets (think Fallujah) sans protection. That is the popular vision of Iraq in the media, even though that level of violence represents the situatiuon in a tiny part of this country. If combat is the destination of these troops, and if what the young man says is true, then somewhere someone didn't get the memo. That "someone" was not Don Rumsfeld, nor was it President Bush, who in fact wrote said memo. Who "someone" was should be found out. Believe it or not, between Congress and contractors and the Pentagon and delivery systems and grunts in the field there are some weak links in the military supply chain (stifle those gasps!) and that is as inevitable as it is inexcusable.

Yes, it would be satisfying to see some incompetent clown shown the door as a result of this episode, and that might happen, but the system is big beyond any single human's ability to control (yes - even the President of the United States!) the odds of anyone guilty being punished are about equal to the odds of some scapegoat getting the shaft. It's also likely that "someone" won't be found, because it's possible that "someone" doesn't exist.

Ignoring for now the slogan chanters and political partisans, there are a few key points to keep in mind. I will now try to explain to you why this whole situation seems dramatic to those outside looking in and complaining, and less so to those who are doing the best they can to fix the unfixable.

An anonymous quote worth knowing: "The U.S. military has always been perfectly trained and equipped to win the last war".

This painful truth was probably never more evident then in 1990-91 when virtually every piece of equipment in the inventory had to be re-painted from German forest green to a Saddam-inspired tan. The task was accomplished though, and U.S. forces made short work of what was until then the world's 5th largest army.

So for now, at least, enough of a shred of American "can-do" attitude and perseverance survives to ensure that the truism stated above remains only a minor inconvenience. As further evidence of our ability to improvise, adapt, and overcome, when 'bunker-busting' bombs were needed in the first Gulf War they went from drawing board to the desert in approximately 17 days, arriving "too hot to handle" by the waiting ground crews.

A bit of evidence to the contrary though, (or support to the "last war" theory), could be the current state of affairs in Iraq. Many argue that the military proved to be an irrestable invasion force (per 1991 doctrine) that was completely unprepared for the resulting chaotic lack of surviving government infrastructure and the insurgency that has been an often-deadly thorn in the side of progress here. But add that progress is now made in a political/military balancing act (see Fallujah, April through November) and few (none of sound mind) would fault the military completely for any shortfalls.

But here a second painful truth comes into play. "No plan survives first contact with the enemy." It's one of Murphy's Laws of Combat, though Mackubin Thomas Owens relates the actual origin of the phrase here, giving the original quote from Helmuth von Moltke, chief of the Prussian general staff some hundred-plus odd years ago. Von Moltke is often credited with the paraphrasing of his actual quote that is more commonly used today. But given this rule, it's often amusing to hear criticism of the Iraq conflict that includes the phrase "didn't have a plan..." for war, peace or otherwise.

By all means, lets make the supply system better, faster, and more flexible - but lets do so in a way that gets us ready to win the next war. But a caution to those who cry out urging the military to remake itself to fight the current Iraq war, whether by re-defining the role of the Guard/Reserve or other large-scale force structure efforts: Be certain you aren't demanding that the U.S. military strictly adhere to painful truth number one above. In other words, to start preparring now to win the conflict in Iraq - a conflict that will soon be winding down. (See Owen's piece, and imagine the current situation as paralleling the allied approach to the Rhine.)

On the other hand, to those who think that planning now to win the Iraq war is a problem, I offer painful truth number two, which just shows that painful truth number one doesn't matter.

As long as the paragraph about "can-do" attitude and perseverance above remains true. That, by the way, was the key point of the whole discussion. But you knew that when you read it, didn't you?

In the e-mail

Dear Greyhawk.

Sorry for the unsolicited blog recommendation. Strong and Free
Laurie Hawn is a friend of mine. He is a retired CF18 Hornet jockey and squadron commander (actually he was the first Canadian to qualify in a CF18), the former 2ic at CFB Cold Lake, and the Conservative candidate who came within 700 votes of defeating Deputy Prime Minister Anne McLellan in the last election.

