 |  |
 
March 2010
February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009 February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008 August 2008 July 2008 June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007 August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 December 2003 November 2003 October 2003 September 2003 August 2003 July 2003 June 2003 May 2003 April 2003 March 2003 February 2003 January 2003
     |
 Greetings! You are reading an article from The Mudville Gazette. To reach the front page, with all the latest news and views, click the logo above or "main" below. Thanks for stopping by! August 31, 2006 Heroes 101By GreyhawkOver at Milblogs, John of Argghhh directs us to the newly named Paul Ray Smith Middle School. Here (until the front page changes - sorry, no permalinks) is the original news story (and photos) from the 3ID's (The Division Smith served with in Iraq) web page. Here's the school's homepage. (Mascot: Eagles, chosen by the student body. Should have been the Bulldogs, but that's okay...) Here are the google news results for Paul Smith Middle School- the only four news sites to cover the story are military-based. Hard to break into the mainstream media during Jon Benet week, I guess. But earlier this month the New York Times did run an op-ed bemoaning the lack of Medals of Honor given for Iraq and Afghanistan. While I agree completely with the sentiment, I was a bit surprised to see it expressed in that particular venue. But the following two paragraphs leave no doubt as to why the topic of American war heroes might get more attention in the mainstream media: For reasons I can’t fathom, the Pentagon top brass don’t feel that our heroes in Iraq and Afghanistan are especially meritorious. President Bush has yet to award a single Medal of Honor to a living veteran of combat in either place. (Only one has been given posthumously.)"We aren't reporting on heroes - because of Bush!!!" There are other Medals being processed, of course, and it would suit me fine if this sort of thing accelerates the process. But no doubt after that the New York Times would pretty much ignore them too. Posted by Greyhawk / August 31, 2006 2:32 AM | Permalink 24 TrackBacksFree speech saved versus evil Nazi Bushies! ...Hugo and Mahmoud sitting in a tree, k-i-s-s-i-n-g... Mexico or China: the bigger threat? Plus all the News you need, the way you want it... Read More Have you ever had a day, a week, a month, or an entire school year when you thought it would be appropriate for your students, colleagues, or administrators to form the cast of a Broadway play or musical? Do you sometimes find yourself in melodramati... Read More …Profiling that is. As a general rule I believe that profiling is a great deterrent in preventing crime and catching criminals, looking out for the tell-tell signs of a drug runner up Interstate 95 results in a lot of drugs being taken off the ..... Read More I have been reading Dawn Over Baghdad - how the U.S. military is using bullets and ballots to remake Iraq. It is written by the editor in chief of The American Enterprise and as such I figure it comes as Read More Keith Olbermann had one of the most beautifully spoken commentaries I have every heard - about Donald Rumsfeld's recent speech. You can see it here on YouTube. Every word is true and point on. As Lincoln said (paraphrasing), the only Read More Two years after the Beslan school massacre in Russia, where over 150 children were killed by Muslim terrorists, there is a gripping article in Esquire magazine about what happened inside the school. If you choose to read it, the article will give yo... Read More There is another vacancy that I think Chavez is more qualified to hold… Saddam Husseins seat in the Axis of Evil Read More Mr. Robert Stokely father of Sgt. Mike Stokely KIA 08/16/2005 needs our help, not in building a tribute to his son, but rather to help honor the memory of another fallen hero, that being SFC Bobby Hollar. He writes: "I have been working with Mar .... Read More Following the Saddam regime collapse a power vacuum followed in which we have never been able to fully compensate for. I firmly believe that quiting will be far more disastrous for us as a nation and for the world as a whole. Therefore we need the comm... Read More I recently wrote the post I support the troops, I do not support the war. In this post I will try to answer the objections made in the comments and trackbacks to that initial post. If there are trackbacks and/or Read More Eco-Leftists have expressed outrage today over the lack of attention being paid to the stingray's feelings following the death of 'Crocodile Hunter" Steve Irwin. While applauding the attack as a "victory for nature over evil human exploitation of ... Read More I have no Idea if this report is accurate or of the credibility of the Daily Mail’s source on this. The US could not have had a better Ally in the War on Terror than Tony Blair and I firmly believe that Britain will remain just as staunch an Ally. Read More Today's winner is The New Republic magazine, arguably America's leading liberal opinion journal. Read More . . . a fresh and compelling video of the events of September 11 using home-video and the audio of emergency calls made that morning. Read More Today's winner is Congressman John Sweeney R-NY. Read More This is truly disgusting, and it's another reason why the UN needs to be disbanded: Read More History cannot be sugar-coated in order to appease individual groups. Facts are facts and the facts about 9-11 are that 19 Islamic extremists executedan attack on this country that murdered nearly 3,000 innocent people. If CAIR or any other Islamic org... Read More Today's winner is Palm Beach County Commissioner Tony Masilotti. Read More I discovered that Slate's presenting The 9/11 Report: A Graphic Adaptation online, and decided to take a look at the finished product, as can everyone else, and be the judge. It's a presentation that's at least 106 pages long, and may still be update... Read More Some fifteen million men of military age were called to arms in the US armed forces during the war. Frank,refused to be left out of the struggle. He begged the draft board to take him. He couldn’t bear to see friends head of to war while he remain... Read More Today's winner is Palm Beach County School's Chief Financial Officer Joe Moore. Read More George LopezWorld Trade CenterSeptember 11, 2001 I never met George Lopez, so when I agreed to write a memorial for one of the victims of 9/11 I never contemplated how difficult it might actually be, I just knew it was something that had to be do ..... Read More da da de da de da Its my birthday to you know. Yeah, thats how the song goes...and its for real. Today is my birthday, and because I'm now cooking for a party I didn't know I was having, there will be no blogging 'til tomorrow afternoon at the ..... Read More The EU takes another step in allowing Iran and the Mad Mullahs to have nuclear weapons. The UNSC voted 14-1 in July to demand Iran cease its Uranium enrichment & other programs leading to nuclear weapons, and the US and other countries offered a series... Read More 26 Comments |
March 17, 2010Dawn Patrol 03/17/2010 [Mrs Greyhawk]
Welcome to the Dawn Patrol, our daily roundup of information on the War on Terror and other topics - from the MilBlogs and various sources around the world. If you're a blogger, you can join the conversation. If you link to any of these stories, add a link to the Dawn Patrol too and your trackback will be added to the list. Hat Tips to the Dawn Patrol are greatly appreciated.Refresh for updates.
AFGHANISTANSuicide attackers killed in Afghanistan -- [CNN] US kills 8 terrorists in 2 new airstrikes in North Waziristan -- [LWJ - Bill Roggio] S.N.A.B.U. = Situation Normal All BAF-fed Up -- [Afghanistan My Last Tour - in Afghanistan] Post Office Doesn't Like Me -- [Afghanistan My Last Tour - in Afghanistan] Danger Room Explainer: Outsourced Intel in Afghanistan -- [Danger Room] IRAQIraq Votes - Part VI -- [MEMRI] Mission Accomplished: Astroturfing Baghdad -- [Danger Room]
U.S. AND OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLDAllies everywhere feeling snubbed by President Obama -- [Washington Post] Chahar-Shanbeh Souri -- [Planet Iran]
WAR ON TERROR /TERRORISMIf bin Laden is found, he'll be killed, Holder says -- [AP] ACLU files lawsuit for information on US Predator program -- [Threat Matrix] SUPPORTING THE TROOPSArmy Suicides Grow, but This Soldier Was Saved -- [Politics Daily] Silver Star Winner Reprimanded for Afghan Battle -- [ABC]
MILITARYArrrrrrmy Training, SIR! -- [This Ain't Hell] WELCOME HOMEBushrod honors were not misplaced -- [Fredericksburg.com] They're Coming Home! -- [KBND]
THE MEDIA/CULTUREIt's just some ribbon. -- [From my Position...]
POLITICSGE and Ronald Reagan: The Mutual Gift That Keeps On Giving -- [Politics Daily] Petraeus Testifies About DADT
The Petraeus briefing: Biden's embarrassment is not the whole story -- [Foreign Policy Blog] HUMOR/SATIRE
Iraq, Afghanistan, War, Terrorism, Military, Politics, Media, MilBlogs, dawn patrol Mudville
|
The Mudville Gazette is the on-line voice of an American warrior and his wife who stands by him. They prefer to see peaceful change render force of arms unnecessary. Until that day they stand fast with those who struggle for freedom, strike for reason, and pray for a better tomorrow.
 
 
 I like having visitors to my house. I hope you are entertained. I fight for your right to free speech, and am thrilled when you exercise said rights here. Comments and e-mails are welcome, but all such communication is to be assumed to be 1)the original work of any who initiate said communication and 2)the property of the Mudville Gazette, with free use granted thereto for publication in electronic or written form. If you do NOT wish to have your message posted, write "CONFIDENTIAL" in the subject line of your email. Original content copyright © 2003 - 2009 by Greyhawk. Fair, not-for-profit use of said material by others is encouraged, as long as acknowledgement and credit is given, to include the url of the original source post. Other arrangements can be made as needed. Contact: greyhawk at mudvillegazette dot com  |
- via email, facebook, twitter, etc.
The press could do more to publicize some of our heroes, and Captain Chontosh and others may well be a legitimate candidate for a MOH, but I don't see a lack of these awards as necessarily a bad thing. What gets missed is that individual acts of heroism aren't planned for; which is to say that by the time a soldier, sailor, or airman is in a position to earn his or her moh, the odds are good that someone at a higher command level screwed up. Our military is much better run than it was during Vietnam and it may be that we aren't putting soldiers in so many impossible situations as back then.