He has considerable expertise in military affairs and Canadian politics, a flare with language, and an unlimited supply of relevant Churchill quotes. I think you will like his blog.

Lately he has written on:

And, they are surprised, why? On the Senate and military spending

Much Ado About Much Ado On the BMD

Parrish the Thoughtless

The Greatest Canadian?

Remembering On the personal meaning of Remembrance day.

What's in a 'Dis'? On the Canadian military

I think you will find him worth reading. He might even qualify for milblogs.

A regular reader.

Victor Marciano

Well, Victor Vitor Veetor, I'll have to agree and add that your site's worth a visit as well.

Out-Dumbed, by George!

Did you really believe we?re too stupid to see,
How you tried to deceive us with smug sophistry?

Did you actually think we?d accept without thinking,
That our ship of state?s hulled, our economy?s sinking?

We saw how with help from your media tools,
You picked just the right captain for your ship of fools.

With your Cambodian Admiral at the helm of your boat
You needed an ocean of lies just to keep him afloat.

You put forward no spokesman with a true honest voice
And offered the voters no acceptable choice.

Your party got ?jacked? by the loons on the left,
And the rest of you?ve yet to wake up to the theft.

You let billionaire bandits with a bolshevik whiff,
Take your ?Ride? for a drive that went straight off the cliff.

So, do you now blame your loss on these crazies and flakes?
Nope, by Jove, it was Rove, must?ve messed with the brakes.

Even now that you?ve lost, you refuse to accept,
That your party?s outdated and its leaders inept.

The election is over, and with your masquerades falling
The true you we see is truly appalling.

You?ve nothing but scorn for true faith and belief
Holding up Christianity as some election year thief.

Your apostasy?s clear to those blacks and hispanics,
Who, next time around, just may be your Titanics.

So now as you sit contemplating your fate,
Sipping modest chablis, camembé²´ on your plate,

Just remember your failure in sowing false fears,
And let this burn in your brains for four more long years:

Even owning the press and controlling the tube,
You got your butts whipped by an? ol? Texas rube.

So, keep pondering this ?til your brains are all numbed
Rove didn?t outsmart you; you were smartly out-dumbed

That?s gonna stick in your craws ?til you?re forced to disgorge,
All you smart liberal wienies just got out-dumbed, by George.

Russ Vaughn

Proud Red State Retard and former Democrat ?til they made me a political homeless person and the Republicans offered shelter.

The poem above was inpired by the rereading of this letter I sent to the editor of the San Antonio Express-News back during the election, and which, to my utter amazement, they published:

Out-Dumbing the Dems

Good heavens, may wonders never cease! I just read a Jan Jarboe (South Texas Ultralib) column and found myself agreeing with her. Her advice to Democrats that George Bush is not the dummy they think he is reminds me of a good ol? boy from South Alabama who once worked for me. We were making a product presentation to a military procurement officer who was extremely full of himself and patronizing to us as civilian marketers, talking down to us as if we were entirely ignorant of the system. Offended by his condescension, I thought of explaining that we were intimately familiar with the proper procedures but then thought better of it. It was, after all, my salesman?s account, so I should let him handle it.

For thirty minutes he sat there in wide-eyed awe, hanging on to every word of this pompous buffoon?s detailed explication of military procurement, interrupting with only an occasional, ?Wow,? or ?Gee, so that?s how it?s done.? Knowing my guy was a senior Reserve Navy officer and intimately familiar with this whole process I just sat there and bit my tongue.

When we finally got out in the parking lot, with an order even larger than we had sought, I said, ?Jim, why on earth did you put up with that blowhard, like that?? To which he winked, waved the order forms and drawled,

?Hey, Boss, sometimes you just gotta out-dumb ?em.?

Ain?t it the truth? Just ask Ann Richards. Or Al Gore. (And now John Kerry.)

Russ Vaughn

P.S.
Liberal Democrats love chants; so I have a brand spanking new one for them: Two! Four! Six! Eight! Never Misunderestimate!

Left Behind

It seems a few lefty types thought they'd struck upon a fine idea: create a blog, then email a bunch of center/right bloggers to attempt to bring the crowds to their site. I especially enjoyed this post there:

Vehicles in New Jersey are covered with decals representing little ribbons inscribed with the legend: ?Support Our Troops.? I have done a lot of driving recently and have noticed geographical disparities in the distribution of these symbols. There are fewer in the Midwest and very few at all in the LA area. They are also disproportionately displayed on SUVs and vans, which isn?t surprising given that the owners are disproportionately reliant on the oil supplies that our soldiers are in Iraq to protect (among their other purposes).

What is it exactly that these decals exhort us to do? How can I, or anyone, support the troops themselves? What can we possibly do for them? It seems that the message is really an exhortation to support the war.

...since it sums up so nicely the vacant American Left position on virtually everything. "I'm not aware of something, therefore it doesn't exist. Discovery is beyond my capability."

Of course, the authors solicited links, as I said, so there is a small possibility that the post reflects nothing of the author's mindset and is merely designed to draw comments. If so it did quite well, with over 100 as of now, including an early one that's a fine take down from Joe Katzman of Winds of Change, who saved me much effort.

Joe's comment begins "Hmm. Just got an email from Left2Right" and goes on to exceed the quality of anything else written on the site. (Except maybe the Dean Esmay comment a little further down) But those so inclined can read the original post and all the comments for some insight to the current mind of the left regarding "support the troops".

It all just brings to mind the lack of lefty support for anysoldier.com, in spite of Michael Moore encouragement that I documented here, or the complete absence of lefty blogs from any of the SoA challenge teams or individuals found here. (To be clear, SoA, of course, helps in the rebuilding of Iraq - so I suppose lefty support of that effort is out of the question too.)

Read as much of the whole thing as you can stand.

I expect these same folks might drop a few spare quarters into the hat for Jeremy Hinzman, but When it comes to "support" from the left, as with so many other things, the lights are on but nobody's home.

Welcome Home

A Soldier's Life After Iraq is actually A Blog by the wife of a Senior Airman in the Air Force Reserves, who returned last April from a rotation at Balad Air Base in Iraq

Just after the attacks on Sept 11th, Eric (my hubby), was eagerly anticipating a phone call from the USMC for a recall. He was finishing up his 4 yrs of inactive reserves. When a few weeks went by and no call came he started calling recruiters wanting to know if and when he would be called up. The said he probably wouldnt be. Then he wanted to reinlist in the marines for another 4 yrs. (he really wanted to go kick some osama butt) After discussing it with me, I of course caved and ok'd it. He went down to the recruters office and after weeks of waiting and paperwork processing etc they recruiter finally told him basically "look we have so many new recruits already; for the marines to take you back you would have to drop rank" Eric was pretty upset about that.

Then he saw a commercial on the tv for the air force. He called them and they were very excited and interested to have him being a marine and all. He could keep his rank and they even gave him a sign on bonus! No disrespect to the marines we still love them, but they can be bull headed. The reserves allowed him to serve the country he loves "one weekend a month two weeks a year". while he still would have preferred active duty the closest base to us was only a reserve base (without uprooting the whole family and moving) that is what he chose.

After two years and no deployments I was pretty comfortable with the situation.

Then two weeks before thanksgiving he was told to make ready and given a 3 page list of items to go out and purchase.

Skipping forward a bit, this from the blog's description:

Soldier returns from serving in Balad Iraq, only to be fired from his civilian employer because of his military duties. Shortly after, while on orders to fort gordon his leg is broken requiring a rod, plate and 6 screws to put back together. Line of duty orders are cancelled due to technicality, eliminating families income. Stop/Loss furthers family heartache as soldier gets ready to deploy agian shortly.