Also, while I have tremendous respect for our servicemen who sack up every day in Iraq, I think that a lot of the danger they face is random. There is zero opportunity to earn a MOH when you're fighting against an IED. There is little opportunity to react.
Another point is that while it can be argued that MOH's have been handed out stingily, the same is not true of lesser awards; I've been reading about bronze stars handed out somewhat shamelessly.
And maybe someone here has a better handle on this, but how do the ratio of awards handed out in Iraq compare with the ratio of WWII?
regards,
f
Greyhawk:
Just wanted to inform you readers on another story about the Paul Ray Smith Middle School. http://www.defenselink.mil/News/NewsArticle.aspx?id=637
It's interesting. I was just sitting down with a former Navy co-worker and we were talking about medals and the MOH and whatnot. He noted that I have five ribbons already, after having been in the USAR for about 3.5 years. He said that his whole time in the USN in the 1980's he only got ONE RIBBON. My father noted the same thing, in that he was USAFR from 1966 to 1972 and he had just the single ribbon as well. It's like nowadays they give out TONS of lower and middle importance ribbons, but are loathe to hand out the top stuff; specifically the MOH.
We've arguably seen ferocious fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan. The likes of which we've probably not seen since Vietnam. Is it that nobody is putting anybody in for the MOH, or is it that the brass are refusing to grant the award, thus downgrading the MOH to DSC or some such?
It's disturbing to me, as a civilian reluctantly looking on from the outside, that valor and selflessness are not be recognized sufficiently. From the anti-Bush and utopian media I expect no different, but why not from the Administration and military??? This seems part of a pattern, that I think is very ill-advised, of trying to satisfy the anti-Bushies and the utopians in some half-assed way. Any such concessions will NEVER satisfy them (they are borderline insane) and will only harm the cause of national unity and demoralize our men and women on the front lines.
D. Ox
Hello,
This is a great blog. I'm going to be sure to link yours to mine. Would you mind doing the same for me?
Thank you very much.
My site:
www.americanlegends.blogspot.com
Take care,
Mark
Actually the number of medals awarded has been quite high. By 2004 the Army aone had awarded 111 Silver Stars andover 13,000 Bronze Stars. Many if not most of those Bronze Stars were given for "service" not for valor, in other words for just generally doing a good job. The Marines on the other hand had only awarded 200 Bronze Stars at that point. But plenty of Heroes are out there: SFC Paul Smith, Sgt Leigh Ann Hester, Marine Lt. Jeffre Lee, and hundreds of others.
Also while the President ulimately chooses who gets "The Medal", it is soldiers' unit leaders who recommend them for awards.
Ultimately, the Times excuse is self serving as Rumsfeld pointed out, they are an intellectually and morally confused entity, who wold rather report a few cases of sensationalized misconduct then any of the thousands of cases of valor by US forces.
Hi Mr. and Mrs. Greyhawk. I have some bad news to report, off topic of course. There has been an attack on one of our own in Washington. I found this story over at Little Green Footballs. The name of the article is National Guardsman Brutally Attacked. Let us get them so he can have some justice. Also, let us put a stop to this before it becomes 'fashionable'.
Sorry I couldn't bring good news this time. I will look for some...
Latest Navy Cross going to Petty Officer 2nd Class Matthew G. Axelson
http://northshorejournal.org/index.php/2006/08/petty-officer-2nd-class-matthew-g-axelson
If I recall correctly, there is only one medal out there that does not require recomendation. That is the PH. It's often abused, but only the recipient knows the real truth. I'm totally baffled why folks would whine about not enough MOH's being handed out. Don't they have a clue what what that honor really represents?
I'm mad as hell. Has nothing to do with the article above but I read a post on this site about the "cool school" on milblog. It touched me and I posted the story on my hometown newspaper because they have a comment seciton at the bottom of their articles. Well today, I was reading the paper and the first story I saw was a piece "bragging" that middle school kids can avoid recruitment efforts. I reposted the story about the brave Sergeant First Class Paul R. Smith. Please honor his memory by posting your comments here
www.sj-r.com/sections/news/stories/94776.asp
Thanks folks.
Folks,
Is it just me that sees this type of thing as just another attempt to find some kind of fault as well as a symptom of the writers lack of knowledge about the way decorations are awarded. I'm a civilian but even I know that George Bush doesn't just randomly dool out medals to troops.
Furthermore, as a previous commentor said how doe you get a MOH against an IED or a VBIED? I agree there have been plenty of circumstances where the MOH may have been appropriatly especially during the assault on Fallujah but sometimes the situation or the circumstances if you will aren't condusive.
Anyway, it's a not a "number of medals" game; they're not a scorecard.