Anyone hiring OIF vets in Georgia? More here.

Atrocities in Toronto

Mudville readers were first introduced to U.S. Army deserter Jeremy Hinzman here last February Hinzman, an active duty soldier, fled his post rather than deploy to Iraq.

Michelle Malkin offers an update:

But there is a Michael Moore-sized distinction between Hinzman and the thousands of ?resisters? who fled to Canada during the Vietnam War. Unlike the American draft dodgers who crossed the northern border more than three decades ago, Hinzman volunteered for military service in January 2001. He joined of his own free will. Nobody forced him to go to the recruitment office. Nobody dragged him to Fort Bragg.

He happily cashed in his Army paychecks until deployment to Afghanistan was imminent. After his application for conscientious-objector status was rejected, he grudgingly finished his stint in Afghanistan, declared opposition to the coming war in Iraq, packed up his wife and infant son, and waltzed into the open arms of Toronto's radical leftists.

It's been one big pacifist kumbayah ever since -- a dazzling procession of campus tributes, rock-star galas, and international media martyrdom. And when he's not on his tour of self-promotional duty, Hinzman and his wife (a feminist social worker who has also applied for asylum in Canada) are savoring the good life in their newly adopted home. Hinzman reports on his own snazzy Web site:

In the mornings, we usually take (son) Liam to various playgroups in our neighborhood. In the afternoon, we alternate which one of us cooks dinner. I also try to go for a run while Liam naps. In the evening we play with our son and often go to various parts of Toronto and 'people watch' to get Liam out of the house. After he goes to sleep for the night, I try to read or Nga (Hinzman's wife) and I watch a movie or do various other things. A great deal of this routine, or lack thereof, will probably soon change after I get a work permit and find some sort of employment.

Hinzman is enjoying his domestic tranquility on the backs of each and every American military man and woman who is living up to his or her commitment to uphold a sworn oath of duty. Hinzman and his lawyer plan to argue to Canadian immigration officials that American soldiers are guilty of war crimes and that forcing Hinzman to fight in Iraq would have likely made him a war criminal. Among the witnesses testifying on Hinzman's behalf is former U.S. Marine Staff Sgt. Jimmy Massey, the Winter Soldier of the 21st century, who claims his platoon killed ?a bunch of innocent civilians.? Massey has been making the rounds in the French media and other America-hating swamps.

Talk about an understatement! The Washington Post details Massey's testimony in a report headlined Former Marine Testifies To Atrocities In Iraq. Bear in mind as you read this that Massey and Hinzman are from separate branches of service, and Massey's testimony is just to establish the "fact" that Hinzman would have been compelled to commit the same sort of acts Massey claims he himself did.

TORONTO, Dec. 7 -- A former U.S. Marine staff sergeant testified at a hearing Tuesday that his unit killed at least 30 unarmed civilians in Iraq during the war in 2003 and that Marines routinely shot and killed wounded Iraqis.

Jimmy J. Massey, a 12-year veteran, said he left Iraq in May 2003 after a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress. He said he and his men shot and killed four Iraqis staging a demonstration and a man with his hands up trying to surrender, as well as women and children at roadblocks. Massey said he had complained to his superiors about the "killing of innocent civilians," but that nothing was done.

Massey, 33, of Waynesville, N.C., was the chief witness at a refugee board hearing for a U.S. Army deserter, Jeremy Hinzman, who is attempting to win asylum in Canada after he fled from Fort Bragg, N.C., rather than go to Iraq. Hinzman, 25, the first of at least three U.S. military deserters to apply for asylum here, argues that he refused to go to Iraq to avoid committing war crimes.

In Washington, a Marine Corps spokesman at the Pentagon said Massey's charges had been investigated and were unproved.

"We take such allegations very seriously," said Maj. Douglas Powell. "And Jimmy Massey, who is a former staff sergeant, out of the Corps, has made these statements before in the press. They've been looked into, and nothing has been substantiated."

<...>

During one 48-hour period, Massey said under oath, his platoon set up roadblocks and killed "30-plus" civilians. He said his men, fearing suicide bombers, poured massive firepower into cars that did not stop as they approached the roadblocks. In each instance, he said, none of the cars was found to have contained explosives or arms.

"Why didn't the Iraqis stop? That is something that has plagued me every waking moment of the day," he said. He said they may have been confused by the Americans' gestures or thought that a warning shot was celebratory gunfire.

"I don't know if the Iraqi people thought we were celebrating their newfound freedom. But I do know we killed innocent civilians," Massey said. In one case, the driver of a car leaped out with his hands up. "But we kept firing. We killed him," Massey said. In another case, he and other Marines shot and killed four protesters near a checkpoint after a single incoming gunshot from an unknown source, he said. None of the protesters was found with arms.

Then this fact near the bottom of the story (emphasis added):

The government won a ruling that the legality of the Iraq war could not be an issue at the refugee hearing. But Hinzman's attorney, Jeffry House, has introduced testimonials and human rights reports to support Hinzman's claim that he would have been forced to violate the Geneva Conventions in Iraq.

Some of Hinzman's supporters, including House, are Vietnam-era draft dodgers. They compare Massey's testimony to the disclosure of the My Lai massacre of civilians in Vietnam.

I Went to Iraq, and Made a Pile of Money!

But it's mostly this stuff you see pictured to the left. (If you're like me you accumulate a ton of change while traveling anyway - I don't know why that is. Maybe I just notice it more since I have to take it with me through airport metal detectors.) These, however, are what the Army and Air Force Exchange Service (AAFES) gives you instead of metal coins at forward deployed locations. They're called "gift certificates" - but they're the smallest such denominations you'll ever see, with 5, 10 and 25 cent versions. They're cardboard pogs, and I don't keep them in my pocket because they'd just get destroyed, so the damn things just accumulate on my desk.

We recently had a visit from this group - a funny bunch of guys who lifted the spirits of all those present. Comedian Tom Irwin had already worked the coins into his routine. Something like this: "I went into the Exchange, bought something, and for change they gave me this. (Holds up pogs) What the hell is this? 'That's money' they told me. 'You can spend it at all AAFES locations.' So the next time I bought something I wrote "5 dollars" on a piece of cardboard and handed it to the cashier. 'Keep the change' I said."

But anyhow - the 'coins' do make sense, they're lighter and thinner than U.S. coins and therefore easier to transport in bulk. And in a place where transport is among the most dangerous activities you can engage in, that matters. But like I said, for the individual GI these things just tend to accumulate during the tour.

So the bottom line is I need to get rid of these future collector's items. So like a dutiful husband I'm sending this money home to the wife. Like a typical wife she's going to spend it, and here's how. Anyone who donates to Spirit of America via clicking the link below, then e-mails her (greyhawk@mudvillegazette.com) proof of said donation and a mailing address will be sent some of the Greyhawk fortune. Minimum 20 dollar donation to SoA to qualify, and offer expires when supplies are exhausted. Already donated via the link? By all means, send your request to Mrs G. Allow a few weeks for delivery, offer void where prohibited, etc etc etc.

Footnote: Besides Tom we were entertained by James P. Connolly, Warren B. Hall, & Tony Daro - thanks to all of them for being here. Hoo-ah.

2004 Weblog Awards

We're not just in the Military Blog category! There are MilBloggers hidden throughout the 2004 Weblog Awards. And here is where you'll find them:

EagleSpeak in the 6750+ category.

Geek Empire and Chapomatic in the 3500 - 5000 category.

The Common Virtue in the 1000-1750 category (Man down! Get there, stat!)

Brain Fertilizer and Froggy in the 500-1000 category.

Serenity's Journal and Ipse Dixit in the 100-250 category.
And...

The Mudville Gazette and The Evangelical Outpost in the Top 100 category.