Paul
(Folks stop by our site http://www.techography.com I really could use the feedback)
My son was in SFC Smith's company during the war. Remember, there is a long vetting process to award the medal and, although there were many more during Vietnam, I wonder how many years it took for the total to be reached. Also, having been AD during that time, I would suggest to that there was a bit of award inflation during those years.
The fact that some of the commenters brought up IEDs as the reason more medals for valor are not being awarded demonstrates the problem. The American public has no idea what is going on in Iraq. Your Marines. soldiers and sailors have been engaging in fierce, tranditional combat, in some instances hand to hand combat, taking the fight to the enemy, and acquiting themselves with valor and distinction. If you think they are just sitting around, waiting for the next IED to blow up, you need to do some further reading to find out what is really going on. Just don't look to the MSM for that.
One problem may be the Hillary Generals who have not yet been washed out of the system, who denigrate the concept of personal heroism. Soon they will no longer be in a position to affect the process.
"Hillary Generals". Oh, Please! Now its the democrats fault that Bush is not giving out medals!. Come on!
I suspect the media doesn't play up the "heroes" for two reasons:
1. When you're losing a war, demand for hero stories isn't very strong.
2. The Bush administration lied about two other "heroes," Jessica Lynch and Pat Tillman. Twice burned, thrice shy.
WW ... over in this comment thread at Blackfive, Tom W. says it best.
If you follow the course of events in Iraq from 2003, the insurgency hasn't been able to stop a single step in the Coalition plan. Our troops have faced the worst that Islamic so-called warriors have to offer, and they haven't blinked.
Maybe slowed down a litle ... but not stopped. We are winning, despite your "service" as Liar-in-Chief to tell us otherwise.
The only way we lose, is if we leave before the job is done ... just like in any war we have fought, be it WWII or Vietnam. And, if we stay, it will get done, as long as we have leaders, like our current President, who will act decisively at crunch time ...
... and people like Greyhawk, Blackfive, SMASH, and Subsunk (along with ordinary commenters like myself) who will ALWAYS be here to refute the Big Lies of Liars-in-Chief like you, WW.
None of us are going away.
Deal with it.
It is the fault of men who got their stars by sucking up to a military hating White House, guys like Wesson Oil Clark and Collin Powell.
Proclaim someone a hero and the iconoclasts go to work. I still don'tunderstand why Tilman suddenly ceased to be a hero when it turns out his death was by friendly fire. Fucking Feather Merchants!
Funny thing about that Wesson Oil Clark. He won. Apparently you people just HATE victory, don't you? Rich, where do you buy your mushrooms?
By the way, even your fire-breathing neo-con masters are now having their doubts about your Liar in Chief's war. And did you see that the Republican-controlled Senate Intelligence Committee just refuted your Liar in Chief's lie about Saddam and al-Qaeda? Looks you dumbsh!ts will be last to know.
Dub-Dub -- still strainin' at gnats, as usual, instead of acknowledging the good and the bad, as it really exists.
There are still troops in Kosovo ... so by your apparent standards, NATO hasn't won that war yet, either ...
... and BTW, Wesley Clark didn't take the war to a decisive conclusion against its intended target. Milosovec was finally removed from power by his own people in 2001, two years after the American air war ended. We nabbed Saddam faster than that ... and he was in hiding, unlike Milosovec!
Oh, and here's another "connection" for ya ... and yes, it's that simple.
Methinks the Senate report you're crowing about will be reduced to a status just above one of your posts here before too long. We already knew the ties between Saddam and AQ were only casual at best ... the question was whether they would stay that way -- and given AQ's willingness to make common cause with the Baathist dead-enders once we went in there, that was a real good question!
In the meantime ... Iraq takes control of its miliary ... and ABC is airing a docudrama that calls many more whose INACTION led to 911 to account.
In that light, your crowing about this report is reiminiscent of the bluster of the Magnificent Oz ... "pay no attention to the (progress) behind the curtain."
Well said, Rich. Well said.
WWI and WWII were won by men with steeled resolve. Our military men and women and military leaders have that same resolve to lead us to victory as well. And the resolve of the milbloggers and those of us fighting the propaganda war on the homefront will support them 100%.
When exactly did Pat Tillman cease to be a hero, I don't believe I got that memo. Every man and woman that serves the country is a hero. Do you really need somebody to tell you who is or is not a hero? Or is having an original thought a completely foreign concept for you?
Pinger isn't cooperating with me on trackbacks. My post for the 2,996 project is here: http://homefrontsix.blogspot.com/2006/09/father-mychal-judge-00001.html
Good to see you back and posting! Missed ya!
Every man and woman that serves the country is a hero.
Funny, the Romans debased their currency, too.
Hey think this one will turn out to be "hero" too? Better stay tuned, wingnuts!
http://tinyurl.com/pbbby